Minds in Communion - 14

Immaterial information

I begin this series of blogs quoting from an article by Kyle Butt, M.Div., entitled “Immaterial Information” (https://apologeticspress.org/immaterial-information-14571/)

Butt cites The American Heritage dictionary that defines materialism as, “The theory that physical matter is the only reality and that everything, including thought, feeling, mind, and will, can be explained in terms of matter and physical phenomena.” Evolutionist Paul Davies wrote, ‘The materialist believes that mental states and operation are nothing but physical states and operations.’ . . . In short, there is an idea prevalent among those who believe in evolution that matter is the only ‘real’ thing that exists. If it is not material or physical, then it is not a part of the Universe, and is either non-existent or unimportant.

“The fundamental flaw with this particular theory is the fact that it can be proven that some things do exist which are not material. Among the most obvious of those is information.”

Immaterial information, 2

I continue citing Kyle Butt:

“Information is not material or physical. It is something that can be transferred via material media like pen, ink, voice, sand, air, etc. [It can also be transferred/transmitted via semaphore, the genetic code, telegraph, the neural code.] But its substance is something completely different from the medium used to convey the message. Millions of processes everyday deal strictly with information. From DNA to desktop computers, multiplied millions of processes focus primarily on information. This information can be transferred, translated, decoded, and encoded into a host of different physical media without ever altering the actual information.

“So what does this mean? If information is not material, and information does exist, then some things that are not material do exist. One of those immaterial beings is God. The Bible says that God is Spirit (John 4:24). He is the great Knower, the master Giver of information, Who sustains all things by ‘the word of His power’ (Hebrews 1:3).” [And I would add that God is the Ultimate Source of all information that has been instantiated in His creations.]

Existence of the immaterial

Greg Koukl composed an article in 2013 entitled “How to Know Immaterial Things Exist?” In my latest blog posts I have shown that there is reality in the immaterial. This point is vital to an understanding and acceptance of dualist interactionism. We have seen that information is a reality in and of itself, distinct from matter and energy. It is immaterial and consists of structure, purpose and meaning. It also has a statistical component, all of these aspects having been addressed in earlier blogs as well as in my books.

Koukl comments on the content of the mind:

“When you gaze, as it were, on the content of your mind so that you know what it is you are thinking, is the thing that you’re aware of neurons, brain tissue, and electrical impulses? No. The things you’re aware of are your own thoughts. Maybe there are electrical impulses that are happening when you’re thinking, and it may be that they’re always accompanied with the thoughts, but that isn’t how you know your own thoughts. You can just tell by reflecting, if you will, upon your thoughts themselves that you are not gazing upon something that has chemical properties. Thoughts have propositional qualities. They are not governed by the laws of physics, yet your brain chemistry is. They must be something different. . . . Can we employ some of those same ways of knowing that we know immaterial things to other issues, like the existence of God or souls or morality? I think the answer to that is yes. There is no good reason to believe that we cannot have confident knowledge about facts of the immaterial world. If we simply, by default, assert that we can’t know those things, then what Christians are doing is asserting a materialist worldview that is not only inconsistent with Christianity, but I think inconsistent with our basic perception of reality. . . . the rejection of the idea of certitude about spiritual things is not well grounded.”

I close this post paraphrasing Mortimer Adler who stated that we need our brains to think, but we do not think with our brains.

Jesus, high priest of the New Covenant

In Hebrews 7-10 Jesus Christ is identified as the high priest of the New Covenant, a priest in the order of Melchizedek. The author explains how the New Covenant came to be and its significance for the eternal salvation of repentant believers. I recommend this Scripture to you to obtain a much fuller understanding of the New Covenant given to mankind by the love and grace of God the Father through the atoning sin sacrifice of His Son, Jesus Christ, raised to life by the Spirit as our eternal priest. I have made reference to these verses in my second book, The Boundless Love of God: A Holy Spirit Story.

My next blogs will address the New Covenant in Hebrews by which the indwelling of the Holy Spirit has been restored to repentant believers, making a personal communion between the Holy Spirit and the human spirit and soul the reality desired by our Creator God since His creation of Man.

I introduce this series of blogs with a quotation from the third chapter of my book, Section 3:3 Restoration of Communion by God’s Grace:

“We look to Athanasius to confirm the reality of salvation offered to fallen mankind through Jesus Christ. Athanasius is regarded as the Father of Christian Orthodoxy, and he championed the ‘view that the Spirit of God is a fully divine person like the Father and the Son.’ Athanasius ‘focused on how the identity of Christ in the incarnation made it possible for him to accomplish salvation. Being both God and man he could represent both parties and reconcile them through redemption . . . . the logic of New Testament doctrine on salvation assumed a divine-human Christ.’ His biblical argument was that only God can save people from their sin. Jesus Christ saves people from their sin. Therefore, Jesus Christ is God incarnate. No human creature can save another creature; thus it was vital to salvation that Jesus Christ was the God-Man. God’s only begotten Son is our Savior and our redeemer by the shedding of his blood.”

I cite Article 20, Belgic Confession: The Justice and Mercy of God in Christ:

We believe that God - who is perfectly merciful and also very just - sent the Son to assume the nature in which the disobedience had been committed, in order to bear it in the punishment of sin by his most bitter passion and death. So God made known his justice by his Son, who was charged with our sin, and he poured out his goodness and mercy on us, who are guilty and worthy of damnation, giving to us his Son to die, by a most perfect love, and raising him to life for our justification, in order that by him we might have immortality and eternal life.

“Oh, how boundless is our Father’s love for us!”

The way into the Most Holy Place

In Hebrews 9 we read that only once a year the high priest entered the inner room, the Most Holy Place, of the tabernacle and never without a blood sacrifice. In verses 8-9 it reads, “The Holy Spirit was showing by this that the way into the Most Holy Place had not yet been disclosed as long as the first tabernacle was still standing. This is an illustration for the present time, indicating that the gifts and sacrifices being offered were not able to clear the conscience of the worshipper.”

In the next section, “The Blood of Christ,” verses 11-12; 14-15 read, “When Christ came as high priest of the good things that are already here, he went through the greater and more perfect tabernacle that is not man-made, that is to say, not a part of this creation. He did not enter by means of the blood of goats and calves; but he entered the Most Holy Place once for all by his own blood, having obtained eternal redemption. . . . How much more, then, will the blood of Christ, who through the eternal Spirit offered himself unblemished to God, cleanse our consciences from acts that led to death, so that we may serve the living God! For this reason Christ is the mediator of a new covenant, that those who are called may receive the promised eternal inheritance - now that he has died as a ransom to set them free from the sins committed under the first covenant.”

In Hebrews 14-16 it reads, “. . . because by one sacrifice he has made perfect forever those who are being made holy. The Holy Spirit also testifies to us about this. First he says: ‘This is the covenant I will make with them after that time, says the Lord. I will put my laws in their hearts, and I will write them on their minds.’” [And we are beginning to understand how this act of the Lord likely occurs by dualist interaction between His Mind and the mind of repentant mankind.]

In my second book, Section 2.3, I wrote what applies to these verses: “As Jesus was dying on the cross he was heard in the ninth hour to cry out in Aramaic, ‘Eloi, Eloi, lama sabachthani?’ - which means, ‘My God, my God, why have you forsaken me?’ In the sixth hour darkness had come over the whole land and lasted until the ninth hour. The sun had stopped shining, and the curtain in the temple was torn in two as Jesus called out with a loud voice, ‘Father, into your hands I commit my spirit.’ Jesus then breathed his last and died. The tearing of the temple curtain signified that people again had direct access to the Spirit of God [by the atoning blood of Christ] . . . .”

“But the eternal plan of God was to be fulfilled by the physical and spiritual death of Jesus the Man while carrying the sins of mankind. Jesus was a sinless propitiating sacrifice for the redemption of Man from sin. . . . Jesus was in full obedience to the necessity for his death to fulfill his Father’s purpose. It accounts for his final words on the cross, ‘It is finished.’ With that, he bowed his head and gave up his spirit.” Now repentant mankind has direct access to the Most Holy Place!

The greatest negative in the universe is the cross, for with it God wiped out everything that was not of himself: the greatest positive in the universe is the Resurrection, for through it God brought into being all he will have in the new sphere. (Watchman Nee)

John 4:34

“My food,” said Jesus, “is to do the will of him who sent me and to finish his work.” It was always the will and intent of our Creator God to have a personal, bidirectional communion with the crown of his creation, Man.  It was a communion lost at the Fall but restored by the sacrificial, redeeming death and resurrection of Jesus Christ to repentant believers in the reality of the living Savior.

Non-material energy of an immaterial mind

I conclude posts from this chapter with the following excerpts. I recommend reviewing this work to come to an understanding of how substance dualism applies to dualist interactionism. What I am posting now complements much of what I have shared in my books and blogs. These excerpts are included since they identify the focus of my own research over nearly 30 years.

“For anything to cause a physical object to move, or cause any change in one, there must be a flow of energy or transfer of momentum, from the cause to the physical object. But how could there be an energy flow from an immaterial mind to a material thing? What kind of energy could it be? . . . . Could there be causal interactions among immaterial substances? Ruling out mind-body causal interaction does not in itself rule out the possibility of a causally autonomous domain of immaterial minds in which minds are in causal commerce with other minds. Perhaps that is the picture of a purely spiritual afterlife envisioned in some religions and theologies. . . . is there anything in principle wrong with locating immaterial minds in physical space and thereby making it possible for them to participate in the causal transactions of the world? . . . . It is not surprising that substance dualism has not been a prominent alternative in contemporary philosophy of mind. But there is no call to exclude it a priori, without serious discussion; some highy reputable and respected philosophers continue to defend it as a realistic - perhaps the only - option. . . . you can take having a mind simply as having a certain special set of properties, capacities, and characteristics, something that humans and some higher animals possess but sticks and stones do not. To say that something ‘has a mind’ is to classify it as a certain sort of thing - as a thing with capacities for certain characteristic sorts of behavior and functions, such as sensation, perception, memory, learning, consciousness, and goal-directed action. For this reason, it is less misleading to speak of ‘having a mentality’ than ‘having a mind.’”

Brain waves of the mind's neuronal networks

I will be posting selected excerpts from an article by Jon Lieff, M.D. entitled “Neuronal Networks and Brain Waves” (http://jonlieffmd.com/blog/neuronal-networks-brain-waves). In my latest blogs I have addressed the role of wave forms and quantum tunneling in dualist interaction between the immaterial mind and the synaptic networks of the human brain. Lieff’s article is informative and touches on some of the points I have made in my books and certain blog posts. It is my hope that the reader will obtain a better understanding of the complexity and remarkable design of the synaptic networks that make the transmission of linguistic codes possible in cognition.

“Along with 80 billion neurons and 800 trillion constantly changing connections, individual neurons use very precise rhythms and groups of neurons oscillating together in very specific frequencies. The perplexing relationship of neuronal networks and brain waves is critical to future understanding of the brain.” Lieff identifies “. . . daily changes of axons, dendrites and synapses; thousands of different kinds of neurons; thousands of different kinds of post synaptic densities; glial cell networks; and electrical synapses.” He has “. . . discussed whether the network patterns of the neuronal connections could explain the workings of the mind. . . . But perhaps the greatest difficulty in understanding how the brain functions is describing the precise mechanisms that allow rhythms and waves to interact constantly with the changing anatomy of the synaptic connections.

“The changing dynamics of wide ranging neuronal circuits occurs throughout the brain in milliseconds at the level of individual neurons and groups of neurons. Neurons join a circuit one moment and another the next moment. Groups of neurons fire action potentials in very specific rhythms that rapidly change. Groups of neurons produce brain waves - synchronous oscillations - that communicate information from one section of the brain to another. Synchronous brain waves couple with other frequencies to connect multiple regions.”

Brain waves of the mind's neuronal network, 2

I have discussed columns of neurons in the context of cerebral modules in my books and related blog posts. Dr. Lieff addresses them in his article:

“Columns of cells, or multiple related columns, are a frequent anatomic brain structure, such as in the cortex. In these columns, the dynamic node includes proximity to other structures, but, also, individual and group behavior of neurons, electric currents, and alterations that occur with factors that modulate neurons. These dynamic relationships between neurons and regions of neurons can change in an instant, with one neuron participating in two totally different brain-wide neuroplastic circuits in milliseconds. [By what mechanism do these instant changes happen? Read on.]

“. . . Some slow and fast waves can work together through a process called coupling [I have discussed this relationship in my writings]. By coupling, many different brain regions can communicate together at the same time using multiple different frequencies. Coupling is a complex process where one rhythm nests within another and is carried along with it. Cross frequency coupling occurs when slower and faster frequencies work together - faster somehow nested inside the slower rhythms. . . . In the cortex, slow theta waves in the range of 5 to 8 Hz couple with much faster gamma waves and modulate the powerful gamma messages that appear to link distant brain regions. These long-range connections have raised the question whether gamma waves are part of the process that brings together all the disparate parts of conscious experience. . . . many of the brain’s neurons have multi sensory inputs and connections to multiple modalities. Precise rhythms are critical in the brain’s ability to differentiate and use multi modal inputs. For any task, many different brain regions are active and integrated through both multiple synapses and multiple brain waves. Networks use specific frequencies to tie information and neuronal groups together.”

“. . . Brain waves when they arrive at distant locations can have very different interactions and effects based on the local anatomy and physiology. These processes occur in milliseconds, far faster than any available imaging.”

In the last post taken from this article I will include Dr. Lieff’s challenging and insightful proposal!

Brain waves of the mind's neuronal network, 3

I conclude these posts from Dr. Jon Lieff’s article with his following stimulating comments:

Brain waves when they arrive at distant locations can have very different interactions and effects based on the local anatomy and physiology. These processes occur in milliseconds, far faster than any available imaging. Brain mapping will need to include these dimensions to get anywhere in understanding the brain’s relation to mental events. But the most important question is often ignored. Where is the direction for all of this? There is no known center directing this fantastically complex circuitry (changing each millisecond), the neuronal action potential rhythms, and the many different brain wave frequencies. Even more complex is the coupling and uncoupling of different frequencies communicating information between local and global regions and the neuro modulation that alters brain waves in specific regions. With no center in this four dimensional complexity, isn’t the best explanation mind interacting with each molecule, each cell and each brain region [Italics added].

These comments amplify those I have made concerning dualist interaction between the immaterial mind, including the Mind of God/Holy Spirit, and the material synaptic networks of the human brain. I thank Dr. Lieff for his article.

Waves of the Holy Spirit

I have devoted much time studying the means by which the Holy Spirit communes with the mind of repentant mankind in our time, a process restored to fallen mankind by the sin sacrifice of Jesus Christ on the cross and sent as He promised upon His resurrection. I have learned that wave forms are generated by cognition that are transmitted through neural synaptic networks. Wave forms carry specified information within encoded spike trains of action potentials that is transmitted across neural synapses facilitated by quantum tunneling. Because this mechanism was created by God to make personal communion between people possible, it is conceivable that the mechanism is used by the indwelling Holy Spirit to provide Counsel to the mind of people who seek it. It is a process of dualist interaction between the immaterial Mind of the Holy Spirit and the mind of Man and the material components of the brain’s synaptic networks.

I came across an article by Dr. Brad Long entitled “The Four Great Waves of the Holy Spirit,” published January 23, 2020 (https://www.prmi.org/the-four-great-waves-of-the-holy-spirit). He opens his article with “The Father’s master strategy for extending the Gospel to all nations and people on earth began with wave upon wave of the Holy Spirit to advance the Kingdom of God to all humanity. . . . “ In Acts 1:8 He states, “You will receive power when the Holy Spirit comes on you; and you will be my witnesses in Jerusalem, and in Judea and Samaria, and to the ends of the earth.” Dr. Long continues, “Beginning with Pentecost, the Holy Spirit has worked in successive waves or pulses to advance the Kingdom of God. . . .These pulsations of the Holy Spirit are the pattern of God’s working in the book of Acts. . . .This establishes the reality that while the outpouring of the Holy Spirit at Pentecost was an initial event, it was not to be seen as a single unique event, but rather the beginning of a pattern extending until the return of the King. This also clarifies this usage of ‘filled with the Holy Spirit; as having the same meaning as the ‘Holy Spirit falling upon people for power.’ . . . These waves . . . advance the Kingdom of God by bringing people into the purposes of God, empowering and equipping them to fulfill these purposes.”

I find it interesting that Dr. Long identifies the action of the Holy Spirit as waves. Perhaps we are learning at least in part how the communion between the Holy Spirit and the spirit and soul of mankind occurs, thanks to advances being made in the neurosciences that show concordance between scientific findings and Scripture.

Wave forms of the immaterial mind

In many of my blog posts I am discussing wave forms that are under intensive study by neuroscientists, including so-called traveling waves. It is difficult to find work that acknowledges, or even considers, the role of the immaterial cognitive mind in generating the wave forms which transmit specified information along coherent synaptic networks to achieve tasks. material reductionism still reigns rather dominant in that literature, and the human mind is equated with computer metrics and algorithms instantiated in the brain.

As I have asked in my books and some blogs, so what? Why am i spending time researching this category of neuroscience literature? My response is that our immaterial minds and the brain’s material synaptic networks which allow humans to communicate, to move and to create are the creations of God by the power of the Holy Spirit. That man uses this medium to commune opens the door for the holy spirit to use it as well, acting as our Counselor and helper. it is important that i document this dualist interaction to the best of my ability, drawing upon an accumulation of evidence and abductive reasoning, both valid scientific methods that can draw upon laboratory evidence. in so far as i am successful, it is my hope that this activity will draw people into the kingdom of god when they understand that god still desires a personal communion with us and has created the path by which that happens in our time.

Soul/mind apart from the body

taken from an article by dr. John D. Jones entitled “The distinction between the soul and body.”

“Having argued that there is a distinction between the mind/soul and body, we need to ask about the nature of that relation. In particular, we want to ask whether the soul/mind can exist apart from the body or separately from the body. . . . the soul is to the body as a captain is to a ship. That is, the captain governs the ship, but the captain is a being that is ontologically distinct from the ship and can exist when not on the ship. . . . the intellectual operation of the soul acts independently of the body. . . . the intellectual soul has its own substantial existence. that is, it can exist separately from the body.”

In making the case for dualist interaction between the immaterial cognitive mind of man and the material processes of the brain’s synaptic networks, we see the mind as the “captain” and the “ship” as the synaptic networks and body, a good analogy. We live to have the holy spirit become our “captain.”

New technology identifies cognitive waveforms

In 2006 Akgul, Akin and Sankur published an article in Med Bio Eng Comput, vol. 44:945-958, entitled “Extraction of cognitive activity-related waveforms from functional near-infrared spectroscopy signals.” The article describes a new technology to identify cognitive waveform activity. I am posting several excerpts from this article and will show its historical relevance to the work of John C. Eccles in a subsequent post.

“The main objective of most neuroimaging studies has been the precise and accurate detection of the evoked responses to single-event trial stimulation. Since the evoked responses are usually minute in amplitude, and deeply buried under the background activity of the brain, researchers have to resort to advanced signal-processing techniques to extract these evoked responses. A promising new neuroimaging modality is the functional near-infrared spectroscopy (fNIRS), which can capture cerebrovascular changes in the surface of the cortex. [This modality] can potentially detect and tract cerebrovascular changes, called blood oxygenation dependent (BOLD) signals by the use of optical methods. Similar to fmri, fnirs is sensitive to deoxyhemoglobin while complimentarily it can measure the changes in oxyhemoglobin.

“. . . Functional neuroimaging studies performed by both fmri and fnirs methods have confirmed that the increase of regional cerebral blood flow towards activated areas exceeds the regional oxygen consumption, and hence the signal pattern observed in the bold response resembles the oxyhemoglobin signal of fnirs. Similar to fmri signal analysis, fnirs analysis is concerned with the varying cerebrovascular alterations due to stimuli.

Eccles showed increase in blood flow with cognitive activity

In Chapter 6, Section 5 of his book, How the Self Controls Its Brain, John C. Eccles describes how the concentration of “attention causes neural activity in rather large areas of the brain, as is revealed by the rcbf technique (regional cerebral blood flow). . . . one can concentrate attention to a finger tip in order to detect a minimal touch that is expected,” and it is this focus of attention that results in the neural activity. “In this technique, radio-xenon . . . is injected into the internal carotid artery through a cannula that has been inserted for a clinical investigation. A battery of 254 geiger counters is mounted in a helmet applied over one side of the scalp. the brief injection causes a pattern of increased radioactivity, as observed by the counts of the geiger assemblage. This increase in counts signals an increased blood flow, which in turn gives a quantitative measure of the subjacent cortical activity. The counts are done in the control resting situation and then during the chosen mental task which . . . was a concentrated attention on the finger tip in anticipation of a just recognizable touch.” Eccles’ study gave “a clear demonstration that the mental act of attention can activate appropriate regions of the cerebral cortex.”

Immaterial self and mind

In the next several blogs I will be posting excerpts from the book written by John Foster entitled The immaterial self: a defence of the cartesian dualist conception of the mind. Foster is a fellow in philosophy at Brasenose College, Oxford.

The back cover includes the following: “Dualism holds that the mind is wholly non-physical and that mental phenomena are not reducible to anything else. The Immaterial Self examines and defends this thesis, and in particular argues for its cartesian version, which assigns the non-physical ingredients of the mind to a non-physical subject. The book exposes the inadequacies of the materialist and reductionist accounts of the mind which have become so fashionable in recent years.”

Five claims of dualism

Foster identifies the five claims of dualism:

there is a mental realm

the mental realm is fundamental

there is a physical realm

the physical realm is fundamental

the two realms are ontologically separate

Foster states that “human beings of sufficient maturity have minds. . . . and some will accept the existence of non-embodied minds, such as those of God, angels, and departed spirits. . . . mentality is not reducible to something else. . . . the mental and the physical realms are ontologically separate. Roughly, what this means is that the entities which feature in the one realm are entirely different from those which feature in the other - that the class of mental-realm entities and the class of physical-realm entities do not overlap.”

Dualistic causation

I cite Foster who stated, “Whether we are dualists or materialists. . . we presumably have to accept the existence of psychophysical causation.” He asks, “Why should the fact that mind and body are so different in nature make it difficult to understand how there could be causal relations between them? . . . typically, when one physical event causes another, the two events are either spatially contiguous (or coincident) or are connected by a spatiotemporally continuous series of events through which the causal process passes. This feature of physical causation may make it seem that causation has to operate by means of spatial contact - that spatial contact is the essential mechanism for causal contact. And, of course, once this is accepted, causation between physical and non-physical events is automatically excluded, simply because the non-physical events have no spatial location. . . . but if there is no conceptual difficulty in envisaging causation-at-a-distance in the physical realm, THEN DUALISTIC CAUSATION SHOULD NOT BE EXCLUDED, OR REGARDED AS CONCEPTUALLY PROBLEMATIC, PURELY ON THE GROUNDS THAT THERE IS NO SPATIAL CONTACT BETWEEN THE NON-PHYSICAL MIND AND THE BODY. . . . ON THE DUALIST VIEW, WE CANNOT UNDERSTAND HOW PSYCHOPHYSICAL CAUSATION OPERATES; WE SIMPLY HAVE TO ACCEPT IT AS A BRUTE FACT, WITH NO FURTHER EXPLANATION, THAT CERTAIN TYPES OF NEURAL EVENT DIRECTLY CAUSE CERTAIN TYPES OF MENTAL EVENT, AND VICE VERSA.”

Embodiment

Foster states the following:

“Although the basic subjects involved in human mentality are wholly non-physical, each subject is, at least for a certain phase of its history, intimately linked with a particular biological organism. It is this link which makes it appropriate to speak of the subject as having a body, or as embodied. . . . but what, then, is the nature of this link? What is the connection between the non-physical subject and the biological organism which embodies it? . . . Anything approaching an adequate answer to this question . . . would become the business of the neuroscientist. . . . To begin with, it is clear that the connection between the non-physical subject and the biological organism is, fundamentally, a functional one: it is a matter of there being a psychophysical arrangement whereby each partner is equipped to have the right sorts of direct causal influence on the other. This arrangement will be secured by the respective natures of the two entities concerned, together with some framework of physical and psychophysical laws.”

Stan Lennard