Action potentials and wave generation
In my blog posts I have provided data that suggests how nonmaterial wave forms may act to trigger the transmission of encoded information within spike trains of action potentials across synaptic networks through quantum tunneling. It is a process that would involve electron transfers within ionic channel and synaptic vesicle protein components that would release neural transmitters from vesicle pores to traverse synaptic clefts and stimulate action potentials at postsynaptic structures. I have discussed this process in detail in my books and in several blog posts, highlighted in the blog series entitled “Waves in Our Brains.” In more recent posts I have presented data that indicates the generation of wave forms by the immaterial cognitive mind that transmit encoded information to and through receptor synaptic networks. Investigators in neurophysiology are getting closer to confirming dualist interaction between the immaterial mind and the material components of the brain’s synaptic networks.
I refer the reader to an article by Alexandra Pinto Castellanos entitled “Wave to Pulse Generation. From Oscillatory Synapse to Train of Action Potentials,” October 18, 2018. In the article the author posits how neurons have the capacity to transform information from a digital signal at the dendrites of presynaptic terminals to an analog wave at the synaptic cleft and back to a digital pulse when the acquired voltage for the generation of an action potential is achieved at the postsynaptic neuron. The author proposes that the action potential signals are smoothed at the synaptic cleft to create an oscillatory wave with the same frequency as the originating action potential train. She states, “Once the wave has acquired enough amplification after a process of synchronization, the postsynaptic axon responds to this [analog] wave input by generating a [postsynaptic digital] pulse train” with the same frequency but less amplitude. The result is the transmission of the same information flow frequency through a synaptic network.
Detail is presented by the author to explain the process. I note that there is no consideration of a nonmaterial wave form in the process, which I propose functions by quantum tunneling within specific synaptic structures. Rather an electrical signal is converted to a chemical oscillatory wave within the synaptic cleft that is subsequently converted back to the electrical signal of an action potential.
I call the reader’s attention to this particular article to show how waves are now being considered to account for synaptic transmission.
Synaptic transmission summarized
In my two books and selected blogs I have presented discussions of the mechanism of neural synaptic transmission. I emphasize that the mechanism is under active investigation and is most complex. I will not post any discussion of the mechanism as being substantiated by neuroscientific data, but like other investigators I am willing to offer proposals based upon what is currently known. In the following blog I am posting a proposal in general terms. As my research continues, I will modify it as new data is forthcoming. Fundamental to my research is the demonstration of concordance between neuroscience and Scripture where communion between the Holy Spirit and the human spirit, soul and brain are concerned. We can commune with God via prayer, and we can also receive communion from Him in our time through His created synaptic networks. It is a bidirectional communion that gives glory to our Creator God.
The cognitive mind has the capacity to generate wave forms with specific amplitudes and frequencies. The wave forms constitute an immaterial, or nonmaterial, aspect of energy that enables information transmission to and through the material synaptic network components of the human brain. It is a dualist interaction between immaterial and material entities, as has been presented in my books and blogs. Information specified with meaning, purpose and intended action is generated by the cognitive mind (including the Mind of God, the ultimate Source of all information), and the “causal glue” that links specified information with the brain’s synaptic networks is this immaterial energy that is distinct from the classical electrochemical energy of action potentials.
Through a lifelong process of learning neural codes are generated for every action and intention. The codes are stored in neural modules as memory, for example within the modules of the supplementary motor areas of the frontal cortex. The codes have intrinsic amplitudes and frequencies and serve as detectors that can link with the input of wave forms generated by the cognitive mind that have the same wave characteristics. By synchronizing with additional modular neurons sufficient energy is probabilistically exerted via quantum tunneling in ionic channels and the vesicles of presynaptic terminals to generate action potentials at postsynaptic junctions. Quantum tunneling serves as the “trigger” for the transmission of neurotransmitters across synaptic clefts so that spike trains of action potentials are transmitted through coherent synaptic networks. Direction is given to their trajectories by this process so that intended actions result by the action of stimulated nerve and motor receptors.
In my most recent blog posts I have given mention to Bohm’s quantum potential, Q. Bohm considers it “mind like,” consisting of “active information” but does not attribute it to an immaterial mind. I have posited that information transmitted through neural synaptic networks is only generated by an immaterial mind which assigns specificity to it with meaning, purpose and intended action. The information is encoded within the patterns of wave forms and ultimately the spike trains of action potentials. What might be the role of Q, the quantum potential energy, that is distinct from potential and kinetic energy and is proposed to act at synaptic junctions? It has been suggested that it reduces the height of the potential energy at barriers so that wave forms can be transmitted through potential barriers without an expenditure of energy, thereby preventing a violation of the law of conservation of energy. This action permits the generation of an action potential at the postsynaptic junction when wave forms with specified amplitudes and frequencies are successfully transmitted. That wave forms generated by the mind are detected by pyramidal module wave forms with the same or very similar amplitudes, frequencies and shapes establishes synchrony between wave forms having sufficient energy to generate action potentials in specific regions of the brain. The matching process involving specific modules determines the direction for the trajectories of encoded spike trains. Information is transmitted and directed through specific synaptic networks so that intended actions occur.
The mechanism for synaptic transmission is most complex but efficient, reflecting an intelligent design that permits dualist interaction between the Mind of God, the mind of Man and the human brain. I hope this proposal summary contributes to an understanding of the wonderful process of minds in communion.
Linkage of mind and brain
Danko Georgiev wrote an article entitled “A Linkage of Mind and Brain: Sir John Eccles and Modern Dualistic Interactionism,” published in Biomedical Reviews, 2011: 22: 81-84. I am posting quotes from that article that relate to points I have shared in my books and blogs.
The author shared that the nature of the mind-brain relationship is poorly understood. He states that “the roots of the problem lie within the causally closed deterministic structure of classical materialism.” In his article he discusses “how the quantum dualistic interactionism proposed by Sir John Eccles could resolve these problems.” I have provided much evidential support for dualist interactionism in my writings and have included support for an open indeterminant universe, components of which are governed by quantum mechanics. Georgiev states that “the behavior of elementary physical particles [is] inherently indeterministic so that one cannot predict exactly the future state of an individual particle, only the probability with which [a] given future state could occur. The dynamics of individual quantum particles is governed by a wavefunction. . . . The indeterminism in quantum mechanics stems from the fact that when the particle interacts with other particles only one of the possible states is actualized.” Indeterminism allows quantum components to be open to influences outside a classical material universe, including an immaterial cognitive mind as I have discussed in my writings.
“Sir John Eccles, who won the 1963 Nobel Prize in Physiology or Medicine for his work on the synapse, was one of the first who understood the importance of quantum mechanics for resolving the mind-brain problem.” He proposed “that mental events can cause brain events.” According to Georgiev “it is possible to construct a theory in which mind and brain states interact: the brain state produces deterministically a mind state [reflective of material reduction] after which the mind state makes an indeterministic choice from multiple possible alternatives and selects a future brain state.”
In his concluding remarks the author acknowledges the increasing number of neuroscientists who think that quantum theory supports dualist interactionism as proposed by Eccles. He states, “Attestation for that are the plethora of recent models based on the nanoscale organization of the neurons in which the mind states can affect the brain through quantum effects.” He refers to “the experimental verification of quantum tunneling for hydrogen transfer in enzyme-catalyzed reactions, quantum quasi-particle assisted folding of proteins and microsecond quantum coherence in the retina” permitting navigation by the sensing of Earth’s magnetic field by certain birds.
Immateriality of the psyche
Mikhail Reshetnikov is a Meritorious Scientist of the Russian Psychoanalytic Institute who argues for the non-materiality of the psyche. He developed an hypothesis of the brain as having a biological interface with mental activity, the psyche, which transmits information. In his 2018 article, “Non-Material Theory of the Psyche: Historical Prerequisites, Argumentation and Practical Implications,” he “compares the brain with the computer hardware, on the one hand, and the psyche with the software, on the other.” This is a common analogy. Specified information emanating from a mind is encoded within spike trains of action potentials and transmitted through coherent synaptic networks, a topic I have discussed in my books and several blogs. He states in his article that “academic science is currently viewing information as a non-material factor, so that only its carriers (biological, paper, electronic etc.) are material.” He went on to state that “it is not true that the nervous system controls the psyche but rather the psyche controls the nervous system including the central nervous system.” His points are consistent with many that have been cited in my writings. He includes a saying taken from the scientific community, “However much effort you put into dissembling the radio, you won’t find the music inside!” And music is a beautiful and creative form of specified information.
What is the "non-material energy" in synaptic transmission?
In my books and blogs I have addressed the role of a “non-material energy” in the transmission of neural codes within spike trains of action potentials through coherent, synchronous synaptic networks, refuting the reductive materialism so prevalent today. Action potentials are characterized by electrochemical reactions which arrive at presynaptic vesicular grids where there exists an activation barrier against the opening of ionic channels. The arrival of action potentials stimulates calcium ions to move through ionic channels into the interior of presynaptic terminals. Molecular and electronic configurations of the components of synaptic vesicles and membranes bordering synaptic clefts are excited by these ions into metastable levels referred to as quasiparticles. (Does a similar process occur within ionic channels driven by action potentials?) The metastable levels consist of electrons and hydrogen bonds which are altered from superposition states to unstable states which lead to the unidirectional processes of exocytosis. The motion along a given direction occurs by quantum tunnelling through the potential, or activation, barriers. The time scale for this action is in pico- to femtoseconds and corresponds to the quantal dynamics of electron transfers. Molecular transformations that occur between synaptic vesicles and cleft membranes cause membrane fusion and the formation of pores through which synaptic transmitters are released into synaptic clefts. I submit that the metastable level of quasiparticle formation that sets into motion quantum tunnelling can be considered the “non-material energy” of the activated state. It is this energy that serves as the quantum trigger for exocytosis. Might the non-material energy of the Mind of God and the mind of Man act at these sites by this mechanism? There is evidence that cognition generates specified wave forms that can tunnel. Is there an interaction between the proposed wave forms and the wave functions of molecular components in superposition within ionic channels, synaptic vesicles and cleft membranes that leads to exocytosis? Could such a process relate to Hebrews 11:1 that mentions “evidence of things unseen?”
I refer the reader to the article by Friedrich Beck entitled “Synaptic Quantum Tunnelling in Brain Activity.” It was published in NeuroQuantology in June 2008. It is a key article that reveals a link between spike trains of action potentials and the quasiparticle wave function which tunnels through potential barriers of synaptic vesicles and cleft membrane components resulting in the transmission of neural codes along synaptic networks. The synaptic quantum trigger identified by Beck frees the physical processes of synaptic transmission from the strict determinism of a classical mechanistic picture. Beck regarded “exocytosis as a candidate for quantum processes to enter the network [of synaptic transmission], thus regulating its performance.” Within his quantum trigger model is likely the “non-material energy” that enables coherent synaptic transmission, a dual process of interaction between what is immaterial and material.
Current investigators in the neurosciences are accepting in increasing numbers the microsite hypothesis of John Eccles that I have discussed in my writings and his work in collaboration with Friedrich Beck. I strongly recommend this article to you since it is relevant today to the processes of neural transmission under active investigation.
Action potentials and wave forms
Matthew S. Scarnati and his coauthors published an article in Frontiers in Synaptic Neuroscience in April, 2020 that addressed the function of presynaptic calcium channels and their relation to action potential waveforms. In previous blog posts I have addressed research that increasingly shows that cognition generates wave forms that interact with neural synaptic components, likely by way of quantum tunneling. This article refers to action potential wave forms and how both the depolarization and repolarization of ionic channels activate the passage of calcium ions that leads to the release of synaptic transmitters into synaptic clefts. I quote from the article, “Determining the change in open probability of presynaptic calcium channels and taking into account how local calcium concentration also changes throughout the action potential are both necessary to fully understand how the action potential triggers neurotransmitter release.”
My takeaway from this article coupled, with others I have addressed in recent blogs, leads me to the following speculation: Action potentials are wave forms with varying amplitudes, frequencies, durations and shapes as pointed out by the authors. The wave forms are specified and transmit neural codes within the spike trains. They impact the superposition of atomic components of molecular structures (electrons, hydrogen bonds) within ionic channels, and by quantum tunneling quasiparticles pass through voltage barriers to activate protein conformational changes that process calcium entry into synaptic terminals. It is a stochastic process, and the authors shared that the release probability is up to 25 percent of calcium channels that are rendered active at the end of action potential passage. The influx of calcium ions into presynaptic terminals leads to vesicle fusion with cleft membranes creating pores through which synaptic transmitters pass to stimulate excitatory postsynaptic action potentials. In a recent blog I discussed that quantum tunneling of quasiparticles is involved in this process that transmits wave forms along coherent synaptic networks to achieve specified actions.
Snare proteins and quantum tunneling
I have referred to the work of Danko D. Georgiev in previous posts and in my books. He authored an article that was preprinted in August, 2020 entitled “Quantum Information Theoretic Approach to the Mind-Brain Problem,” Progress in Biophysics & Molecular Biology. He challenged material reductionism in his introductory statement, “The brain is composed of electrically excitable neuronal networks by the activity of voltage-gated ion channels” [reference to which was given in my last blog post]. “Further portraying the molecular composition of the brain, however, will not reveal anything remotely reminiscent of a feeling, a sensation or a conscious experience. In classical physics, addressing the mind-brain problem is a formidable task because no physical mechanism is able to explain how the brain generates the unobservable, inner psychological world of conscious experiences and how in turn those conscious experiences steer the underlying brain processes toward desired behavior [a topic I have addressed in detail in my books]. . . . Comprising consciousness of unobservable quantum information integrated in quantum brain states [superpositions] explains the origin of the inner privacy of conscious experiences and revisits the dynamic timescale of conscious processes to picosecond conformational transitions of neural biomolecules. . . . Thus, quantum information theory clarifies the distinction between the unobservable mind and the observable brain. . . . the mind and the brain are not identical . . . the mind-brain problem is to explain how the unobservable conscious mind and the observable brain relate to each other: do they interact . . . ?” [My research has addressed this question extensively.]
Georgiev continues describing a most complex process, “. . . the dynamic timescale of conscious processes is consistent with picosecond conformational transitions of neural biomolecules. Examples of picosecond protein dynamics, which is directly related to the neuronal processing of information, include regulation of conductance of voltage-gated ion channels, activation of ionotropic glutamate receptors by neurotransmitter binding, or vibrational motions of the alpha-helix backbone involved in the conformational flexibility of SNARE proteins that drive exocytosis of synaptic vesicles. In contrast, the observable brain dynamics of electric spikes propagating along neuronal projections at a millisecond timescale describes transfer of classical information, which is triggered by quantum processes.”
“The minimal molecular machinery capable of driving synaptic vesicle fusion is comprised of only three SNARE proteins: synaptobrevin, syntaxin and SNAP-25 [I have discussed the proposed function of these proteins in my books]. These three SNARE proteins zip together to form a bundle of four alpha-helices referred to as the core SNARE complex. The twisting of the 4-alpha-helix bundle inside the core SNARE complex applies a traction force that drives the fusion of the opposing phospholipid bilayers of the synaptic vesicle and the plasma membrane. The zippering of the core SNARE complex is potent enough to drive synaptic vesicle exocytosis . . . In different neuron types, the process of exocytosis is regulated by different sets of SNARE master proteins that effectively set the potential energy barrier for vesicle fusion . . . . Classical particles are forbidden from entering spatial regions where the particle energy is less than the potential energy . . . whereas quantum particles are not . . . . the quantum wavefunction . . . needs to be continuous throughout space, which allows the quantum particle to tunnel through the potential energy barrier . . . and appear on the other side. . . . quantum quasi-particles . . . are able to transport energy along the protein and could trigger conformational transitions. . . . In the case of SNARE zipping, the role of the barrier is played by the calcium sensor synaptotagmin, which clamps the SNARE complex in partially zipped conformation. Quantum tunneling . . . through the barrier may induce full zipping of the SNARE complex and trigger exocytosis. In essence, massive proteins do not quantum tunnel, whereas quantum excitations propagating [as quasi-particles] along the proteins do. Quantum tunneling of such excitations could act as a trigger that steers the overall protein motion . . . into one of two alternative classical paths. Thus, cortical neurons that have surpassed . . . the voltage threshold for the generation of electric spike, are able to amplify the quantum dynamics of SNARE proteins at individual axonal buttons into a macroscopic pattern of active synapses that release neurotransmitter molecules. . . . The dynamic timescale of the underlying quantum processes is on the order of picoseconds.”
Is it possible that Georgiev has also given a description of the “non-material energy” to which I have referred in my latest blog posts, an energy that actualizes interaction between the immaterial mind and the material components of the synaptic networks?
Non-material theory of the psyche
Professor Mikhail Reshetnikov is a Meritorious Scientist of the Russian Federation. He authored an article published in Advances in Social Sciences Research Journal on January 25, 2019, entitled Methodological Background and Foundations of the Non-Material Theory of the Psyche. I am including several quotes from his article in which he provides evidence for the non-material nature of the psyche, or cognitive mind of humans.
“Mental activity is viewed as a kind of informational exchange and interaction, as well as accumulation and processing of information. . . . Nobody would deny that the brain and the nervous system are material structures regulating activities of internal organs, reflex reactions and adaptive functions of the organism, and mental activity is based on these structures. But the essence of mental activity is different. We accumulate information, process and verify information, produce information. . . . Information is understood by contemporary academic science as a non-material factor. . . . the founder of cybernetics N. Wiener emphasized that information is neither matter nor energy, information is information. . . . Only information carriers (biological, paper, electronic etc.) are material. . . . Information as such, on a carrier but without a perceiving subject, is virtually non-existent. Only living beings, and most of all, humans can be subjects of its perception, as well as produce, carry, store and verify non-material information. . . . Generally speaking, the phrase ‘we think with the brain’ is as absurd as the phrase ‘we walk with the spinal cord’ just because it relates to motility impulses. . . . it is not the computer that remembers something, finds it, calculates or analyses it. It is done by the non-material software, without which a computer is just a piece of metal. Similarly, the brain without the psyche which was formed under the influence of a society is just a biological substrate, a tissue that includes synapses, chemical mediators, nervous centers, transmitters, etc., but nothing more than that.”
It is encouraging that this distinguished scientist gives strong support to dualist interactionism between the immaterial mind and the material components of the brain. Yes, Mortimer Adler stated that we need our brains to think, but we do not think with our brains.
Molecular motors of synaptic transmission
Thomas C. Sudhof is a recognized authority at Stanford University who has extensively investigated synaptic transmission. In October 2013 he had an article published in Nature Medicine, Vol. 19, No. 10 entitled “A Molecular Machine for Neurotransmitter Release: Synaptotagmin and Beyond.” I refer the interested reader to this particular article since it includes excellent illustrations of the elaborate molecular machine that governs the release of neural transmitters into the synaptic cleft, specifically the fusion of docked synaptic vesicles to the presynaptic membrane and the subsequent opening of pores through which synaptic transmitters are released into the cleft. The machines reflect a complex, elaborate and coordinated molecular activity in which design has been instantiated for specific function, namely the transmission of specified information encoded within spike trains of action potentials through synaptic networks. I am including below an excerpt from his article that summarizes the mechanism of synaptic vesicular release. By reading this information it is my hope that it will lead to the reading of his entire article.
“We now know of a general mechanism of membrane fusion that operates by the interaction of SNAREs [for soluble N-ethylmaleimide-sensitive factor (NSF)-attachment protein receptors] and SM proteins (for Sec1/Munc18-like proteins). We also have now a general mechanism of calcium-triggered fusion that operates by calcium binding to synaptotagmins, plus a general mechanism of vesicular positioning adjacent to calcium channels, which involves the interaction of the so-called RIM proteins with these channels and synaptic vesicles. Thus, a molecular framework that accounts for the astounding speed and precision of neurotransmitter release has emerged.”
Molecular motors of synaptic transmission - continued
Axel T. Brunger and coworkers have examined the mechanism of synaptic vesicle fusion and have proposed that fusion is initially inhibited until it is released by “calcium ion binding to synaptotagmin-C2 domains. . . fusion is [then] assisted by SNARE complex zippering and by active membrane remodeling properties of synaptotagmin.” Their article was published in Trends in Cell Biol., August 2018. The process of synaptic transmission was summarized as follows: “Synaptic transmission between pre- and post-synaptic neurons occurs when the pre-synaptic neuron terminal is temporarily depolarized upon an action potential, opening calcium ion channels near the active zones of synapses. Since the extracellular calcium ion concentration is much higher than the cytoplasmic concentration, calcium ion will flow into the cytoplasm. In turn, calcium ion will trigger fusion of neurotransmitter-filled synaptic vesicles with the presynaptic membrane in less than a millisecond. Upon fusion, neurotransmitter molecules are released into the synaptic cleft, and then bind to receptors that are located in the postsynaptic membrane.”
The authors described the complex machinery mechanism in considerable detail. It is a highly coordinated process that acts in mere milliseconds. Their proposal shows how synaptic fusion is kept from happening until calcium ion influx releases the inhibition. They state, “Taken together, synaptotagmin and synaptotagmin-like C2 domains may play a dual role of inhibiting a certain process, such as membrane fusion, in the absence of calcium ions, and of activating the same process after release of inhibition by membrane remodeling in the presence of calcium ions.”
Quantum interactive dualism
I am including quotations from an article by Danko Georgiev and James Glazebrook entitled, “Quantum Interactive Dualism: From Beck and Eccles Tunneling Model of Exocytosis to Molecular Biology and SNARE Zipping.” It was published in Biomedical Reviews, 2014, Vol. 25: 15-24. I include this article because it supports dualist interactionism proposed by Eccles and Beck and because it adds to the understanding of the designed machine components of synaptic transmission. It is most important to understand that these machine components were created by God through Jesus Christ by the power of the Holy Spirit so that a bidirectional communion would be possible between the Holy Spirit and the human spirit and soul (mind, will, emotion). I submit that it is revelational to us in our time so that we can accept the communion with God He desired so long ago when He created Adam, a communion lost at the Fall but restored by the death and resurrection of Jesus Christ who sent the Holy Spirit as He promised to those who are in repentance. Let us see what this article includes.
“The large-scale anatomy of the brain and its histology are currently well understood. . . . molecular neuroscience has made strides towards elucidating the structure and function of neurons down at the nanoscale. At the microscopic level, the brain is composed of neurons assembled into neural networks. Each neuron is composed of three compartments: dendrites, soma and axon, respectively specialized to input, process and output information by transmitting [encoded] electric signals.
“Sir John Eccles . . . was one of the first who understood the importance of quantum mechanics for resolving the mind-brain problem, and proposed that mental events can cause brain events analogously to how the wave function . . . in quantum mechanics determines the probability . . . for a given quantum particle to be found at a certain position x at a certain moment of time t. Because quantum mechanics governs the behavior of physical systems at the nanoscale level, Eccles hypothesized that quantum effects could be manifest in the process of neurotransmitter release. This appeared to be consistent with the principles of quantum mechanics because the synaptic vesicles are approximately of the right size (40 nm in diameter) so as to be subjected to the quantum uncertainty relations, and because the probability of exocytosis is much smaller than 1 upon each axonal depolarization. Importantly, his hypothesis made interactive dualism feasible.
“The general features of the Beck and Eccles model are as follows: . . . each axon terminal contains approximately 50 synaptic vesicles anchored in a presynaptic vesicular grid. When an axonal electric spike depolarizes the axon terminal, at most one synaptic vesicle releases its neurotransmitter content in the synaptic cleft, and the probability for such an event is approximately 0.4. Because each neuronal axon has over 1000 presynaptic axon terminals, if the neurotransmitter release was due to classical random thermal fluctuations, then brain functional mechanism would be thrown into complete havoc within seconds. In view of the organizational structure of the brain, Beck and Eccles concluded that the probability of release should be quantum mechanical in origin and subject to direct causal influence by means of one’s own consciousness [or mindful intent]. . . . exocytosis needs to be a conditional event depending upon the depolarization of the axonal terminal. This means that the influx of calcium ions is a necessary, but not sufficient condition, for exocytosis to occur. Instead, exocytosis is triggered by the quantum tunneling of a particle [quasiparticle] with mass m satisfying the one-dimensional Schrodinger equation. . . . The potential energy . . . in the Schrodinger equation acts as a barrier for the motion of the particle. . . . due to the requirement for continuity of the quantum wavefunction . . . the quantum particle is able to tunnel through the entire width of the potential energy barrier . . . and appear on the other side. . . . Beck and Eccles determined that their model is physically plausible if the mass of the quantum particle triggering the exocytosis is less than 6 hydrogen masses. . . From this estimate, they also concluded that a quantum mechanical trigger for exocytosis must reside in an atomic process such as the movement of a hydrogen bridge by electronic rearrangement.”
Georgiev and Glazebrook went on to consider additional features of the proposed model, and I refer you to their article. Specifically, they proposed vibrationally assisted tunneling in SNARE zipping which has been discussed in a previous blog. “Motivated by the molecular structure of the four-a - helix bundle of SNARE proteins, we have modeled the SNARE zipping using a quantum quasiparticle . . . propagating along the hydrogen bonds of the protein a - helices of the SNARE complex.”
The authors discussed how their model exhibits temperature dependence in contrast with that of Beck and Eccles which was temperature independent. The authors stated that “our own work demonstrated that the problems in the Beck and Eccles model are not of fundamental character.” They concluded their discussion stating that “quantum mechanics provides a unique opportunity for the construction of mind-brain interaction models without violation of the physical laws. Because quantum effects are most pronounced at the nanoscale, it is natural to expect that the putative models should be implemented at the molecular level inside neurons.”
My last several blogs have addressed these features in some detail, and I refer the interested reader to the articles cited. Again, I propose that the quantum trigger identified by Eccles, Beck and the authors of this article is identified as the “nonmaterial energy” by which interaction between immaterial and material entities occurs in dualist interaction.
Holy Spirit in Scripture in concordance with neuroscience
In my last blogs I have discussed in detail aspects of synaptic transmission that are becoming understood that give credence to dualist interaction between the immaterial mind (and Mind of God) and the material components of the human brain. I have proposed that the “nonmaterial energy” referred to in several cited articles and in my books can be identified as the process of quantum tunneling that interacts with the electrochemical action potentials that transmit encoded specified information.
As I was reading John 14 this morning, I was struck with the need to identify several verses spoken by Jesus Christ that show concordance with what is being presented in the neuroscience literature. If the reader has been following my blog posts and contents of my books over time, I believe my listing of these verses will bring renewed emphasis to this concordance. They are from the NIV Study Bible:
Anyone who has seen me has seen the Father. How can you say, “Show us the Father”? Don’t you believe that I am in the Father, and that the Father is in me? The words I say to you are not just my own. Rather, it is the Father, living in me, who is doing his work. Believe me when I say that I am in the Father and the Father is in me; or at least believe on the evidence of the miracles themselves. . . . But you know him, for he lives with you and will be in you. I will not leave you as orphans; I will come to you. Before long, the world will not see me anymore, but you will see me. Because I live, you also will live. On that day you will realize that I am in my Father, and you are in me, and I am in you. . . . All this I have spoken while still with you. But the Counselor, the Holy Spirit, whom the Father will send in my name, will teach you all things and will remind you of everything I have said to you. . . . but the world must learn that I love the Father and that I do exactly what my Father has commanded me.
The work of the Holy Spirit
I continue with Scripture from John 16:
Now I am going to him who sent me . . . But I tell you the truth: It is for your good that I am going away. Unless I go away, the Counselor will not come to you; but if I go, I will send him to you. . . . But when he, the Spirit of truth, comes, he will guide you into all truth. He will not speak on his own; he will speak only what he hears, and he will tell you what is yet to come.
So we shall hear from the Holy Spirit who in turn will hear from the Father through the resurrected Jesus Christ. Indeed, it is “minds in communion” between God the Father, the risen and living Jesus Christ, the Holy Spirit and the human spirit and soul in repentance. It is God’s created synaptic networks that makes this communion possible, a dualist interaction.
Wave form effects on neurostimulation
In previous blogs I have shared how wave forms are involved in stimulating action potentials and that they transmit neurally encoded specified information. The nonmaterial energy has been identified as being possibly the quantum tunneling process by which synaptic transmission occurs through synchronous, coherent networks.
I now refer to excerpts from an article by Aquiles Parodi and Jin-Woo Choi entitled, “A Pulse Generation Circuit for Studying Waveform Effects on Neurostimulation.” It was published on November 14, 2019, in Electronics, Vol. 8. These will substantiate the proposals I have made that the immaterial mind, including the Mind of God, generate wave forms that stimulate spike trains of action potentials that transmit encoded specified information to bring about desired actions and purposes.
“Electrical stimulation parameters, such as waveform, amplitude, and stimulation frequency, have been shown to affect neurostimulation properties. . . . Electrical stimulation has demonstrated capabilities to alter the compound action potentials and long-term potentiation behavior of complex neural networks . . . . Neuromodulation has been observed at all levels, from individual nerve cells to brain regions, including the synapses. . . . waveform shape has an effect on electrical stimulation outcome.”
The authors refer to “the unknown neural mechanisms involved,” and this has been the subject of my research over almost 30 years, employing the neural synapse as the model for my studies of dualist interactionism. I will add additional posts that address how wave forms interact with neural synaptic networks.
Neural stimulation by waveforms
Warren M. Grill has studied the effects of stimulation waveform on the energy efficiency of neural excitation. His objective is to “understand the biophysical mechanisms underlying the effects of extracellular stimulation on neurons.” [This has been the focus of my own studies over the last 20 years, addressed in my two books and in blog posts on my website.] He continues stating that “Two important considerations when selecting or designing stimulation parameters are selectivity and efficiency. Selectivity is the ability to activate the targeted neural elements without activating the non-target neural elements. . . . Efficiency is achieving the required level of neural activation or response to achieve clinical efficacy with the minimal amount of stimulation. . . . The selectivity and efficiency of neural stimulation are dependent on the choice of the stimulation waveform.”
We see that multiple variables must be considered by the researchers to study biophysical mechanisms that exert effects on neuron stimulation. Our Creator God controls all these variables being uncovered over time by investigators to interact with the human spirit and soul! It is my judgment that God is allowing these kinds of studies to reveal to us how He communes with us! I continue:
Grill has learned that “the stimulation waveform shape can also be manipulated to increase stimulation selectivity between activation of the targeted neural elements and activation of non-target neural elements, and thereby increase the dynamic range between therapeutic effects and unwanted side effects [to the ultimate benefit of Man!] . . . . the energy required for stimulation is indeed dependent on the shape of the stimulation waveform, and highlight the importance of using an appropriately complex model to analyze the effects of waveform shape on neural excitation. . . . [there is an] optimal waveform for a particular application.”
In his concluding remarks Grill states that “the parameter space for electrical stimulation of the nervous system is extremely large, and the design and selection of stimulation parameters to achieve a desired response is a challenging problem” [giving testimony to the infinite power and intellect of our Creator God who designed these parameters for His purposes to achieve His desired responses in us!].
Waveform effects on neurostimulation
Aquiles Parodi and Jin-Woo Choi published an article in Electronics in 2019, Volume 8, p. 1344, that relates to the current consideration of waveform effects on neural stimulation. It is entitled, “A Pulse Generation Circuit for Studying Waveform Effects on Neurostimulation.” I am including a number of excerpts from their article:
“Electrical stimulation has demonstrated capabilities to alter the compound action potentials and long-term potentiation behavior of complex neural networks, even at low stimulation intensities, via an effect termed neuromodulation. Neuromodulation has been observed at all levels, from individual nerve cells to brain regions, including the synapses. . . . This effect is thought to arise from action potentials (APs) that are modulated as they propagate through individual nerve cells, depending on the nerve cell’s properties at the level of the soma, axon, and transmembrane proteins. This modulation can be enhanced or inhibited with neurostimulation. . . . Stimulation waveforms have been studied for their effects in neurostimulation. These include square or rectangular, exponential, ramp, sinusoidal, triangle and Gaussian waveforms.” These authors focused in their studies on the effects of signal shape on neurostimulation and have observed that “waveform shape has an effect on electrical stimulation outcome.”
Aspects of neural activity influenced by stimulation, in this case waveforms, have been addressed in both my books and in more recently posted blog posts on my website. I have presented preliminary evidence in previous blog posts that the immaterial, cognitive mind of humans has the capacity to generate waveforms that interact with the material components of the brain’s synaptic networks. The role of quantum tunneling has been included in these discussions, along with the recently defined potential role of quantum potential energy coupled with kinetic and potential energy in synaptic transmission. I repeat my proposal that the process of quantum tunneling constitutes the “non-material energy” identified by investigators such as William Dembski.
I am copying a lengthy excerpt from this article to show the complexity behind the generation of spike trains of action potentials and synaptic transmission that carry encoded information to effect various actions. It is our Creator God who designed these complex features with the ultimate Purpose of establishing intimate, personal communion with the crown of His creation, Man, by the power of His Holy Spirit. It is this dualist interaction that has been the focus of my own research.
“Design of stimulation waveforms is difficult, due to the diverse options and requirements for each anatomical stimulation target, the undetermined long-term effects of neurostimulation, the diversity of tissue, organ, and patient-level reactions, the unknown neural mechanisms involved [the focus of my studies], and the unknown side effects of stimulation methodology, including electrode type. The parameters of electrical stimulation waveforms, such as the amplitude, width and frequency of stimulation, have been shown to affect prosthetic sensory information in the vestibular nerve, the rate of excitation of individual nerves and nerve bundles, and the spatial selectivity within the bundles. Additionally, differences in stimulation waveforms, the polarity of current and direction, electric field shape and direction, and the temporal pattern of stimulation have been shown to have effects on the outcome of stimulation.”
We serve and worship an awesome God!
Holy Spirit lives in you
For nearly 30 years I have been studying interaction between the Holy Spirit and the human spirit and soul (mind, will and emotion), the neural synaptic network serving as the model for my investigations. I have shared what I have learned in my books and blogs, posting what I hope is compelling evidence for the dualist interaction that occurs between the immaterial Holy Spirit of God and the spirit and soul of Man through the material components of the neural synaptic networks.
Many posts have been made showing how wave forms interact with the spike trains of action potentials in neural synaptic networks. By this process specified information with meaning and purpose is transmitted via neural codes instantiated within the wave forms. Both electrochemical energy and non-material energy provide the power for this transmission. Neuroscientists are at work to uncover the mechanisms by which transmission occurs, mechanisms that go unseen except by application of the most current technological tools. It is exciting and challenging work, with promise for people having impaired sensory and motor functions. Might Hebrews 11:1-3 (NIV) apply?
Now faith is being sure of what we hope for and certain of what we do not see.
I have endeavored to show the concordance that is becoming evident between Scripture and neuroscience in dualist interaction between the Holy Spirit and the human spirit and soul and neural mechanisms. I am reminded of verses in the Book of Romans that apply to the mechanisms being revealed in this interaction. The Apostle Paul spoke to life in the Spirit in Romans 8: 9-11; 15-16 (NIV):
You, however, are controlled not by the sinful nature but by the Spirit, if the Spirit of God lives in you. And if anyone does not have the Spirit of Christ, he does not belong to Christ. But if Christ is in you, your body is dead because of sin, yet your spirit is alive because of righteousness. And if the Spirit of him who raised Jesus from the dead is living in you, he who raised Christ from the dead will also give life to your mortal bodies through his Spirit, who lives in you. . . . For you did not receive a spirit that makes you a slave again to fear, but you received the Spirit of sonship. And by him we cry, ‘Abba, Father.’ The Spirit himself testifies with our spirit that we are God’s children.
Cortical activity waves
Paul Koch and Gerry Leisman have published an article entitled “Cortical Activity Waves Are the Physical Carriers of Memory and Thought.” Readers of my more recent blogs have noted how coherent waveforms are transmitted through synaptic networks that are encoded with specified information within spike trains of action potentials. The authors offer that “coherent waves are instrumental in the retrieval of memory and random waves embody original thought.”
I am encouraged that these authors are linking cortical waves with thought which I have associated with the activity of an immaterial cognitive mind. They continue, “. . . there are numerous different possible neural firing patterns . . . . If each active subset of individual cortical cells represents a distinct thought [possibly corresponding to cortical pyramidal modules with distinct patterns of wave forms], there are about 10^6 billion . . . possibilities for about 20 billion cortical cells. . . . [The authors do not] “describe how these patterns are decoded into a mixture of the semantic content of different wave-memories and memories of previous thoughts. . . . All mammals are subject to cortical activity waves, but only humans can associate language (words, music, fine art, dance, algebra, etc.) with the waves, and thus can have memories of our thoughts.”
In my blogs and books I have provided evidence that wave “patterns” are the neural codes within spike trains of action potentials, and I submit that memory is instantiated within neural codes having meaning, or semantics, and purpose. Are waves generated by “original thought” truly random, or are they the product of cognitive intent? Humans have been uniquely created by God to transmit linguistic neural codes that are actively interpreted by the immaterial mind and are archived in memory. I suggest that this point applies to “words, music, fine art, dance, algebra, etc.” The authors make no direct mention of the cognitive mind, but dualist interaction between an immaterial mind and the neural synaptic network processes can give a more complete analysis of the excellent observations made by these authors in my view.
Wisdom from the Spirit
I am posting selected verses from the Bible that reflect the dualist interaction I discuss in my books and blogs between the indwelling Holy Spirit and the spirit and soul of repentant Man. Articles cited from the neurosciences reveal the mechanisms of neural synaptic networks through which the immaterial mind of Man and Mind of God commune. It is a concordance between science and theology for which I have hopefully provided compelling evidence.
I now post selections from 1 Corinthians 2:10-16 and 6:17 (NIV). As these verses are read it is my expectation that the reader will find that an understanding of dualist interaction gives a depth of meaning perhaps otherwise missed.
The Spirit searches all things, even the deep things of God. For who among men knows the thoughts of a man except the man’s spirit within him? In the same way no one knows the thoughts of God except the Spirit of God. We have not received the spirit of the world but the Spirit who is from God, that we may understand what God has freely given us. This is what we speak, not in words taught us by human wisdom but in words taught by the Spirit, expressing spiritual truths in spiritual words. The man without the Spirit does not accept the things that come from the Spirit of God, for they are foolishness to him, and he cannot understand them, because they are spiritually discerned. The spiritual man makes judgments about all things, but he himself is not subject to any man’s judgment: For who has known the mind of the Lord that he may instruct him? But we have the mind of Christ.
But he who unites himself with the Lord is one with him in spirit.
Power of the Holy Spirit and God's love
I am posting these verses from Paul’s letter to the Ephesians, 3:14-19 (NIV), that are in concordance with content I have shared in my books and blogs that speak to dualist interaction between the Holy Spirit and the human spirit and soul, the synaptic network making it possible. It speaks to the boundless love of God for us:
For this reason I kneel before the Father, from whom his whole family in heaven and on earth derives its name. I pray that out of his glorious riches he may strengthen you with power through his Spirit in your inner being, so that Christ may dwell in your hearts through faith. And I pray that you, being rooted and established in love, may have power, together with all the saints, to grasp how wide and long and high and deep is the love of Christ, and to know this love that surpasses knowledge - that you may be filled to the measure of all the fullness of God.
Tufts of pyramidal apical dendrites
My interest in the tufts of pyramidal apical dendrites is long standing, and I have addressed aspects of their function in earlier blogs. As I reviewed Friedrich Beck’s article referenced in my July 2nd blog I noted his comments about these tufts. The neocortex consists of six lamina. “The pyramidal apical dendrites finish in a tuft-like branching in lamina I.” He stated that he was in agreement with Fleischhauer and coworkers who published articles in 1984 and 1987 that posited that “the apical bundles of dendrites . . . are the basic anatomical units of the neocortex. . . . It has been proposed that these bundles are the cortical units for reception [Italics added], which would give them a preeminent role.” Specifically, can the function of the tufts be expanded to possibly include reception of cognitive wave forms?
The tufts lie at the surface of cortical modules in lamina I and are known to have numerous neural interconnections with the dendritic tufts of adjacent and distant modules. Within modules are specific baseline wave frequencies, amplitudes and shapes that serve as “detectors” of nerve impulses as proposed by Eccles and noted in previous blog posts. I ask if wave forms generated by the cognitive mind pass across cortical modules and become linked with synchronous modular wave forms via the neural spines of apical dendritic tufts? Such a process would enable neural codes within specified wave forms to be transmitted through coherent synaptic networks to stimulate activities. In asking this question I am accepting the immateriality of the cognitive mind and its capacity to generate wave forms that interact with the material synaptic networks of the brain, a dualist interaction.
In subsequent blog posts I shall address the role of pyramidal tufts.
The immaterial mind of God
I am posting several quotations taken from an article by Scott Youngren and published by The Think Institute. It is entitled “Metaphysics, the Matrix, and the Mind of God.” They speak to the immateriality and primacy of the Mind of God.
Since the time of the ancient Greeks, there have been two basic pictures of ultimate reality among Western intellectuals, what the Germans call a Weltanschauung, or worldview. According to one worldview, mind is the primary or ultimate reality. On this view, material reality either issues from a preexisting mind, or it is shaped by a preexistent intelligence, or both . . . This view of reality is often called idealism to indicate that ideas come first and matter comes later. Theism is the version of idealism that holds that God is the source of the ideas that gave rise to and shaped the material world.
The opposite view holds that the physical universe or nature is the ultimate reality. In this view, either matter or energy (or both) are the things from which everything else comes. They are self-existent and do not need to be created or shaped by mind . . . . In this view matter comes first, and conscious mind arrives on the scene much later and only then as a by-product of material processes and undirected evolutionary change. This worldview is called naturalism or materialism.
Stephen C. Meyer
For myself, faith begins with a realization that a supreme intelligence brought the universe into being and created man. It is not difficult for me to have this faith, for it is incontrovertible that where there is a plan there is intelligence - an orderly, unfolding universe testifies to the truth of the most majestic statement ever uttered - “In the beginning God.”
James Clerk Maxwell
God is a mathematician of a very high order and He used advanced mathematics in constructing the universe.
Max Planck
It is evident that an acquaintance with natural laws means no less than an acquaintance with the mind of God therein expressed.
Albert Einstein
An equation for me has no meaning unless it expresses a thought of God.
James Joule
Is intelligent mind an ultimate and irreducible feature of reality? Indeed, is it the ultimate nature of reality? Or is mind and consciousness an unforeseen and unintended product of basically material processes of evolution? If you look at the history of philosophy, it soon becomes clear that almost all the great classical philosophers took the first of these views. Plato, Aristotle, Anselm, Aquinas, Descartes, Leibniz, Spinoza, Locke, Berkeley, Kant, Hegel - they all argued that the ultimate reality, often hidden under the appearances of the material world or time and space, is mind or spirit.
Srinivasa Ramanujam
In the New Story of science the whole universe - including matter, energy, space, and time - is a one-time event and had a definite beginning. But something must have always existed; for if ever absolutely nothing existed, then nothing would exist now, since nothing comes from nothing. The material universe cannot be the thing that always existed because matter had a beginning. It is 12 to 20 billion years old. This means that whatever has always existed is non-material. The only non-material reality seems to be mind. If mind is what has always existed, then matter must have been brought into existence by a mind that always was. This points to an intelligent, eternal being who created all things. Such a being is what we mean by the term God.
Sir Isaac Newton
The immaterial soul
Dr. J. P. Moreland composed an article for the ministry Reasons To Believe (www.reasons.org) addressing the immateriality of the human soul. It was entitled “Body and Soul Part 2: Why the Soul Is Immaterial.” I will post several excerpts from his informative article which provides support for dualist interaction between the immaterial human spirit and soul (and the Holy Spirit) and the material synaptic networks of the human brain. He begins his article with the following:
“. . . a human being’s soul or self . . . is immaterial (or non-material).” Moreland states that the soul is a substance. “Substances are basic fundamental things. They are not in other things or aspects of other things. . . . Substance dualists assert that as a human, [a person] consists of an immaterial substantial soul with a physical body that is not identical to the soul. . . . substance dualists believe that the brain is a physical thing with physical properties and the mind or soul is a mental substance that has mental properties. . . . a human being’s self or ego [is] an immaterial substance that bears consciousness.”
Self awareness, the "I"
Moreland addresses the concept of self awareness, of the “I:”
“. . . through self-awareness, one gains an awareness of the fact that “I” who was and is (and will be) present as the owner of all the [life] experiences. . . . These two facts - “I” am the owner of self-experience, and “I” am an enduring self who exists as the same possessor of all self-experience through time - show that a person is not identical to his experiences. Self (or “I”) is the thing that has them. In short, “I” is a mental substance. Only a single enduring self can relate and unify experiences, a fact that property dualists and physicalists cannot adequately account for or explain away.”
Moreland’s statements give compelling support to the immateriality of the human soul, the mind, the self, the “I.”
Free will
Moreland addresses free will in his article:
“To say that a human is a free will being is to say that humans exercise what is called libertarian freedom. . . . A person’s choice is up to the individual . . . . [One] acts as an agent who is the first cause or ultimate originator of [their] own actions. Moreover, [one’s] reasons for acting do not partially or fully cause [their] actions. . . . Rather, [one’s] reasons are the teleological goals - the purposes or the ends - for the sake of which [one] acts.
Moreland states that “If physicalism is true, then human free will does not exist. Instead, determinism is true. . . . Further, since free acts seem to be for the sake of goals or ends, if physicalism . . . is true, there is no ultimate purpose and thus, there can be no libertarian free acts.”
I have pointed out in past blogs and in my books that it has been the intent of the Spirit of our Creator God to have a personal relationship with us. That has been, and is, His “ultimate purpose.” Jesus Christ’s atoning sacrifice for us has renewed our ability in repentance to have a dualist interaction, a bidirectional relationship, with the indwelling Holy Spirit.