Minds in Communion - 13

 

Action potentials and wave generation

In my blog posts I have provided data that suggests how nonmaterial wave forms may act to trigger the transmission of encoded information within spike trains of action potentials across synaptic networks through quantum tunneling. It is a process that would involve electron transfers within ionic channel and synaptic vesicle protein components that would release neural transmitters from vesicle pores to traverse synaptic clefts and stimulate action potentials at postsynaptic structures. I have discussed this process in detail in my books and in several blog posts, highlighted in the blog series entitled “Waves in Our Brains.” In more recent posts I have presented data that indicates the generation of wave forms by the immaterial cognitive mind that transmit encoded information to and through receptor synaptic networks. Investigators in neurophysiology are getting closer to confirming dualist interaction between the immaterial mind and the material components of the brain’s synaptic networks.

I refer the reader to an article by Alexandra Pinto Castellanos entitled “Wave to Pulse Generation. From Oscillatory Synapse to Train of Action Potentials,” October 18, 2018. In the article the author posits how neurons have the capacity to transform information from a digital signal at the dendrites of presynaptic terminals to an analog wave at the synaptic cleft and back to a digital pulse when the acquired voltage for the generation of an action potential is achieved at the postsynaptic neuron. The author proposes that the action potential signals are smoothed at the synaptic cleft to create an oscillatory wave with the same frequency as the originating action potential train. She states, “Once the wave has acquired enough amplification after a process of synchronization, the postsynaptic axon responds to this [analog] wave input by generating a [postsynaptic digital] pulse train” with the same frequency but less amplitude. The result is the transmission of the same information flow frequency through a synaptic network.

Detail is presented by the author to explain the process. I note that there is no consideration of a nonmaterial wave form in the process, which I propose functions by quantum tunneling within specific synaptic structures. Rather an electrical signal is converted to a chemical oscillatory wave within the synaptic cleft that is subsequently converted back to the electrical signal of an action potential.

I call the reader’s attention to this particular article to show how waves are now being considered to account for synaptic transmission.

Synaptic transmission summarized

In my two books and selected blogs I have presented discussions of the mechanism of neural synaptic transmission. I emphasize that the mechanism is under active investigation and is most complex. I will not post any discussion of the mechanism as being substantiated by neuroscientific data, but like other investigators I am willing to offer proposals based upon what is currently known. In the following blog I am posting a proposal in general terms. As my research continues, I will modify it as new data is forthcoming. Fundamental to my research is the demonstration of concordance between neuroscience and Scripture where communion between the Holy Spirit and the human spirit, soul and brain are concerned. We can commune with God via prayer, and we can also receive communion from Him in our time through His created synaptic networks. It is a bidirectional communion that gives glory to our Creator God.

The cognitive mind has the capacity to generate wave forms with specific amplitudes and frequencies. The wave forms constitute an immaterial, or nonmaterial, aspect of energy that enables information transmission to and through the material synaptic network components of the human brain. It is a dualist interaction between immaterial and material entities, as has been presented in my books and blogs. Information specified with meaning, purpose and intended action is generated by the cognitive mind (including the Mind of God, the ultimate Source of all information), and the “causal glue” that links specified information with the brain’s synaptic networks is this immaterial energy that is distinct from the classical electrochemical energy of action potentials.

Through a lifelong process of learning neural codes are generated for every action and intention. The codes are stored in neural modules as memory, for example within the modules of the supplementary motor areas of the frontal cortex. The codes have intrinsic amplitudes and frequencies and serve as detectors that can link with the input of wave forms generated by the cognitive mind that have the same wave characteristics. By synchronizing with additional modular neurons sufficient energy is probabilistically exerted via quantum tunneling in ionic channels and the vesicles of presynaptic terminals to generate action potentials at postsynaptic junctions. Quantum tunneling serves as the “trigger” for the transmission of neurotransmitters across synaptic clefts so that spike trains of action potentials are transmitted through coherent synaptic networks. Direction is given to their trajectories by this process so that intended actions result by the action of stimulated nerve and motor receptors.

In my most recent blog posts I have given mention to Bohm’s quantum potential, Q. Bohm considers it “mind like,” consisting of “active information” but does not attribute it to an immaterial mind.  I have posited that information transmitted through neural synaptic networks is only generated by an immaterial mind which assigns specificity to it with meaning, purpose and intended action. The information is encoded within the patterns of wave forms and ultimately the spike trains of action potentials. What might be the role of Q, the quantum potential energy, that is distinct from potential and kinetic energy and is proposed to act at synaptic junctions? It has been suggested that it reduces the height of the potential energy at barriers so that wave forms can be transmitted through potential barriers without an expenditure of energy, thereby preventing a violation of the law of conservation of energy. This action permits the generation of an action potential at the postsynaptic junction when wave forms with specified amplitudes and frequencies are successfully transmitted.  That wave forms generated by the mind are detected by pyramidal module wave forms with the same or very similar amplitudes, frequencies and shapes establishes synchrony between wave forms having sufficient energy to generate action potentials in specific regions of the brain. The matching process involving specific modules determines the direction for the trajectories of encoded spike trains. Information is transmitted and directed through specific synaptic networks so that intended actions occur.

The mechanism for synaptic transmission is most complex but efficient, reflecting an intelligent design that permits dualist interaction between the Mind of God, the mind of Man and the human brain. I hope this proposal summary contributes to an understanding of the wonderful process of minds in communion.

Linkage of mind and brain

Danko Georgiev wrote an article entitled “A Linkage of Mind and Brain: Sir John Eccles and Modern Dualistic Interactionism,” published in Biomedical Reviews, 2011: 22: 81-84. I am posting quotes from that article that relate to points I have shared in my books and blogs.

The author shared that the nature of the mind-brain relationship is poorly understood. He states that “the roots of the problem lie within the causally closed deterministic structure of classical materialism.” In his article he discusses “how the quantum dualistic interactionism proposed by Sir John Eccles could resolve these problems.” I have provided much evidential support for dualist interactionism in my writings and have included support for an open indeterminant universe, components of which are governed by quantum mechanics. Georgiev states that “the behavior of elementary physical particles [is] inherently indeterministic so that one cannot predict exactly the future state of an individual particle, only the probability with which [a] given future state could occur. The dynamics of individual quantum particles is governed by a wavefunction. . . . The indeterminism in quantum mechanics stems from the fact that when the particle interacts with other particles only one of the possible states is actualized.” Indeterminism allows quantum components to be open to influences outside a classical material universe, including an immaterial cognitive mind as I have discussed in my writings.

“Sir John Eccles, who won the 1963 Nobel Prize in Physiology or Medicine for his work on the synapse, was one of the first who understood the importance of quantum mechanics for resolving the mind-brain problem.” He proposed “that mental events can cause brain events.” According to Georgiev “it is possible to construct a theory in which mind and brain states interact: the brain state produces deterministically a mind state [reflective of material reduction] after which the mind state makes an indeterministic choice from multiple possible alternatives and selects a future brain state.”

In his concluding remarks the author acknowledges the increasing number of neuroscientists who think that quantum theory supports dualist interactionism as proposed by Eccles. He states, “Attestation for that are the plethora of recent models based on the nanoscale organization of the neurons in which the mind states can affect the brain through quantum effects.” He refers to “the experimental verification of quantum tunneling for hydrogen transfer in enzyme-catalyzed reactions, quantum quasi-particle assisted folding of proteins and microsecond quantum coherence in the retina” permitting navigation by the sensing of Earth’s magnetic field by certain birds.

Immateriality of the psyche

Mikhail Reshetnikov is a Meritorious Scientist of the Russian Psychoanalytic Institute who argues for the non-materiality of the psyche. He developed an hypothesis of the brain as having a biological interface with mental activity, the psyche, which transmits information. In his 2018 article, “Non-Material Theory of the Psyche: Historical Prerequisites, Argumentation and Practical Implications,” he “compares the brain with the computer hardware, on the one hand, and the psyche with the software, on the other.” This is a common analogy. Specified information emanating from a mind is encoded within spike trains of action potentials and transmitted through coherent synaptic networks, a topic I have discussed in my books and several blogs. He states in his article that “academic science is currently viewing information as a non-material factor, so that only its carriers (biological, paper, electronic etc.) are material.” He went on to state that “it is not true that the nervous system controls the psyche but rather the psyche controls the nervous system including the central nervous system.” His points are consistent with many that have been cited in my writings. He includes a saying taken from the scientific community, “However much effort you put into dissembling the radio, you won’t find the music inside!” And music is a beautiful and creative form of specified information.

What is the "non-material energy" in synaptic transmission?

In my books and blogs I have addressed the role of a “non-material energy” in the transmission of neural codes within spike trains of action potentials through coherent, synchronous synaptic networks, refuting the reductive materialism so prevalent today. Action potentials are characterized by electrochemical reactions which arrive at presynaptic vesicular grids where there exists an activation barrier against the opening of ionic channels. The arrival of action potentials stimulates calcium ions to move through ionic channels into the interior of presynaptic terminals. Molecular and electronic configurations of the components of synaptic vesicles and membranes bordering synaptic clefts are excited by these ions into metastable levels referred to as quasiparticles. (Does a similar process occur within ionic channels driven by action potentials?) The metastable levels consist of electrons and hydrogen bonds which are altered from superposition states to unstable states which lead to the unidirectional processes of exocytosis. The motion along a given direction occurs by quantum tunnelling through the potential, or activation, barriers. The time scale for this action is in pico- to femtoseconds and corresponds to the quantal dynamics of electron transfers. Molecular transformations that occur between synaptic vesicles and cleft membranes cause membrane fusion and the formation of pores through which synaptic transmitters are released into synaptic clefts. I submit that the metastable level of quasiparticle formation that sets into motion quantum tunnelling can be considered the “non-material energy” of the activated state. It is this energy that serves as the quantum trigger for exocytosis. Might the non-material energy of the Mind of God and the mind of Man act at these sites by this mechanism? There is evidence that cognition generates specified wave forms that can tunnel. Is there an interaction between the proposed wave forms and the wave functions of molecular components in superposition within ionic channels, synaptic vesicles and cleft membranes that leads to exocytosis? Could such a process relate to Hebrews 11:1 that mentions “evidence of things unseen?”

I refer the reader to the article by Friedrich Beck entitled “Synaptic Quantum Tunnelling in Brain Activity.” It was published in NeuroQuantology in June 2008. It is a key article that reveals a link between spike trains of action potentials and the quasiparticle wave function which tunnels through potential barriers of synaptic vesicles and cleft membrane components resulting in the transmission of neural codes along synaptic networks. The synaptic quantum trigger identified by Beck frees the physical processes of synaptic transmission from the strict determinism of a classical mechanistic picture. Beck regarded “exocytosis as a candidate for quantum processes to enter the network [of synaptic transmission], thus regulating its performance.” Within his quantum trigger model is likely the “non-material energy” that enables coherent synaptic transmission, a dual process of interaction between what is immaterial and material.

Current investigators in the neurosciences are accepting in increasing numbers the microsite hypothesis of John Eccles that I have discussed in my writings and his work in collaboration with Friedrich Beck. I strongly recommend this article to you since it is relevant today to the processes of neural transmission under active investigation.

Action potentials and wave forms

Matthew S. Scarnati and his coauthors published an article in Frontiers in Synaptic Neuroscience in April, 2020 that addressed the function of presynaptic calcium channels and their relation to action potential waveforms. In previous blog posts I have addressed research that increasingly shows that cognition generates wave forms that interact with neural synaptic components, likely by way of quantum tunneling. This article refers to action potential wave forms and how both the depolarization and repolarization of ionic channels activate the passage of calcium ions that leads to the release of synaptic transmitters into synaptic clefts. I quote from the article, “Determining the change in open probability of presynaptic calcium channels and taking into account how local calcium concentration also changes throughout the action potential are both necessary to fully understand how the action potential triggers neurotransmitter release.”

My takeaway from this article coupled, with others I have addressed in recent blogs, leads me to the following speculation: Action potentials are wave forms with varying amplitudes, frequencies, durations and shapes as pointed out by the authors. The wave forms are specified and transmit neural codes within the spike trains. They impact the superposition of atomic components of molecular structures (electrons, hydrogen bonds) within ionic channels, and by quantum tunneling quasiparticles pass through voltage barriers to activate protein conformational changes that process calcium entry into synaptic terminals. It is a stochastic process, and the authors shared that the release probability is up to 25 percent of calcium channels that are rendered active at the end of action potential passage. The influx of calcium ions into presynaptic terminals leads to vesicle fusion with cleft membranes creating pores through which synaptic transmitters pass to stimulate excitatory postsynaptic action potentials. In a recent blog I discussed that quantum tunneling of quasiparticles is involved in this process that transmits wave forms along coherent synaptic networks to achieve specified actions.

Snare proteins and quantum tunneling

I have referred to the work of Danko D. Georgiev in previous posts and in my books. He authored an article that was preprinted in August, 2020 entitled “Quantum Information Theoretic Approach to the Mind-Brain Problem,” Progress in Biophysics & Molecular Biology. He challenged material reductionism in his introductory statement, “The brain is composed of electrically excitable neuronal networks by the activity of voltage-gated ion channels” [reference to which was given in my last blog post]. “Further portraying the molecular composition of the brain, however, will not reveal anything remotely reminiscent of a feeling, a sensation or a conscious experience. In classical physics, addressing the mind-brain problem is a formidable task because no physical mechanism is able to explain how the brain generates the unobservable, inner psychological world of conscious experiences and how in turn those conscious experiences steer the underlying brain processes toward desired behavior [a topic I have addressed in detail in my books]. . . . Comprising consciousness of unobservable quantum information integrated in quantum brain states [superpositions] explains the origin of the inner privacy of conscious experiences and revisits the dynamic timescale of conscious processes to picosecond conformational transitions of neural biomolecules. . . . Thus, quantum information theory clarifies the distinction between the unobservable mind and the observable brain. . . . the mind and the brain are not identical . . . the mind-brain problem is to explain how the unobservable conscious mind and the observable brain relate to each other: do they interact . . . ?” [My research has addressed this question extensively.]

Georgiev continues describing a most complex process, “. . . the dynamic timescale of conscious processes is consistent with picosecond conformational transitions of neural biomolecules. Examples of picosecond protein dynamics, which is directly related to the neuronal processing of information, include regulation of conductance of voltage-gated ion channels, activation of ionotropic glutamate receptors by neurotransmitter binding, or vibrational motions of the alpha-helix backbone involved in the conformational flexibility of SNARE proteins that drive exocytosis of synaptic vesicles. In contrast, the observable brain dynamics of electric spikes propagating along neuronal projections at a millisecond timescale describes transfer of classical information, which is triggered by quantum processes.”

“The minimal molecular machinery capable of driving synaptic vesicle fusion is comprised of only three SNARE proteins: synaptobrevin, syntaxin and SNAP-25 [I have discussed the proposed function of these proteins in my books]. These three SNARE proteins zip together to form a bundle of four alpha-helices referred to as the core SNARE complex. The twisting of the 4-alpha-helix bundle inside the core SNARE complex applies a traction force that drives the fusion of the opposing phospholipid bilayers of the synaptic vesicle and the plasma membrane. The zippering of the core SNARE complex is potent enough to drive synaptic vesicle exocytosis . . . In different neuron types, the process of exocytosis is regulated by different sets of SNARE master proteins that effectively set the potential energy barrier for vesicle fusion . . . . Classical particles are forbidden from entering spatial regions where the particle energy is less than the potential energy . . . whereas quantum particles are not . . . . the quantum wavefunction . . . needs to be continuous throughout space, which allows the quantum particle to tunnel through the potential energy barrier . . . and appear on the other side. . . . quantum quasi-particles . . . are able to transport energy along the protein and could trigger conformational transitions. . . . In the case of SNARE zipping, the role of the barrier is played by the calcium sensor synaptotagmin, which clamps the SNARE complex in partially zipped conformation. Quantum tunneling . . . through the barrier may induce full zipping of the SNARE complex and trigger exocytosis. In essence, massive proteins do not quantum tunnel, whereas quantum excitations propagating [as quasi-particles] along the proteins do. Quantum tunneling of such excitations could act as a trigger that steers the overall protein motion . . . into one of two alternative classical paths. Thus, cortical neurons that have surpassed . . . the voltage threshold for the generation of electric spike, are able to amplify the quantum dynamics of SNARE proteins at individual axonal buttons into a macroscopic pattern of active synapses that release neurotransmitter molecules. . . . The dynamic timescale of the underlying quantum processes is on the order of picoseconds.”

Is it possible that Georgiev has also given a description of the “non-material energy” to which I have referred in my latest blog posts, an energy that actualizes interaction between the immaterial mind and the material components of the synaptic networks?

Non-material theory of the psyche

Professor Mikhail Reshetnikov is a Meritorious Scientist of the Russian Federation. He authored an article published in Advances in Social Sciences Research Journal on January 25, 2019, entitled Methodological Background and Foundations of the Non-Material Theory of the Psyche. I am including several quotes from his article in which he provides evidence for the non-material nature of the psyche, or cognitive mind of humans.

“Mental activity is viewed as a kind of informational exchange and interaction, as well as accumulation and processing of information. . . . Nobody would deny that the brain and the nervous system are material structures regulating activities of internal organs, reflex reactions and adaptive functions of the organism, and mental activity is based on these structures. But the essence of mental activity is different. We accumulate information, process and verify information, produce information. . . . Information is understood by contemporary academic science as a non-material factor. . . . the founder of cybernetics N. Wiener emphasized that information is neither matter nor energy, information is information. . . . Only information carriers (biological, paper, electronic etc.) are material. . . . Information as such, on a carrier but without a perceiving subject, is virtually non-existent. Only living beings, and most of all, humans can be subjects of its perception, as well as produce, carry, store and verify non-material information. . . . Generally speaking, the phrase ‘we think with the brain’ is as absurd as the phrase ‘we walk with the spinal cord’ just because it relates to motility impulses. . . . it is not the computer that remembers something, finds it, calculates or analyses it. It is done by the non-material software, without which a computer is just a piece of metal. Similarly, the brain without the psyche which was formed under the influence of a society is just a biological substrate, a tissue that includes synapses, chemical mediators, nervous centers, transmitters, etc., but nothing more than that.”

It is encouraging that this distinguished scientist gives strong support to dualist interactionism between the immaterial mind and the material components of the brain. Yes, Mortimer Adler stated that we need our brains to think, but we do not think with our brains.

Molecular motors of synaptic transmission

Thomas C. Sudhof is a recognized authority at Stanford University who has extensively investigated synaptic transmission. In October 2013 he had an article published in Nature Medicine, Vol. 19, No. 10 entitled “A Molecular Machine for Neurotransmitter Release: Synaptotagmin and Beyond.” I refer the interested reader to this particular article since it includes excellent illustrations of the elaborate molecular machine that governs the release of neural transmitters into the synaptic cleft, specifically the fusion of docked synaptic vesicles to the presynaptic membrane and the subsequent opening of pores through which synaptic transmitters are released into the cleft. The machines reflect a complex, elaborate and coordinated molecular activity in which design has been instantiated for specific function, namely the transmission of specified information encoded within spike trains of action potentials through synaptic networks. I am including below an excerpt from his article that summarizes the mechanism of synaptic vesicular release. By reading this information it is my hope that it will lead to the reading of his entire article.

“We now know of a general mechanism of membrane fusion that operates by the interaction of SNAREs [for soluble N-ethylmaleimide-sensitive factor (NSF)-attachment protein receptors] and SM proteins (for Sec1/Munc18-like proteins). We also have now a general mechanism of calcium-triggered fusion that operates by calcium binding to synaptotagmins, plus a general mechanism of vesicular positioning adjacent to calcium channels, which involves the interaction of the so-called RIM proteins with these channels and synaptic vesicles. Thus, a molecular framework that accounts for the astounding speed and precision of neurotransmitter release has emerged.”

Molecular motors of synaptic transmission - continued

Axel T. Brunger and coworkers have examined the mechanism of synaptic vesicle fusion and have proposed that fusion is initially inhibited until it is released by “calcium ion binding to synaptotagmin-C2 domains. . . fusion is [then] assisted by SNARE complex zippering and by active membrane remodeling properties of synaptotagmin.” Their article was published in Trends in Cell Biol., August 2018. The process of synaptic transmission was summarized as follows: “Synaptic transmission between pre- and post-synaptic neurons occurs when the pre-synaptic neuron terminal is temporarily depolarized upon an action potential, opening calcium ion channels near the active zones of synapses. Since the extracellular calcium ion concentration is much higher than the cytoplasmic concentration, calcium ion will flow into the cytoplasm. In turn, calcium ion will trigger fusion of neurotransmitter-filled synaptic vesicles with the presynaptic membrane in less than a millisecond. Upon fusion, neurotransmitter molecules are released into the synaptic cleft, and then bind to receptors that are located in the postsynaptic membrane.”

The authors described the complex machinery mechanism in considerable detail. It is a highly coordinated process that acts in mere milliseconds. Their proposal shows how synaptic fusion is kept from happening until calcium ion influx releases the inhibition. They state, “Taken together, synaptotagmin and synaptotagmin-like C2 domains may play a dual role of inhibiting a certain process, such as membrane fusion, in the absence of calcium ions, and of activating the same process after release of inhibition by membrane remodeling in the presence of calcium ions.”

Quantum interactive dualism

I am including quotations from an article by Danko Georgiev and James Glazebrook entitled, “Quantum Interactive Dualism: From Beck and Eccles Tunneling Model of Exocytosis to Molecular Biology and SNARE Zipping.” It was published in Biomedical Reviews, 2014, Vol. 25: 15-24. I include this article because it supports dualist interactionism proposed by Eccles and Beck and because it adds to the understanding of the designed machine components of synaptic transmission. It is most important to understand that these machine components were created by God through Jesus Christ by the power of the Holy Spirit so that a bidirectional communion would be possible between the Holy Spirit and the human spirit and soul (mind, will, emotion). I submit that it is revelational to us in our time so that we can accept the communion with God He desired so long ago when He created Adam, a communion lost at the Fall but restored by the death and resurrection of Jesus Christ who sent the Holy Spirit as He promised to those who are in repentance. Let us see what this article includes.

“The large-scale anatomy of the brain and its histology are currently well understood. . . . molecular neuroscience has made strides towards elucidating the structure and function of neurons down at the nanoscale. At the microscopic level, the brain is composed of neurons assembled into neural networks. Each neuron is composed of three compartments: dendrites, soma and axon, respectively specialized to input, process and output information by transmitting [encoded] electric signals.

“Sir John Eccles . . . was one of the first who understood the importance of quantum mechanics for resolving the mind-brain problem, and proposed that mental events can cause brain events analogously to how the wave function . . . in quantum mechanics determines the probability . . . for a given quantum particle to be found at a certain position x at a certain moment of time t. Because quantum mechanics governs the behavior of physical systems at the nanoscale level, Eccles hypothesized that quantum effects could be manifest in the process of neurotransmitter release. This appeared to be consistent with the principles of quantum mechanics because the synaptic vesicles are approximately of the right size (40 nm in diameter) so as to be subjected to the quantum uncertainty relations, and because the probability of exocytosis is much smaller than 1 upon each axonal depolarization. Importantly, his hypothesis made interactive dualism feasible.

“The general features of the Beck and Eccles model are as follows: . . . each axon terminal contains approximately 50 synaptic vesicles anchored in a presynaptic vesicular grid. When an axonal electric spike depolarizes the axon terminal, at most one synaptic vesicle releases its neurotransmitter content in the synaptic cleft, and the probability for such an event is approximately 0.4. Because each neuronal axon has over 1000 presynaptic axon terminals, if the neurotransmitter release was due to classical random thermal fluctuations, then brain functional mechanism would be thrown into complete havoc within seconds. In view of the organizational structure of the brain, Beck and Eccles concluded that the probability of release should be quantum mechanical in origin and subject to direct causal influence by means of one’s own consciousness [or mindful intent]. . . . exocytosis needs to be a conditional event depending upon the depolarization of the axonal terminal. This means that the influx of calcium ions is a necessary, but not sufficient condition, for exocytosis to occur. Instead, exocytosis is triggered by the quantum tunneling of a particle [quasiparticle] with mass m satisfying the one-dimensional Schrodinger equation. . . . The potential energy . . . in the Schrodinger equation acts as a barrier for the motion of the particle. . . . due to the requirement for continuity of the quantum wavefunction . . . the quantum particle is able to tunnel through the entire width of the potential energy barrier . . . and appear on the other side. . . . Beck and Eccles determined that their model is physically plausible if the mass of the quantum particle triggering the exocytosis is less than 6 hydrogen masses. . . From this estimate, they also concluded that a quantum mechanical trigger for exocytosis must reside in an atomic process such as the movement of a hydrogen bridge by electronic rearrangement.”

Georgiev and Glazebrook went on to consider additional features of the proposed model, and I refer you to their article. Specifically, they proposed vibrationally assisted tunneling in SNARE zipping which has been discussed in a previous blog. “Motivated by the molecular structure of the four-a - helix bundle of SNARE proteins, we have modeled the SNARE zipping using a quantum quasiparticle . . . propagating along the hydrogen bonds of the protein a - helices of the SNARE complex.”

The authors discussed how their model exhibits temperature dependence in contrast with that of Beck and Eccles which was temperature independent. The authors stated that “our own work demonstrated that the problems in the Beck and Eccles model are not of fundamental character.” They concluded their discussion stating that “quantum mechanics provides a unique opportunity for the construction of mind-brain interaction models without violation of the physical laws. Because quantum effects are most pronounced at the nanoscale, it is natural to expect that the putative models should be implemented at the molecular level inside neurons.”

My last several blogs have addressed these features in some detail, and I refer the interested reader to the articles cited. Again, I propose that the quantum trigger identified by Eccles, Beck and the authors of this article is identified as the “nonmaterial energy” by which interaction between immaterial and material entities occurs in dualist interaction.

Holy Spirit in Scripture in concordance with neuroscience

In my last blogs I have discussed in detail aspects of synaptic transmission that are becoming understood that give credence to dualist interaction between the immaterial mind (and Mind of God) and the material components of the human brain. I have proposed that the “nonmaterial energy” referred to in several cited articles and in my books can be identified as the process of quantum tunneling that interacts with the electrochemical action potentials that transmit encoded specified information.

As I was reading John 14 this morning, I was struck with the need to identify several verses spoken by Jesus Christ that show concordance with what is being presented in the neuroscience literature. If the reader has been following my blog posts and contents of my books over time, I believe my listing of these verses will bring renewed emphasis to this concordance. They are from the NIV Study Bible:

Anyone who has seen me has seen the Father. How can you say, “Show us the Father”? Don’t you believe that I am in the Father, and that the Father is in me? The words I say to you are not just my own. Rather, it is the Father, living in me, who is doing his work. Believe me when I say that I am in the Father and the Father is in me; or at least believe on the evidence of the miracles themselves. . . . But you know him, for he lives with you and will be in you. I will not leave you as orphans; I will come to you. Before long, the world will not see me anymore, but you will see me. Because I live, you also will live. On that day you will realize that I am in my Father, and you are in me, and I am in you. . . . All this I have spoken while still with you. But the Counselor, the Holy Spirit, whom the Father will send in my name, will teach you all things and will remind you of everything I have said to you. . . . but the world must learn that I love the Father and that I do exactly what my Father has commanded me.

The work of the Holy Spirit

I continue with Scripture from John 16:

Now I am going to him who sent me . . . But I tell you the truth: It is for your good that I am going away. Unless I go away, the Counselor will not come to you; but if I go, I will send him to you. . . . But when he, the Spirit of truth, comes, he will guide you into all truth. He will not speak on his own; he will speak only what he hears, and he will tell you what is yet to come.

So we shall hear from the Holy Spirit who in turn will hear from the Father through the resurrected Jesus Christ. Indeed, it is “minds in communion” between God the Father, the risen and living Jesus Christ, the Holy Spirit and the human spirit and soul in repentance. It is God’s created synaptic networks that makes this communion possible, a dualist interaction.

Wave form effects on neurostimulation

In previous blogs I have shared how wave forms are involved in stimulating action potentials and that they transmit neurally encoded specified information. The nonmaterial energy has been identified as being possibly the quantum tunneling process by which synaptic transmission occurs through synchronous, coherent networks.

I now refer to excerpts from an article by Aquiles Parodi and Jin-Woo Choi entitled, “A Pulse Generation Circuit for Studying Waveform Effects on Neurostimulation.” It was published on November 14, 2019, in Electronics, Vol. 8. These will substantiate the proposals I have made that the immaterial mind, including the Mind of God, generate wave forms that stimulate spike trains of action potentials that transmit encoded specified information to bring about desired actions and purposes.

“Electrical stimulation parameters, such as waveform, amplitude, and stimulation frequency, have been shown to affect neurostimulation properties. . . . Electrical stimulation has demonstrated capabilities to alter the compound action potentials and long-term potentiation behavior of complex neural networks . . . . Neuromodulation has been observed at all levels, from individual nerve cells to brain regions, including the synapses. . . . waveform shape has an effect on electrical stimulation outcome.”

The authors refer to “the unknown neural mechanisms involved,” and this has been the subject of my research over almost 30 years, employing the neural synapse as the model for my studies of dualist interactionism. I will add additional posts that address how wave forms interact with neural synaptic networks.

Neural stimulation by waveforms

Warren M. Grill has studied the effects of stimulation waveform on the energy efficiency of neural excitation. His objective is to “understand the biophysical mechanisms underlying the effects of extracellular stimulation on neurons.” [This has been the focus of my own studies over the last 20 years, addressed in my two books and in blog posts on my website.] He continues stating that “Two important considerations when selecting or designing stimulation parameters are selectivity and efficiency. Selectivity is the ability to activate the targeted neural elements without activating the non-target neural elements. . . . Efficiency is achieving the required level of neural activation or response to achieve clinical efficacy with the minimal amount of stimulation. . . . The selectivity and efficiency of neural stimulation are dependent on the choice of the stimulation waveform.”

We see that multiple variables must be considered by the researchers to study biophysical mechanisms that exert effects on neuron stimulation. Our Creator God controls all these variables being uncovered over time by investigators to interact with the human spirit and soul! It is my judgment that God is allowing these kinds of studies to reveal to us how He communes with us! I continue:

Grill has learned that “the stimulation waveform shape can also be manipulated to increase stimulation selectivity between activation of the targeted neural elements and activation of non-target neural elements, and thereby increase the dynamic range between therapeutic effects and unwanted side effects [to the ultimate benefit of Man!] . . . . the energy required for stimulation is indeed dependent on the shape of the stimulation waveform, and highlight the importance of using an appropriately complex model to analyze the effects of waveform shape on neural excitation. . . . [there is an] optimal waveform for a particular application.”

In his concluding remarks Grill states that “the parameter space for electrical stimulation of the nervous system is extremely large, and the design and selection of stimulation parameters to achieve a desired response is a challenging problem” [giving testimony to the infinite power and intellect of our Creator God who designed these parameters for His purposes to achieve His desired responses in us!].

Waveform effects on neurostimulation

Aquiles Parodi and Jin-Woo Choi published an article in Electronics in 2019, Volume 8, p. 1344, that relates to the current consideration of waveform effects on neural stimulation. It is entitled, “A Pulse Generation Circuit for Studying Waveform Effects on Neurostimulation.” I am including a number of excerpts from their article:

“Electrical stimulation has demonstrated capabilities to alter the compound action potentials and long-term potentiation behavior of complex neural networks, even at low stimulation intensities, via an effect termed neuromodulation. Neuromodulation has been observed at all levels, from individual nerve cells to brain regions, including the synapses. . . . This effect is thought to arise from action potentials (APs) that are modulated as they propagate through individual nerve cells, depending on the nerve cell’s properties at the level of the soma, axon, and transmembrane proteins. This modulation can be enhanced or inhibited with neurostimulation. . . . Stimulation waveforms have been studied for their effects in neurostimulation. These include square or rectangular, exponential, ramp, sinusoidal, triangle and Gaussian waveforms.” These authors focused in their studies on the effects of signal shape on neurostimulation and have observed that “waveform shape has an effect on electrical stimulation outcome.”

Aspects of neural activity influenced by stimulation, in this case waveforms, have been addressed in both my books and in more recently posted blog posts on my website. I have presented preliminary evidence in previous blog posts that the immaterial, cognitive mind of humans has the capacity to generate waveforms that interact with the material components of the brain’s synaptic networks. The role of quantum tunneling has been included in these discussions, along with the recently defined potential role of quantum potential energy coupled with kinetic and potential energy in synaptic transmission. I repeat my proposal that the process of quantum tunneling constitutes the “non-material energy” identified by investigators such as William Dembski.

I am copying a lengthy excerpt from this article to show the complexity behind the generation of spike trains of action potentials and synaptic transmission that carry encoded information to effect various actions. It is our Creator God who designed these complex features with the ultimate Purpose of establishing intimate, personal communion with the crown of His creation, Man, by the power of His Holy Spirit. It is this dualist interaction that has been the focus of my own research.

“Design of stimulation waveforms is difficult, due to the diverse options and requirements for each anatomical stimulation target, the undetermined long-term effects of neurostimulation, the diversity of tissue, organ, and patient-level reactions, the unknown neural mechanisms involved [the focus of my studies], and the unknown side effects of stimulation methodology, including electrode type. The parameters of electrical stimulation waveforms, such as the amplitude, width and frequency of stimulation, have been shown to affect prosthetic sensory information in the vestibular nerve, the rate of excitation of individual nerves and nerve bundles, and the spatial selectivity within the bundles. Additionally, differences in stimulation waveforms, the polarity of current and direction, electric field shape and direction, and the temporal pattern of stimulation have been shown to have effects on the outcome of stimulation.”

We serve and worship an awesome God!

Holy Spirit lives in you

For nearly 30 years I have been studying interaction between the Holy Spirit and the human spirit and soul (mind, will and emotion), the neural synaptic network serving as the model for my investigations. I have shared what I have learned in my books and blogs, posting what I hope is compelling evidence for the dualist interaction that occurs between the immaterial Holy Spirit of God and the spirit and soul of Man through the material components of the neural synaptic networks.

Many posts have been made showing how wave forms interact with the spike trains of action potentials in neural synaptic networks. By this process specified information with meaning and purpose is transmitted via neural codes instantiated within the wave forms. Both electrochemical energy and non-material energy provide the power for this transmission. Neuroscientists are at work to uncover the mechanisms by which transmission occurs, mechanisms that go unseen except by application of the most current technological tools. It is exciting and challenging work, with promise for people having impaired sensory and motor functions. Might Hebrews 11:1-3 (NIV) apply?

Now faith is being sure of what we hope for and certain of what we do not see.

I have endeavored to show the concordance that is becoming evident between Scripture and neuroscience in dualist interaction between the Holy Spirit and the human spirit and soul and neural mechanisms. I am reminded of verses in the Book of Romans that apply to the mechanisms being revealed in this interaction. The Apostle Paul spoke to life in the Spirit in Romans 8: 9-11; 15-16 (NIV):

You, however, are controlled not by the sinful nature but by the Spirit, if the Spirit of God lives in you. And if anyone does not have the Spirit of Christ, he does not belong to Christ. But if Christ is in you, your body is dead because of sin, yet your spirit is alive because of righteousness. And if the Spirit of him who raised Jesus from the dead is living in you, he who raised Christ from the dead will also give life to your mortal bodies through his Spirit, who lives in you. . . . For you did not receive a spirit that makes you a slave again to fear, but you received the Spirit of sonship. And by him we cry, ‘Abba, Father.’ The Spirit himself testifies with our spirit that we are God’s children.

Cortical activity waves

Paul Koch and Gerry Leisman have published an article entitled “Cortical Activity Waves Are the Physical Carriers of Memory and Thought.” Readers of my more recent blogs have noted how coherent waveforms are transmitted through synaptic networks that are encoded with specified information within spike trains of action potentials. The authors offer that “coherent waves are instrumental in the retrieval of memory and random waves embody original thought.”

I am encouraged that these authors are linking cortical waves with thought which I have associated with the activity of an immaterial cognitive mind. They continue, “. . . there are numerous different possible neural firing patterns . . . . If each active subset of individual cortical cells represents a distinct thought [possibly corresponding to cortical pyramidal modules with distinct patterns of wave forms], there are about 10^6 billion . . . possibilities for about 20 billion cortical cells. . . . [The authors do not] “describe how these patterns are decoded into a mixture of the semantic content of different wave-memories and memories of previous thoughts. . . . All mammals are subject to cortical activity waves, but only humans can associate language (words, music, fine art, dance, algebra, etc.) with the waves, and thus can have memories of our thoughts.”

In my blogs and books I have provided evidence that wave “patterns” are the neural codes within spike trains of action potentials, and I submit that memory is instantiated within neural codes having meaning, or semantics, and purpose. Are waves generated by “original thought” truly random, or are they the product of cognitive intent? Humans have been uniquely created by God to transmit linguistic neural codes that are actively interpreted by the immaterial mind and are archived in memory. I suggest that this point applies to “words, music, fine art, dance, algebra, etc.” The authors make no direct mention of the cognitive mind, but dualist interaction between an immaterial mind and the neural synaptic network processes can give a more complete analysis of the excellent observations made by these authors in my view.

Wisdom from the Spirit

I am posting selected verses from the Bible that reflect the dualist interaction I discuss in my books and blogs between the indwelling Holy Spirit and the spirit and soul of repentant Man. Articles cited from the neurosciences reveal the mechanisms of neural synaptic networks through which the immaterial mind of Man and Mind of God commune. It is a concordance between science and theology for which I have hopefully provided compelling evidence.

I now post selections from 1 Corinthians 2:10-16 and 6:17 (NIV). As these verses are read it is my expectation that the reader will find that an understanding of dualist interaction gives a depth of meaning perhaps otherwise missed.

The Spirit searches all things, even the deep things of God. For who among men knows the thoughts of a man except the man’s spirit within him? In the same way no one knows the thoughts of God except the Spirit of God. We have not received the spirit of the world but the Spirit who is from God, that we may understand what God has freely given us. This is what we speak, not in words taught us by human wisdom but in words taught by the Spirit, expressing spiritual truths in spiritual words. The man without the Spirit does not accept the things that come from the Spirit of God, for they are foolishness to him, and he cannot understand them, because they are spiritually discerned. The spiritual man makes judgments about all things, but he himself is not subject to any man’s judgment: For who has known the mind of the Lord that he may instruct him? But we have the mind of Christ.

But he who unites himself with the Lord is one with him in spirit.

Power of the Holy Spirit and God's love

I am posting these verses from Paul’s letter to the Ephesians, 3:14-19 (NIV), that are in concordance with content I have shared in my books and blogs that speak to dualist interaction between the Holy Spirit and the human spirit and soul, the synaptic network making it possible. It speaks to the boundless love of God for us:

For this reason I kneel before the Father, from whom his whole family in heaven and on earth derives its name. I pray that out of his glorious riches he may strengthen you with power through his Spirit in your inner being, so that Christ may dwell in your hearts through faith. And I pray that you, being rooted and established in love, may have power, together with all the saints, to grasp how wide and long and high and deep is the love of Christ, and to know this love that surpasses knowledge - that you may be filled to the measure of all the fullness of God.

Tufts of pyramidal apical dendrites

My interest in the tufts of pyramidal apical dendrites is long standing, and I have addressed aspects of their function in earlier blogs. As I reviewed Friedrich Beck’s article referenced in my July 2nd blog I noted his comments about these tufts. The neocortex consists of six lamina. “The pyramidal apical dendrites finish in a tuft-like branching in lamina I.” He stated that he was in agreement with Fleischhauer and coworkers who published articles in 1984 and 1987 that posited that “the apical bundles of dendrites . . . are the basic anatomical units of the neocortex. . . . It has been proposed that these bundles are the cortical units for reception [Italics added], which would give them a preeminent role.” Specifically, can the function of the tufts be expanded to possibly include reception of cognitive wave forms?

The tufts lie at the surface of cortical modules in lamina I and are known to have numerous neural interconnections with the dendritic tufts of adjacent and distant modules. Within modules are specific baseline wave frequencies, amplitudes and shapes that serve as “detectors” of nerve impulses as proposed by Eccles and noted in previous blog posts. I ask if wave forms generated by the cognitive mind pass across cortical modules and become linked with synchronous modular wave forms via the neural spines of apical dendritic tufts? Such a process would enable neural codes within specified wave forms to be transmitted through coherent synaptic networks to stimulate activities. In asking this question I am accepting the immateriality of the cognitive mind and its capacity to generate wave forms that interact with the material synaptic networks of the brain, a dualist interaction.

The immaterial mind of God

I am posting several quotations taken from an article by Scott Youngren and published by The Think Institute. It is entitled “Metaphysics, the Matrix, and the Mind of God.” They speak to the immateriality and primacy of the Mind of God.

Since the time of the ancient Greeks, there have been two basic pictures of ultimate reality among Western intellectuals, what the Germans call a Weltanschauung, or worldview. According to one worldview, mind is the primary or ultimate reality. On this view, material reality either issues from a preexisting mind, or it is shaped by a preexistent intelligence, or both . . . This view of reality is often called idealism to indicate that ideas come first and matter comes later. Theism is the version of idealism that holds that God is the source of the ideas that gave rise to and shaped the material world.

The opposite view holds that the physical universe or nature is the ultimate reality. In this view, either matter or energy (or both) are the things from which everything else comes. They are self-existent and do not need to be created or shaped by mind . . . . In this view matter comes first, and conscious mind arrives on the scene much later and only then as a by-product of material processes and undirected evolutionary change. This worldview is called naturalism or materialism.

Stephen C. Meyer

For myself, faith begins with a realization that a supreme intelligence brought the universe into being and created man. It is not difficult for me to have this faith, for it is incontrovertible that where there is a plan there is intelligence - an orderly, unfolding universe testifies to the truth of the most majestic statement ever uttered - “In the beginning God.”

James Clerk Maxwell

God is a mathematician of a very high order and He used advanced mathematics in constructing the universe.

Max Planck

It is evident that an acquaintance with natural laws means no less than an acquaintance with the mind of God therein expressed.

Albert Einstein

An equation for me has no meaning unless it expresses a thought of God.

James Joule

Is intelligent mind an ultimate and irreducible feature of reality? Indeed, is it the ultimate nature of reality? Or is mind and consciousness an unforeseen and unintended product of basically material processes of evolution? If you look at the history of philosophy, it soon becomes clear that almost all the great classical philosophers took the first of these views. Plato, Aristotle, Anselm, Aquinas, Descartes, Leibniz, Spinoza, Locke, Berkeley, Kant, Hegel - they all argued that the ultimate reality, often hidden under the appearances of the material world or time and space, is mind or spirit.

Srinivasa Ramanujam

In the New Story of science the whole universe - including matter, energy, space, and time - is a one-time event and had a definite beginning. But something must have always existed; for if ever absolutely nothing existed, then nothing would exist now, since nothing comes from nothing. The material universe cannot be the thing that always existed because matter had a beginning. It is 12 to 20 billion years old. This means that whatever has always existed is non-material. The only non-material reality seems to be mind. If mind is what has always existed, then matter must have been brought into existence by a mind that always was. This points to an intelligent, eternal being who created all things. Such a being is what we mean by the term God.

Sir Isaac Newton

The immaterial soul

Dr. J. P. Moreland composed an article for the ministry Reasons To Believe (www.reasons.org) addressing the immateriality of the human soul. It was entitled “Body and Soul Part 2: Why the Soul Is Immaterial.” I will post several excerpts from his informative article which provides support for dualist interaction between the immaterial human spirit and soul (and the Holy Spirit) and the material synaptic networks of the human brain. He begins his article with the following:

“. . . a human being’s soul or self . . . is immaterial (or non-material).” Moreland states that the soul is a substance. “Substances are basic fundamental things. They are not in other things or aspects of other things. . . . Substance dualists assert that as a human, [a person] consists of an immaterial substantial soul with a physical body that is not identical to the soul. . . . substance dualists believe that the brain is a physical thing with physical properties and the mind or soul is a mental substance that has mental properties. . . . a human being’s self or ego [is] an immaterial substance that bears consciousness.”

Self awareness, the "I"

Moreland addresses the concept of self awareness, of the “I:”

“. . . through self-awareness, one gains an awareness of the fact that “I” who was and is (and will be) present as the owner of all the [life] experiences. . . . These two facts - “I” am the owner of self-experience, and “I” am an enduring self who exists as the same possessor of all self-experience through time - show that a person is not identical to his experiences. Self (or “I”) is the thing that has them. In short, “I” is a mental substance. Only a single enduring self can relate and unify experiences, a fact that property dualists and physicalists cannot adequately account for or explain away.”

Moreland’s statements give compelling support to the immateriality of the human soul, the mind, the self, the “I.”

Free will

Moreland addresses free will in his article:

“To say that a human is a free will being is to say that humans exercise what is called libertarian freedom. . . . A person’s choice is up to the individual . . . . [One] acts as an agent who is the first cause or ultimate originator of [their] own actions. Moreover, [one’s] reasons for acting do not partially or fully cause [their] actions. . . . Rather, [one’s] reasons are the teleological goals - the purposes or the ends - for the sake of which [one] acts.

Moreland states that “If physicalism is true, then human free will does not exist. Instead, determinism is true. . . . Further, since free acts seem to be for the sake of goals or ends, if physicalism . . . is true, there is no ultimate purpose and thus, there can be no libertarian free acts.”

I have pointed out in past blogs and in my books that it has been the intent of the Spirit of our Creator God to have a personal relationship with us. That has been, and is, His “ultimate purpose.” Jesus Christ’s atoning sacrifice for us has renewed our ability in repentance to have a dualist interaction, a bidirectional relationship, with the indwelling Holy Spirit.

Stan Lennard
Minds in Communion - 12

Information and the Mind of God

Information is a subject not often addressed in the scientific and theological literature, though it is on the increase. I have discussed this topic in both of my books and in many blog posts. I am redirecting my posts to address information, and I emphasize that the Mind of God is the ultimate Source of ALL information. Believers blessed by the indwelling of the Holy Spirit have access to information given by the Mind of God.

Information, language of science

I begin my posts on information with excerpts from the book by Hans Christian von Baeyer, entitled Information: The New Language of Science. Information is neither matter nor energy. It is an entity on its own that precedes both. It emanates from a mind, the ultimate Source being the Mind of God.

von Baeyer discusses the transmission of information by the human brain, a topic I have addressed extensively in my books and in several blog posts:

“Even the brain, which consists of a vast neural network of cells exchanging electrical and chemical signals, turns out to be a powerful processor of information coded [Italics added] for the most part in the form of off-on signals, zeroes and ones.”

Neural codes are instantiated within spike trains of action potentials, corresponding to von Baeyer’s “off-on signals, zeroes and ones.”

The Lord gives wisdom, knowledge, understanding

Specified information with meaning and purpose comes from the Mind of God through the indwelling Holy Spirit in repentant believers. In Proverbs 2:6 we see the reality of the transmission of wisdom, knowledge and understanding to faithful believers: For the Lord gives wisdom, from his mouth come knowledge and understanding.

In my books and blogs I have addressed the blessing that we have to hear directly from God through His Holy Spirit, a blessing restored by the grace and love of God through the sin sacrifice of His Son, Jesus Christ.

Minds of God and Man give form to information

What is information? How is it defined? von Baeyer addresses this question. Though it is often claimed that information can be generated by natural selection, it has been emphasized here and in my books that information can only come from a mind. From von Baeyer:

“Etymology offers a clue [to the definition]. ‘Information’, ‘deformation’, conformation’, ‘transformation’, and ‘reformation’ obviously derive from ‘formation’, which, in turn, comes from ‘form’. Information is therefore the infusion of form on some previously unformed entity, just as de-, con-, trans-, and re-formation refer to the undoing, copying, changing, and renewing of forms. Information refers to moulding or shaping a formless heap - imposing a form onto something.”

Our Creator God had infinite options by which to actualize information into all He created and sustains to this day. That He created our universe in three spatial and a single time dimension is evidence that He imposed form from the possibilities so that we see and can live successfully on Earth in our space-time. As I expand on these points it is my hope that information will become a reality that gives glory to the Mind of God.

Information rules out possibilities

In my books and several blog posts I have referred to the work of William A. Dembski, specifically to his book Being as Communion: A Metaphysics of Information. I complement my last blog with selected comments by Dembski in Chapter 3, “Information as Ruling Out Possibilities”:

“In everyday life, information is associated with intelligent agents who form statements to convey meaning. Accordingly, intelligent agents convey information to other intelligent agents by making meaningful statements within a system of language. Information, therefore, customarily presupposes intelligence, language, and semantics. . . . In general, information is about realizing possibilities by ruling out others. Unless possibilities are ruled out, no information can be conveyed. To say, ‘It’s raining or it’s not raining’ is uninformative precisely because this statement rules out no possibilities. On the other hand, to say, ‘It’s raining’ rules out the possibility ‘It’s not raining’ and therefore conveys information. . . . Writing in the context of human communication, Robert Stalnaker put it this way, ‘To learn something, to acquire information, is to rule out possibilities. To understand the information conveyed in a communication is to know what possibilities would be excluded by its truth.’”

I have shared with documentation in my books that the neural code is a linguistic code by which specified (meaningful) information is transmitted from a source of intelligence to and through the synaptic networks of a receptor’s brain.

Entropy and information

von Baeyer discusses entropy in the context of information in his book. He referenced Ludwig Boltzmann who “pointed out that . . . the value of entropy rises from zero, when we know all about a system, to its maximum value when we know least. . . . Entropy is . . . about our lack of information.”

God, who is the ultimate Source of all information, held the “maximum value” of informational entropy at the Beginning of creation when He had not yet specified how information would be instantiated into given creations. All possibilities existed in the Mind of God. As God specified how information would be selectively actualized, possibilities were ruled out, and aspects of given created systems became known with the value of entropy approaching, or becoming, zero.

As one reads this blog post one may understand better how information, as a topic, can escape one’s attention and comprehension. I have addressed entropy in the context of information here and in my books so that readers can come to an understanding of it, especially beholding God’s glory in His creation of our universe and all within it.

In my more recent blog posts I have discussed wave function and wave forms in the context of synaptic transmission. I refer the reader back to the three part series entitled “Waves in Our Brains.” von Baeyer discussed the wave function in Chapter 5 of his book, and I include a significant excerpt from it that deals ultimately with . . . information:

“If the wave function does not represent a faithful picture of an atom, what exactly is it? In different experiments one can measure the positions, the velocities, the energy levels, the magnetic effects and a variety of other properties of the electron. All these properties can be predicted from the wave function, which therefore acts as a succinct mathematical encoding of information resembling a map of potentiality - a catalogue of possibilities. If the wave function is nothing but a storehouse of information needed to make correct predictions, then the stuff of the world is really, at bottom, information.”

Wave function, definition

von Baeyer asks, “But what is the wave function? Its interpretation as a probability provides a clue. Probabilities . . . are shorthand expressions of partial knowledge - of information. Similarly, the wave function of an electron in an atom contains information about the likelihood of finding the electron in various places. It is a map of potentialities - a catalogue of possibilities. It is information, pure and simple; and its shape determines the form of the atom.”

I share this quote from von Baeyer since it is important to understand what a wave function is and how it differs from wave length and wave form. I have discussed wave forms as they apply to synaptic transmission through neural networks in some of my latest blog posts.

The quantum and human nature

von Baeyer discusses Anton Zeilinger’s work in quantum physics in the last chapter of his book. I share an excerpt from his book that will serve as the foundation for points I will make in subsequent blog posts that relate quantum mechanics and information:

Like John Wheeler he [Zeilinger] wants to know why the quantum? Like Schrodinger he wants the answer to speak to the broad public; and like Pauli he feels intuitively that the answer, when it comes, will turn out to illuminate human nature itself.”

The relationship between quantum mechanics and information rests in probabilities.

Information, the root of quantum mechanics

von Baeyer cites comments by Niels Bohr made to Anton Zeilinger concerning the “mediating role of information”:

“Its crucial, underlying assumption is Bohr’s proclamation that physics in general, and quantum mechanics in particular, do not describe the world itself, only what we are able to say about it. Bohr demands that we wake up from the spell of Democritus - the illusion that we can come to grips with the objective material world, without acknowledging, or even trying to understand, the mediating role of information. We never see a chair, Bohr would say: we receive sense impressions that give us information which our brains somehow process into the idea . . . of chair [via instantiated neural codes transmitted through synaptic networks and “read”/interpreted by the human mind, addressed in my books]. We don’t see, or detect, or measure an atom: we gather information about the atom and encode it in a mathematical construct called a wave function, which enables us to make predictions about information we may gather in future experiments. To leave information, from which we gain all of our knowledge of nature, out of consideration when discussing the nature of the physical world is a gross and outdated oversimplification. If, however, we accept that information, not matter, lies at the root of quantum mechanics, reductionism, that faithful, flawed handmaiden of science, requires us to ask: what are the fundamental building blocks of information? Zeilinger replies: propositions; Wheeler calls them answers to questions: and the simplest of those, in turn, is an elementary proposition, a yes-or-no question with an answer that’s called a ‘bit’ of information. It is impossible to imagine a simpler question than one that requires a yes-or-no answer.”

I am sharing complex descriptions of information and its relation to the quantum and ultimately to the human mind, as well as the Mind of God! We must understand the fundamental importance of information and how it relates to energy and matter. In upcoming blog posts this topic will be addressed.

God's free play through quantum probabilities

In my studies and writings I have relied significantly upon the work of William A. Dembski. I am sharing his comments that consider how God, who is immaterial and Spirit, interacts with the material world, including the human brain. Quantum mechanics gives nondeterminism to the universe which characterizes it as being informationally open and accommodating free will. Here is Dembski’s informative quote taken from my book, The Boundless Love of God: A Holy Spirit Story:

“. . . such [an open] universe will produce . . . patterns of events that stand out against the backdrop of randomness. . . . Such patterns [intended by God] could reasonably be interpreted as constituting novel information inputted from outside the system . . . in a nondeterministic universe, diving action could impart information into matter [e.g. a neural synaptic network] without violating any physical laws by which matter operates . . . A deity capable of co-opting randomness would impart information by arranging outcomes [with small probabilities and specification], but do so by channeling the material energy in ways that violate no principle governing matter. If divine action takes this form, the problem of finding the missing material energy by which God introduces novel information into the world simply does not arise. . . . information is then being transferred without any transfer of material energy. . . . Quantum mechanics . . . offers such a picture of the universe, allowing God free play at the quantum level. . . . In a world of irreducibly chance or random events [integral to the neural synapse], as some interpretations of quantum theory allow, [the Mind of] God can channel such events [and communications] toward preordained ends.”

Since the mind of Man is created in the image of the Mind of God, the postulate that Dembski shares reasonably applies to the immaterial mind of Man which can also channel communications of encoded information toward preordained ends with meaning and purpose.

Special divine action

I cite Alvin Plantinga in my second book who also addresses the openness of the universe to novel information. Here are my comments:

Plantinga states that classical science does not claim that the universe is causally closed. His statements are consistent with special divine action in the world. Just as God, who is immaterial and Spirit, can act in the physical universe, so too can the immaterial minds of human beings. There is no objection to special divine action or for human free action, dualistically conceived. Plantinga goes further to state that the indeterminism of quantum mechanics offers even less of a problem for divine action than classical science. “. . . special divine action . . . is by no means incompatible with quantum mechanics . . . because . . . quantum mechanics doesn’t determine a specific outcome for a given set of initial conditions, but instead merely assigns probabilities to the possible outcomes.” Plantinga states further, “Perhaps He is also very much a hands on God, constantly active in history, leading, guiding, persuading and redeeming His people, blessing them with ‘the internal Witness of the Holy Spirit’ (Calvin) or ‘the Internal instigation of the Holy Spirit’ (Acquinas) and conferring upon them the gift of faith.”

Information, the primal substance

I will now post selected excerpts from Dembski’s book, Being as Communion: A Metaphysics of Information, some of which I have included in my books and have made reference to in blogs. I strongly recommend this book to those who wish to understand the theory of communication. “For a thing to be real it must be able to communicate with other things. If this is so, then the problem of being receives a straightforward resolution: to be is to be in communion.” [Taken from the back cover piece] Dembski compellingly documents that “information in nature is ‘communion,’” and this extends to communion between the Mind of God and the mind of Man by the power of the indwelling Holy Spirit.

Intelligence creates information

“[Dembski’s] argument is that intelligence creates information, which in turn can manifest itself materially, and that intelligence is thus the preeminent first cause. This puts matter causally downstream from both intelligence and information, making it a subordinate and derivative concept. . . .Dembski not only takes information to be the fundamental substance, but also clearly believes . . . that this substance ultimately originates with a personal God who intentionally gives being to the world, ordering its material structure and guiding its inhabitants for a purpose.”

All possible worlds and information

I cite Dembski, who states, “As a Christian theist, I’m happy to regard the collection of all possible worlds as residing in the mind of God and then see God, in an act of creation, as actualizing one world, ours, to the exclusion of others. . . . Unlike materialism, which makes matter the starting point for inquiry, information makes the actual world and the possibilities associated with it the starting point. Information thus allows the world to be whatever it is. . . . We know that a world exists and that it realizes certain possibilities to the exclusion of others, thereby generating information.”

Intelligence vs nature

Dembski presents an interesting and informative discussion of intelligence as it relates to nature:

“In everyday experience, we distinguish between two sources of information: intelligence and nature. . . . an intelligence, to advance a purpose, may identify one possibility to the exclusion of others and thereby produce information. Alternatively, nature, as a system of causes and effects, may bring about some event to the exclusion of others, and thereby produce information. . . . a human intelligence, to advance a purpose, performs a conceptual act, identifying one possibility to the exclusion of others. Such an act requires thought and consciousness, and yet in humans makes use of neurophysiology [encoded spike trains of action potentials that transmit information through synaptic networks, as discussed in my books and specific blog posts], which in turn is part of nature. Human intelligence may therefore be regarded as natural even if it is not purely material. . . . According to information theorist Douglas Robertson, the defining characteristic of intelligent agents . . . is their ability to create and communicate information. That’s what intelligences do for a living. . . . it follows that if nature is itself the act of a creative intelligence, then nature is a form of information and nature’s operations may themselves be regarded as intelligent and teleological. Nature’s intelligence would in that case be a derived intelligence. . . . Because materialism gives primacy to matter, it downgrades the role of intelligence in nature, conceiving of nature in purely material terms, thus making intelligence a byproduct of material nature rather than its source and purpose. Materialism sees matter as fundamentally non-intelligent, and it thus needs to constitute intelligence out of matter.”

Nature, a created order

Dembski addresses God’s creations as teleological:

“. . . from the vantage of Christian theism, I . . . see nature as a created order endowed by its creator with certain powers, all of which may be regarded as teleological since they were intended by God. But Christianity goes further, holding to a supernatural deity, with God acting in ways that transcend nature’s inherent powers. . . . Christian theism therefore regards nature as inherently incomplete, finding its completion in God. . . . Christian theism is compatible with God delegating to nature many of its powers (cf. the medieval distinction between primary and secondary causes, secondary causes operating under their own power, instituted by the primary cause, God).”

Information, neither matter nor energy

Dembski cites cybernetics founder, Norbert Weiner, who “thought that information could not be subsumed under matter: ‘Information is information, not matter or energy. No materialism which does not admit this can survive at the present day.’”

Patterns of information

Dembski discusses the patterns of information that are problems for materialism:

“The problem for materialism and empiricism in reconstituting the world, whether in terms of elemental matter or elemental sensory experiences respectively, is ultimately informational. When we do science, we don’t encounter matter in its raw state nor do we encounter sensory experiences in their raw state. Rather, we encounter certain patterns to the exclusion of others [Dembski’s ‘small probabilities’ selected by an intelligent mind]. In other words, we encounter information. The material and sensory features associated with these patterns are secondary. Indeed, those very features are themselves patterned and thus informational. The patterns, or equivalently the types of information conveyed, are primary.”

Effected spoken word

“The expression ‘effected spoken word’ . . . means this: an agent, in forming an intention [a thought of a cognitive mind], accomplishes it by first articulating the intention as a word [for example, the linguistic neural code I have discussed in my books and in many blogs], then transmitting that word through a speech act [for example, the transmission of neural codes through synchronous synaptic networks], and finally ensuring that this spoken word achieves its desired effect [the action end point that completes the definition of information, as discussed by Werner Gitt]. . . . When the agent is God intent on creating a world, creation likewise becomes an effected spoken word. Compare Isaiah 55:11, God speaking, ‘So shall my word be that goeth forth out of my mouth: it shall not return unto me void, but it shall accomplish that which I please, and it shall prosper in the thing whereto I sent it.’” (William A. Dembski)

Primacy of information for science

Dr. Dembski challenges the long-held primacy of matter for science, with the claim that reduction to materialistic explanations have a hold on primacy. I am posting a quotation from Dembski:

“. . . information is, in the end, always the product of a creative intelligence. This would make intelligence rather than information the most basic metaphysical entity [the Mind of God], placing all-sufficiency with intelligence rather than information. Indeed, as a theist, I regard an intelligent being, God, as the prime reality. The issue here, however, is not the primacy of intelligence or teleology for metaphysics. The issue, rather, is the primacy of information for science. I am arguing that information should properly be regarded as the prime entity and object of study in science, displacing matter from its current position of eminence.”

Energy and information

We have read posts that deal with intelligence, information and matter, but what about energy? Dembski addresses the topic of energy in the following excerpts:

“Information changes dynamically, with information passing in, through, and out of matter. . . . Anything that exhibits information needed at some point to be imparted with information. What causes information to undergo such dynamic transformation? The usual answer to this question is stated in one word: energy. . . . energy is logically downstream from information in the sense that energy is always inferred from information, but not vice versa. . . . Energy . . . seems unavoidable in discussions about the dynamics of information. . . . When information happens - and it happens all the time - what causes it to happen? . . . energy is as good an answer as exists. This answer makes energy the causal glue that connects diverse items of information in an informational universe.”

Dembski specifically mentions an immaterial energy in this context, and I have addressed such energy in blog posts that discuss the role of wave forms in the transmission of linguistic neural codes through synaptic networks by the process of quantum tunneling.

Nonmaterial energy

I cite Dembski:

“More generally, in any inquiry, scientific or otherwise, if we are trying to understand an information transfer, the first thing we witness is an information relationship, and only then are we in a position to uncover how energy might have given rise to that relationship. Some form of energy must presumably be involved - we are supposing that information transfers require energy transfers (though not necessarily material energy transfers). Moreover, if the energy can’t be material, then it must be nonmaterial.”

Nondeterministic universe - informationally open

Dembski states that “a nondeterministic universe can be informationally porous and thus open to action by a deity able to impart information without imparting material energy. Quantum mechanics, when interpreted as a fundamentally probabilistic theory, offers such a picture of the universe, allowing God free play at the quantum level. . . . In a world of irreducibly chance or random events, as some interpretations of quantum theory allow, God can channel such events toward preordained ends.”

We have seen in my books and in selected blogs that synaptic transmission is stochastic, or random. It is a nondeterminism that allows the intent of a mind, including the Mind of God, to influence the direction and intensity of spike trains of action potentials through synchronous synaptic networks to bring about specific actions. Quantum mechanics provides the “trigger” mechanism for such action by the process of quantum tunneling, and it is wave forms with frequency, amplitude and shape that serve as the nonmaterial energy for specified information transmission, interacting with the material electrochemical energies along dendrites and axons in the nervous system.

Defining property of intelligence

Dembski addresses the property that gives definition to intelligence:

“The defining property of intelligence is its ability to create information. . . . The ability of intelligence to create information should be more obvious and convincing to us than any claim of the natural sciences. Why? Because (1) we ourselves are intelligent beings who create information all the time through our thoughts and language and (2) the natural sciences themselves are logically downstream from our ability to create information (if we were not information creators, we could not formulate scientific theories, much less search for those that are empirically adequate, in which case there would be no science). Materialist philosophy, however, has all this backwards, making a materialist science primary and then defining our intelligence out of existence because materialism leaves no room for it (except as unintended motions and modifications of matter). The saner course would be to leave no room for materialism.”

Creation of information

Dembski argues in Chapter 20, “The Creation of Information,” that “intelligence is the ultimate source of information, . . . I come at this question as a Christian for whom God, as creator, is the ultimate source of all there is, and thus of all the information in the world. My model for information creation, therefore, cannot be bottom up, as in trying to reconstitute information from material processes, but rather must be top down, as in trying to understand the creation of information from the vantage of a creative intelligence (in particular, the Christian God).”

Etymology of intelligent

Dembski provides an excellent etymology of “intelligent” in his book:

The word intelligent comes from the Latin [language]. It stems from two Latin words, the preposition inter, meaning between, and the Latin . . . verb lego, meaning to choose or select. . . . According to its Latin etymology, intelligence therefore consists in choosing between. In an act of information creation, an intelligence chooses which possibility within a matrix of possibility to actualize. In the ultimate act of information creation, a supreme intelligence chooses which world among all possible worlds to actualize. The world so chosen becomes the real world. . . . Thus, for me, a nonmaterial trinitarian God is the supreme intelligence and ultimate reality. Moreover, this God creates via speech acts. God speaks and things happen. Or, alternatively, God communicates information and new possibilities are actualized.”

Wave forms in our brains, revisited

In my books and a number of blog posts I have presented information that shows the possible role wave forms play in synaptic transmission. Their transmission involves quantum tunneling in ionic channel and synaptic vesicle components. The random/stochastic property of this transmission allows for the immaterial intent/will of an intelligence to generate specified information (with small probabilities) that is actualized with direction through the material components of synapses and their networks. It is a complex and fascinating process that is under investigation by neuroscientists who now have advanced technology to assist their studies.

There is increasing evidence that the “nonmaterial energy” discussed by Dembski and other authors whom I have quoted in my more recent blogs is expressed within the frequencies, amplitudes, shapes and phases of wave forms that are distinct from the material electrochemical energies of action potentials. This nonmaterial energy serves as the “causal glue” (to quote Dembski) between the specified information emanating from a mind and the linguistic codes instantiated within the material spike trains of action potentials that travel through neural synaptic networks to effect intended action. I have endeavored to present this information with documentation to give compelling support to the concept of dualist interaction between the immaterial mind, including the Mind of God, and the material components of the human brain.

Stan Lennard
Minds in Communion - 11

Eschatological Spirit of the early church

Gordon Fee shared in the Preface to his book, Paul, the Spirit, and the People of God, comments that drove the writing of his book. I am sharing several of them that should give contemporary Christians reason to be more effective in their witness to the Holy Spirit.

“The bottom line is . . . the generally ineffective witness and perceived irrelevancy of the church in Western culture. Here, it seems to me, is where the real difference between Paul and us emerges, where in a culture similar to ours the early believers seem to have been more effective than we are. I am convinced this is due in large part to their experience of the reality of the Spirit’s presence. . . . Crucial to this experience was the early church’s understanding of the Spirit as the fulfillment of Jewish hopes of the return of the divine presence . . . . What this meant for early Christians was that the Spirit was not only the personal presence of God in and among them (both individually and corporately) but that their understanding of God had to be broadened so as to become trinitarian. . . . Equally crucial to the experience of the Spirit was the early church’s self-understanding as “thoroughly eschatological,” in the “already/not yet” sense [which I have discussed in my books]. The first believers really believed that the future had begun, being attested by the gift of the outpoured Spirit, who also served as the guarantee of the future consummation. . . . This personal, powerful, experience of the eschatological Spirit not only transformed them individually but made them effective in their being the people of the good news in pagan Grego-Roman culture. And this is why I think they had the better of it, and why we would do well to recapture something of that reality.”

Already but not yet

The theological concept of “already but not yet” holds that believers are actively taking part in the kingdom of God, although the kingdom will not reach its full expression until sometime in the future. We are “already” in the kingdom, but we do “not yet” see it in its glory. The “already but not yet” theology is related to kingdom theology or inaugurated eschatology.

The “already but not yet” paradigm was developed by Princeton theologian Gerhardus Vos early in the 20th century. (https://www.gotquestions.org/already-not-yet.html)

The marginalized Holy Spirit

Gordon Fee expressed a concern when Jesus Christ is the sole focus in the church, although He is rightly to be taught. He pointed out that “. . . we are less sure about the Holy Spirit. Despite the affirmations in our creeds and hymns and the lip service paid to the Spirit in our occasional conversations, the Spirit has been largely marginalized both in the halls of learning and in the life of the church as a community of faith.

“. . . too often missing . . . are two further matters that, for Paul, lie at the very heart of faith. First, the Spirit as person, the promised return of God’s own personal presence with his people; second, the Spirit as eschatological fulfillment, who both reconstitutes God’s people anew and empowers us to live the life of the future in our between-the-times existence - between the time of Christ’s first and second coming.

“If the church is going to be effective in our postmodern world, we need to stop paying mere lip service to the Spirit and to recapture Paul’s perspective: the Spirit as the experienced, empowering return of God’s own personal presence in and among us, who enables us to live as a radically eschatological people in the present world while we await the consummation.”

And through my studies I have shared the process by which, at least in part, the Holy Spirit interacts with us in repentance in our time. It is a dualist interaction created by God so that He can have a personal communion with His people.

Renewed presence of God

The outpouring of the Spirit meant for Paul that God had fulfilled his promise to dwell once again in and among his people.

This statement was posted at the beginning of Fee’s second chapter. He went on to say, “God has made us this way, in his own image, because he himself is a personal, relational being. The great problem with the fall is that we lost not only our vision of God (that is, his true character has been distorted) but also our relationship with God, and thus no longer knew his abiding presence. For Paul the coming of Christ and the Spirit changed all of this forever.”

Indwelling of the Holy Spirit

Citing Fee, “Here, then, is one of the more significant areas where the Spirit represents both continuity and discontinuity between the old and new covenants. The continuity is to be found in the promised renewal of God’s presence with his people; the discontinuity lies in the radically new way God has revisited them - indwelling them individually as well as corporately by his Spirit.”

Purchased for God's glory

In his letter to the Corinthians Gordon Fee points out that the Apostle Paul appealed “to the presence of the Spirit in their lives in the context of the saving work of Christ. In ‘purchasing’ them for God’s glory, Christ also purchased their bodies, as evidenced by the Holy Spirit, whose temple they are because God now dwells not in temples made by human hands, but in temples constructed by his own hands. Thus they are not their own, to do with their bodies as they please. They belong to the God who purchased them through Christ’s [redeeming, sin] sacrifice and now indwells them by his Spirit.”

Gospel is about salvation

Gordon Fee shares that “at the heart of Paul’s theology is his gospel, and his gospel is essentially about salvation - God’s saving a people for his name through the redeeming work of Christ and the applying work of the Spirit.”

God's love is the foundation of salvation

Fee expressed “that the love of God is the foundation of Paul’s view of salvation . . . . The grace of our Lord Jesus Christ is what gave concrete expression to that love; through Christ’s suffering and death on behalf of his loved ones, God accomplished salvation for them at one moment in human history. The participation in the Holy Spirit continually makes that love and grace real in the life of the believer and the believing community. The koinonia (‘fellowship/participation’) of the Holy Spirit . . . is how the living God not only brings people into an intimate and abiding relationship with himself, as the God of all grace, but also causes them to participate in all the benefits of that grace and salvation - that is, by indwelling them in the present with his own presence and guaranteeing their final eschatological glory.”

The love of God

I am sharing wonderful comments from Gordon Fee about how the Apostle Paul considered the love of God:

“For Paul the ‘love of God’ was no mere abstraction. God’s [boundless, my addition] love, the most essential reality about his character and the absolute predicate of our existence, has been demonstrated historically in its most lavish and expansive expression through Christ’s death for his enemies. . . . But such love is not merely an objective historical event. By the presence of the Spirit, God’s love, played out to the full in Christ, is an experienced reality in the heart of the believer. This is what the Spirit has so richly ‘shed abroad in our hearts.’ If we are not thus overtaken by God himself at this crucial point, then all else is lost. . . . What rectifies all of this for us is not simply the fact of God’s love - although in some ways that would surely be enough - but that God’s love has been effectively realized in the experience of the believer. God’s love for us has been ‘poured out’ as a prodigal, experienced reality by the presence of the Holy Spirit, whom God has also lavishly poured out into our hearts.”

The Spirit's presence of the future

I cite Gordon Fee in the following statements: “For Paul, . . . salvation in Christ is a fundamentally eschatological reality, meaning, first of all, that God’s final salvation of his people has already been accomplished by Christ. . . . This essential framework likewise causes Paul to see the church as an end-time community, whose members live in the present as those stamped with eternity. We live as strangers on earth; our true citizenship is in heaven (Phil 3:20). . . . Believers have tasted of the life to come; and the full and final realization of the future is so certain that God’s new people become heavenly radicals as they live in the ‘already’ but ‘not yet’ of the present age.”

The seal, metaphor for the Spirit

Fee writes, “In Paul, as Ephesians 1:13 and 4:30 make certain, the seal is a metaphor for the Spirit, by whom God has marked believers and claimed them as his own.”

Spirit gives us life

Fee shares that “Paul’s point is simply that we can be certain that our bodies, though destined for death, will be given life, precisely because of the Spirit who indwells us. . . . the Spirit guarantees our future, including our bodily resurrection. . . . the future body is supernaturally fitted for the final life of the Spirit, totally unhindered by any of its present weaknesses.”

To be saved by the Spirit

Fee summarizes what it means to be “saved” by the Holy Spirit:

“In sum: ‘to be saved’ in the Pauline view means to become part of the people of God, who by the Spirit are born into God’s family and therefore joined to one another as one body, whose gatherings in the Spirit form them into God’s temple. God is not simply saving diverse individuals and preparing them for heaven; rather he is creating a people for his name, among whom God can dwell and who in the life together will reproduce God’s life and character in all its unity and diversity.”

Life in the Spirit

Fee continues: “In saving us through Christ and the Spirit, God has created an eschatological people, who live the life of the future in the present, a life reflecting the character of the God who became present first in Christ and then by his Spirit. As the renewed [indwelling] presence of God, the Spirit, having given life to his people, now leads them in paths of righteousness for his name’s sake.” [the process of dualist interaction addressed in my books and blogs]

Active life in the Spirit

Gordon Fee discusses life in the Spirit, that it “is not passive; nor is obedience automatic. We continue to live in the real world; we are, after all, both already and not yet. Therefore, the imperative for the already is walk in/by the Spirit. That assumes that we live in a world very much controlled by the flesh; but it also assumes that we now live in that world as different people, led by the Spirit and empowered by the Spirit to produce the fruit of righteousness, rather than to continue in the works of the flesh.

Empowered by the Holy Spirit

I conclude my posting of excerpts from Gordon Fee’s book, Paul, the Spirit, and the People of God, with this one from Chapter 15:

“The Spirit’s major role in Paul’s view lies with his being the essential element of the whole of Christian life, from beginning to end. The Spirit thus empowers ethical life in all its dimensions - individually, within the community, and to the world. Believers in Christ, who are Spirit people first and foremost, are variously described as living by the Spirit, walking in the Spirit, being led by the Spirit, bearing the fruit of the Spirit, and sowing to the Spirit. Ethics for Paul is likewise founded in the Trinity: the Spirit of God conforms the believer into the likeness of Christ to the glory of God. The Spirit is thus the empowering presence of God for living the life of God in the present. There is therefore no Christian life that is not at the same time a holy life, made so by the Holy Spirit whom God gives to his people (1 Thess 4:8). At the same time, life in the Spirit also includes every other imaginable dimension of the believer’s present end-time existence, including being empowered by the Spirit to abound in hope, to live in joy, to pray without ceasing, to exercise self-control, to experience a robust conscience, to have insight into God’s will and purposes, and to endure in every kind of present hardship and suffering. To be a believer means nothing less than being filled with and thus to live in and by the Spirit.”

I pray that the excerpts I have posted from the books by Ryrie and Fee are seen to be in concordance with what I have described as dualist interaction in my books and blogs. The Holy Spirit indwells believers who are in repentance and accept the truth of the Gospel in our time. This indwelling of the Holy Spirit by the grace and boundless love of God through his living, glorified Son, Jesus Christ, did not cease with the closure of the Canon, as believed by some. No, it is a reality now in our end-times existence as we await the final promised consummation upon the return of Jesus Christ.

Galatians, Luther's Book

I am sharing several Scriptures from the Book of Galatians, referred to as “Luther’s Book.” The basic message of the book brought about the Protestant Reformation, and it is also referred to as the “Magna Carta of Christian liberty.” These Scriptures attest to the indwelling of repentant believers by the Holy Spirit with whom our personal communion has been restored by the grace of God through the sin sacrifice of His Son, Jesus Christ.

“But when the time had fully come, God sent his Son, born of a woman, born under law, that we might receive the full rights of sons. Because you are sons, God sent the Spirit of his Son into our hearts [souls], the Spirit who calls out, ‘Abba, Father.’ So you are no longer a slave, but a son; and since you are a son, God has made you also an heir.” (Gal 4:4-7)

“But the fruit of the Spirit is love, joy, peace, patience, kindness, goodness, faithfulness, gentleness and self-control. Against such things there is no law. Those who belong to Christ Jesus have crucified the sinful nature with its passions and desires. Since we live by the Spirit, let us keep in step with the Spirit.” (Gal 5:22-25)

“The grace of our Lord Jesus Christ be with your spirit.” (Gal 6:18) [I include this benediction at the end of the book since it identifies the human spirit [s in lower case] which is indwelled by the Holy Spirit [S in upper case], by whose Counsel our souls [minds, wills and emotions] strive to live.

Stan Lennard
Minds in Communion - 10

Quantum Wave Potential

I am posting this blog that counters the monistic proposal for mind-body interaction by David Bohm and gives further justification for dualist interaction between the immaterial mind and the material synaptic networks of the human brain. The blog considers the quantum wave potential described by Bohm and suggests that it is the product of the mind rather than an entity within a monistic perspective.

  The Mind and the Quantum Wave Potential

In my Hypothesis, stated at the beginning of Chapter Seven of my book, Nerve Endings of the Soul: Interaction between the Mind of God and the Mind of Man through Neural Synaptic Networks, it is proposed that a nonmaterial energy from the Mind of God induces the synaptic transmission of encoded specified information within spike trains of action potentials to the mind of Man by quantum tunneling across synaptic clefts.  That the human cognitive mind is created in the image of the Mind of God, the same process for neural transmission through synaptic networks is likely by this created process.  In this blog I will address how the mathematical expression of the quantum wave potential might relate to dualist interaction between the immaterial Mind of God/mind of Man and the material synaptic networks of the human brain.  In my discussion I will be referring to the work of David Bohm, Hiley and Pylkkanen, John C. Eccles, Friedrich Beck, Stephen Meyer and William A. Dembski in particular.  Much of what I am sharing has been presented in my books and earlier blogs, but I will consolidate what I have presented and include information from recent scientific articles that consider the “quantum wave potential,” a mathematical entity described by David Bohm in the quantum Hamilton-Jacobi equation.

Eccles and Beck designated quantum tunneling as the “trigger” for synaptic transmission when the mind willfully transmits specified, encoded programs through neural synaptic networks. Their proposal suggested how quantum tunneling could play a role in controlling the frequency of synaptic exocytosis, a stochastic process. Beck and Eccles proposed that quantum tunneling would enable the “self” to control its brain without violating the energy conservation law. Hiley and Pylkkanen have described a relationship between wave functions and quantum tunnelling.  The question I propose is as follows: Does the cognitive mind activate the “trigger” by generating wave functions, or wave forms, that transmit quasiparticles (electrons) through the voltage potential barriers of synapses by tunneling in the cerebral cortex? [Basil J. Hiley and Paavo Pylkkanen, “Can Mind Affect Matter Via Active Information?” Mind and Matter, Vol. 3(2), 2005, pp. 7-27] The authors acknowledged the work of Eccles and Beck and elaborated on it by considering the role of a quantum wave potential described in mathematical detail by David Bohm in quantum tunneling. (D. Bohm, “A New Theory of the Relationship of Mind and Matter, Philosophical Psychology, Vol. 3, 1990, pp. 271-286; F. Beck and J.C. Eccles, “Quantum Aspects of Brain Activity and the Role of Consciousness,” Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences of the United States of America, Vol. 89, 1992, pp 11357-11361; F. Beck, Quantum Brain Dynamics and Consciousness, The Physical Nature of Consciousness, ed. By P. van Loocke, John Benjamins, Amsterdam, 2001, pp. 83-116)

Hiley and Pylkkanen proposed that the quantum energy involved in synaptic transmission is a form of internal energy distinct from kinetic and classical potential energy that transmits what Bohm called a new type of “active information.”  The energy proposed is associated with simultaneous position and momentum determinants of quantum entities in contrast to the long-accepted Copenhagen perspective of indeterminism. How do quasi-particles (electrons) associated with quantum waves penetrate voltage potential barriers?  By applying Bohm mechanics to tunneling they proposed that the wave form of a quasi-particle goes through a potential barrier depending on the position of the particle in the oncoming wave function.  The total energy of the process is conserved because there is a redistribution of energy between the kinetic energy, the classical potential energy and the quantum potential energy described by David Bohm.  Particles at the front of the wave function, or specified wave form, pass through the barrier by tunneling while those at the rear are reflected before they reach the barrier.  The third group of trajectories remain inside the voltage barrier for a time.  The quantum wave potential was described as having active information for the particles. At the quantum level this information was stated to organize and give direction to the dynamic evolution of quantum wave and quasi-particle flow in double-slit experiments.  Could the proposed quantum wave potential also give direction to wave forms and quasiparticles through neural synaptic networks?  The quantum wave potential energy is expressed in the shape or form of the wave rather than in its amplitude, accounting for the conservation of energy in tunneling.  Hiley and Pylkkanen considered the quantum wave potential to have a physical, deterministic aspect by its influence on the kinetic and potential energies at synaptic voltage barriers in synaptic entities.  A relationship was suggested between an internal energy and the material synaptic components without violation of the law of conservation of energy as proposed by Beck and Eccles.

The concept of a “new active information” in its role in quantum tunneling was not attributed to the cognitive mind by Bohm, but he stated that it had “mind-like” qualities.  He considered that the mind was not distinct from the physical aspects of synaptic transmission, the two processes being essentially the same.  He stated that “what we experience as mind . . . will, in a natural way, ultimately move the body by reaching the level of the quantum potential and of the ‘dance’ of the particles” involved in quantum tunneling.  He posited that “in some sense a rudimentary mind-like quality is present even at the level of particle physics . . . there is no real division between mind and matter, psyche and soma.”  He referred to “a greater collective mind . . . going indefinitely beyond even the human species as a whole.”

I cited Stephen Meyer in my blog post entitled “Waves in Our Brains,” Part Three (http://estanlennard.com) who stated “our uniform experience affirms that specified or functional information . . . always arises from an intelligent source, from a mind (Italics added),” and I emphasized that it refers to an immaterial mind.  The direction given to a quantum wave and quasiparticle through neural synaptic networks would ultimately be by the intent of a mind, an intellect, with design and purpose.  In my three blogs, each entitled “Waves in Our Brains,” I have given a compelling reason to believe that the cognitive mind of humans generates wave forms.  We see that they have amplitude and frequency as well as the shape and form that has been attributed to the action of the quantum wave potential. (Scott R. Cole and Bradley Voytek, “Brain Oscillations and the Importance of Waveform Shape,” Trends in Cognitive Sciences, 2017, Vol 21, No. 2, pp 137-149) I suggest, therefore, that it is the cognitive mind of Man (and of God) that determines the direction of encoded trajectories of spike trains of action potentials through synaptic networks.  The question that is posed is if the internal energy of the quantum wave potential relates to the wave forms generated by the cognitive mind of Man (as well as of the Mind of God) that have been documented by electrocarticography and functional magnetic resonance imaging.  This topic has been discussed in the “Waves in Our Brains” series. It is proposed that it is instantiated information from a mind that gives the wave form direction by its shape, phase and also by its frequency and amplitude.  As a wave form is transmitted across pyramidal modules in the cerebral cortex the “detector function” described by Eccles within pyramidal modules matches the wave form that is being transmitted from the mind/Mind of god with intrinsic patterns within modules to form synchronous, coherent waves according to their shape and to their amplitude and frequency, a process that includes entrainment and cross frequency coupling.  Direction is thereby given to the trajectories of spike trains of action potentials transmitted through synaptic networks.  Modular neural activity is highly plastic and varied across the primary site of cognition, the cerebral cortex.  By this process of matching, which is under active investigation in our day, direction is given to wave forms emanating from the mind’s intent that are linguistically encoded with information for meaning, specified purposes and actions (e.g. speaking, moving extremities, thinking, etc.) I offer that the quantum wave potential, if it exists, may reflect a causal effect of a mind that gives specified information to the processes and trajectories of quantum tunneling and synaptic transmission. 

In “Waves in Our Brains,” Part Three I quoted Stephen Meyer who stated, “…in using language the human mind routinely generates highly improbable linguistic sequences to convey a preconceived idea.  In the process of thought, functional objectives precede and constrain the selection of words, sounds, and symbols to generate functional sequences from a vast ensemble of meaningless alternatives . . . intelligent agents can select functional goals before the goals are physically instantiated . . . they can then actualize those goals in accord with a preconceived design plan or set of functional requirements.”  Linguistic sequences are transmitted by wave forms constituting neural codes within spike trains of action potentials that are interpreted by the cognitive mind of humans and archived in memory.

I propose that the Mind of God and the mind of Man can by this process channel random synaptic events toward preordained, specified ends. The immaterial wave forms emitted from a mind/Mind are selected from initially random, or indeterministic, probabilities and given specification and direction possibly by an action of the proposed quantum wave potential.  The role in the tunneling process of wave form amplitude is not directly addressed by Bohm and appears to be mathematically discounted, giving primary importance to wave form shape. I propose that the quantum wave potential emanates from, or is influenced by, the intent of a mind that imparts information to the shape of the wave form that determines trajectory direction through cortical modules and downstream synaptic networks.  The wave forms are entrained with the wave forms of specific cortical neural modules to form synchronized spike trains of wave forms that are linguistically encoded and transmitted through coherent networks with meaning, purpose and intended action.  The synaptic networks are referred to as nerve endings of the soul in my first book. Through a lifetime of learning and experience the cognitive mind interprets the neural codes, whether in sensation or motor function. Could this be in part the process by which communion occurs between the Mind of God and the mind of Man?

David Bohm postulated a monistic perspective of mind-body interaction.  The proposal offered in this blog is in support of a dualist interaction between the immaterial mind and the material synaptic networks of the human brain.

Human will and the readiness potential

In her review Gholipour wrote that Aaron Schurger, a researcher at the National Institute of Health and Medical Research in Paris, “studied fluctuations in neuronal activity, the churning hum in the brain that emerges from the spontaneous flickering of hundreds of thousands of interconnected neurons, . . . an ongoing electrophysiological noise [that] rises and falls in slow tides.” In his review of Kornhuber and Deecke’s innovative approach to the study of this activity he found “no purpose behind these apparent trends . . . . the pattern would simply reflect how various factors had happened to coincide.” When he examined his own data from studies using the same method as the German team he “saw something that looked like the Bereitschaftspotential . . . [but considered that the] rising pattern wasn’t a mark of a brain’s brewing intention at all, but something much more circumstantial.” Gholipour shared that “neuroscientists know that for people to make any type of decision, our neurons need to gather evidence for each option.” In my books and blogs I have discussed how cognition initiates activity in the memory codes in the supplementary motor areas followed by the transmission of spike trains of action potentials through synaptic networks to, for example, move a finger or arm. There is prior neural activity just prior to the willful intent for physical action in this instance. Gholipour referred to more recent studies by Schurger and Princeton colleagues that “repeated a version of Libet’s experiment,” finding that brain activity in their subjects began only 150 milliseconds before a movement, “the time people reported making decisions in Libet’s original experiment. . . . In other words, people’s subjective experience of a decision - what Libet’s study seemed to suggest was just an illusion - appeared to match the actual moment their brains showed them making a decision.” Schurger’s studies “showed the Bereitschaftspotential may not be what we thought it was.” Gholipour pointed out in her article that Schurger’s work did not solve the question of free will any more than Libet’s did, but did deepen the question. In my more recent blogs I have identified several actions in synaptic networks that occur as a result of cognitive intent, including the proposed generation of wave forms that are transmitted via quantum tunneling to stimulate action potentials. Might this activity be included in the 150 milliseconds prior to a movement, thus giving support to dualist interaction between the immaterial mind and the material synaptic networks of the human brain?

Human volition, or free will

Chris Frith published an article entitled, “The Psychology of Volition,” in Exp Brain Res, 2013, Vol. 229: 289-299. I am posting several excerpts from that article that describe human volition, or free will. Materialists reduce the mind to the physical brain and go so far as to challenge the existence of free will. By reading these posts I hope you can come to your own conclusion about the reality of human volition.

“From the first-person view, our experience of volitional behavior includes a vivid sense of agency. We feel that, through our intentions, we can cause things to happen and we can choose between different actions. . . . In what sense do we control our behavior? Does such control imply the possibility of mental causation and the existence of free will? Is free will compatible with a materialist approach to the study of behavior? Is this truly free behavior uniquely human? . . . The key feature of a voluntary act as opposed to a reflex is that the voluntary act cannot be fully predicted from the preceding context. The implication is that, if the behavior is not being determined by external events, then the choices must be made ‘from inside’, endogenously. . . . [Frith asks] Is it possible for a nervous system to generate truly random behavior? . . . Unpredictable behavior . . . is self-generated, or endogenous. . . . Whatever the precise mechanisms underlying its perception, volition, seen from the first-person perspective, is associated with a vivid experience of agency. As agents, we have the experience of desiring an outcome and of choosing the action that will achieve it. Some believe that it is this experience of being an agent that leads to a belief in free will. . . . It is the first-person aspect of volition that is uniquely human. . . . The experience of agency requires that these signals be interpreted.” In my books and blogs I have made the effort to identify what does the interpretation, and it is the immaterial mind.

Dualist interaction and substance dualism

I have found an article that addresses substance dualism, essentially another term that can be applied to dualist interactionism. I share excerpts from this article that will be of value in clarifying what is meant by these terms, especially since the perspectives of monism, determinism, materialist reductionism and macroevolution still dominate much of the literature of neuroscience. The article is entitled “What Is Man, that You are Mindful of him? The Harmony of Substance Dualism and MBTI.” It is authored by Reilly LaRose from Taylor University, dated 2020, a student of Dr. Seeman, Philosophy of Mind. The article can be found at https://pillars.taylor.edu/philosophy/1. I will post a series of excerpts from this article.

Substance dualism, under the Stanford encyclopedia of philosophy, can be understood as affirming “a substance is characterized by its properties, but . . . it is more than the collection of the properties it possesses; it is the thing which possesses them. So, the mind is not just a collection of thoughts but is that which thinks - an immaterial substance over and above its immaterial states.” The roots of substance dualism are seated in a metaphysic which argues for the existence of both a physical body and immaterial mind within humans. . . . At base, there are two substances (maybe more) in existence, and humans are constituted by both. Many philosophers point out this unification of body and soul can be understood as a marriage of substances to accomplish beauty and purpose. This union doesn’t downplay the intimacy and interaction of both substances, nor does it deny that both substances are distinct.

LaRose stated, What seems to be captured in . . . substance dualism is the relationship between the body and soul - a meshing that makes consciousness capable of abstraction and thinking through the perceptual organs and phenomenal experience associated with embodiment. But in what sense can I call myself a unified “self” if my body isn’t my whole being? . . . a unified self exists over and above each of these consciousness and bodily experiences. . . . Because there is an enduring soul melded intimately with the body, the stimulations of the body coalesce into various inputs that the soul or mind sits over and above to experience and make decisions over.

In continuing this particular blog series addressing substance dualism and its compatibility with dualist interactionism, I am posting comments by LaRose citing Ralph C. S. Walker:

Walker states that on the basis of reason, the mental cannot solely be the physical. . . . reason provides sufficient justification to believe the mind is not physical since the process of reason interrupts the chain of physical determinism. . . . what reason does is “moves minds” towards certain ideas and behavior. In this way, no matter our physical being, should reason exist ontologically, then no conception of mind remains within the bounds of physical determinism solely: there must be a mental outside the physical to be moved by reason. . . . Further, having a separate, mental existence sets one up to subscribe to an enduring self beyond the physical. . . . Substance dualism holds a simple and profound answer for these observations of conscious life: the soul, the mind, the self is that which feels. We are more than the collection of qualitative phenomenal experiences, but that which experiences them.

Substance dualism, concluded

I conclude this series of posts from the article by Reilly LaRose with the following comments drawing from Riccardo Manzotti and Paolo Moderato:

The conclusion they arrive at is that neuroscience, while peddling a materialist explanation of mind in most cases, tacitly or implicitly holds a dualistic philosophy of mind: “nothing in literature explains why a certain neural phenomenon should produce a certain phenomenal experience. . . . Neuroscience faces an impossible mission . . . showing how a physical world which had been a priori defined as devoid of those properties that are essential of mind may contain or produce those properties.” What Manzotti and Moderato call this situation is an “ontological promissory note” of explanation, meaning that neuroscientists who hold materialist views can only promise that someday the cashing out of explanation for mind in physical terms and causes will be realized. All the while, a dualistic conception of mind and body is guiding the language and practice of neuroscience, for what a materialist calls “mental properties” doesn’t elude the problems associated with materialism and mind. As Manzotti and Moderato put it, these “mental properties” function the same as a dualist’s “mental qualities” in philosophical terms. Both are treated as things in themselves and inexplicable from the perspective of pure physicalism.

Dwelling of the Holy Spirit

It is my hope that dualist interaction between the immaterial and material has been compellingly defended both in my books and blogs by showing concordance between Scripture and neuroscience. Jesus sent as He promised the Holy Spirit to indwell those in repentance, to provide Counsel and Help to believers by faith to this present day. God is Spirit, as is His Holy Spirit, which indwells people via the immaterial human spirit, created in Man at his creation. We have seen that there is now evidence that the immaterial Spirit is causal through the human spirit on the immaterial human mind, with actions manifested in and through the material brain and body. This reality provides understanding of Ephesians 2:19-22:

Consequently, you are no longer foreigners and aliens, but fellow citizens with God’s people and members of God’s household, built on the foundation of the apostles and prophets, with Christ Jesus himself as the chief cornerstone. In him the whole building is joined together and rise to become a holy temple in the Lord. And in him you too are being built together to become a dwelling in which God lives by his Spirit.

A step toward understanding dualist interaction

In my succeeding blogs I will post excerpts from and my discussions in response to recent neuroscience articles that address the apical and distal tufts of the pyramidal cells of the neocortex. I offer a postulate that suggests how the proposed wave forms generated by the cognitive mind interact directly with these structures to actualize the mind’s intention for action, whether it be the movement of an extremity, a creative thought or a spoken word, even from the Holy Spirit. The Holy Spirit may be offering us an explanation of this interaction, a manifestation of his progressive revelation so that we can come to a personal, intimate communion with our Lord and Savior, Jesus Christ.

Tufts of the apical dendrites of pyramidal neurons - a role in cognition?

As I begin this series of blogs some definitions are in order. I will be focusing on a specific part of pyramidal neurons, the dendrites and their apical tufts. The information I am sharing is extracted from two articles, the first: M. W. Spratling, “Cortical Region Interactions and the Role of Apical Dendrites,” Behavioral and Cognitive Neuroscience Reviews, 1(3): 219-228, 2002, and the second: Nelson Spruston, “Pyramical Neurons: Dendritic Structure and Synaptic Integration,” Nature Reviews: Neuroscience, Vol. 9, March 2008, 206-221.

The cerebral cortex consists of a laminar structure of six layers. The cell bodies of pyramidal cells, the most abundant type of cortical neuron, are found in layers II-VI and have distinct morphologies, including two separate dendritic arbors: the basal dendrites which occupy the same layer as the cell body and the apical dendrites which ascend into more superficial layers. For pyramidal cells in layer VI the apical dendrites extend to layer IV, and for pyramidal cells in the other layers the apical dendrites extend to layer I where they are quite dense. Pyramidal cells consist of the only neurons that project outside the cortex “and [are] the primary source of connections between different cortical areas. This class of cell is thus likely to have a major role in cortical information processing.” (I remind the reader that information can only be generated by a mind, discussed in detail in previous blogs and in my books.)

Both the apical and basal dendrites receive connections with axons originating in different cortical areas. They are rich in dendritic spines that project from the dendritic body and along its length to make connections with boutons, specialized pre-synaptic structures at the ends of axons. Between the bouton and the spine is a very narrow synaptic cleft across which neural transmitters flow to generate action potentials transmitted through synaptic networks. Spines are highly variable in their size and shape and are plastic, changing with experience. “It has been suggested that thin, dynamic spines might be available to contribute to learning, whereas larger, more stable spines might be involved in the storage of established memories. Repeated activation of small spines leads to increase in their size by the Hebbian process discussed in my books.

Spruston describes pyramidal neurons as having basal and apical dendrites along with apical tufts. In my research I wonder if the wave forms that appear to be generated by cognition of the immaterial mind interact with the spines of apical dendrites within the apical tufts? Does this interaction occur at ionic channels in the tufts and/or in the specialized, pre-synaptic structures? Are axons involved? What is the result of the proposed interaction, and how are spike trains of action potentials generated that are transmitted through synaptic channels to bring about intended action? As this discussion proceeds I shall address these questions in relation to my postulate that apical tufts are sites for interaction with the immaterial mind.

My discussion that follows will focus on the basics of apical dendritic function which is markedly complex. The two articles to which I am making reference discuss this function in more detail. My focus is to address only one aspect of its function in relation to cognitive activity within the cerebral cortex, giving expression to related points made in earlier blogs in this context. Each blog that follows in this series will be entitled, “Apical tufts in cognition, part 1, 2, etc.”

Apical tufts in cognition, Part 1

I am posting below comments from Spratling’s article addressing the role of attention (by the cognitive mind) in information processing. It must be recalled that information is only generated by a mind (matter cannot generate information), and all information that is transmitted must be encoded (within neural codes to which my books and blogs have spoken).

“Attention is a top-down process that operates via cortical feedback projections. . . . Attention modulates the sensory-driven activation of cells, . . . such that activity in response to an attended stimulus is increased in amplitude and duration. . . . increased attention has effects similar to increasing the contrast or saliency of the stimulus. . . . In the absence of a stimulus, attention increases the rate of spontaneous firing (the author makes no mention of the causal effects of a cognitive mind, and I have shared in my more recent blogs that attention, intent and will likely generate wave forms with amplitude, frequency and phase that can tunnel through voltage barriers of ionic channels and synaptic components to increase ‘the rate of spontaneous firing’ in neural networks) . . . . attention is used to multiplicatively modulate the synaptic strengths of intra-cortical connections so that attended information can be selectively routed to higher cortical regions. . . . modulatory affects could also be achieved by employing neurons that have two functionally distinct dendrites (apical and basal dendrites).”

I continue with this author’s comments that address the complex feedforward and feedback activities that are known to operate in information transmission through interconnected neural networks. Cognition involves such interconnectedness in a top-down fashion. Stimulation and inhibition both operate within and between neural cortical modules to strengthen and direct the transmission of spike train trajectories through selected neural networks, a process that involves synchronization and entrainment as discussed in my recent blogs. I have proposed that linguistically encoded wave forms generated by the mind (e.g. attention) gain direction through neural networks to bring about specific activities (e.g. moving an arm) by entraining modular wave forms whose amplitudes, frequencies and phases are in synchrony with them, establishing coherent wave forms that transmit specified information through neural synaptic networks. The question that is being considered is how apical pyramidal tufts relate to this process. Note in the following excerpt how words (italicized) are used that reflect the cognitive activity of a mind!

“Feedback modulates activity generated by feedforward processing. such modulation may play a role in tasks such as recall, priming and attention. . . . by influencing activation each dendrite can affect learning in a biologically plausible manner. Neurons are likely to learn correlations between the separate information streams targeting the apical and basal dendrites. Apical inputs can therefore influence learning at the basal dendrite and may be considered a source of reinforcement or supervision. This interpretation is bolstered by the fact that the apical dendrites in layer I not only receive projections from other cortical regions but are also targeted by the limbic system; a widely projecting set of interconnected brain structures concerned with emotion and memory.” I offer that the neurons of the material brain cannot do all these functions! It is the mind that accomplishes correlations, interpretations, supervision, recall and learning. Memories are recalled from archived neural codes situated within the liaison brain (e.g. supplementary motor area) discussed in my books.

In my next blog I will return to the article by Spruston and consider in more detail the possible role of pyramidal apical tufts in cognition.

Apical tufts in cognition, part 2

I now return to the article by Spruston to focus on a possible role for apical pyramidal cell tufts in the cognitive activity of the immaterial mind. I am posting excerpts from his article along with my comments, primarily reflecting posts I have made in previous blogs and in my books.

“Pyramidal neurons are abundant in the cerebral cortex . . . they are found primarily in structures that are associated with advanced cognitive functions. . . . Critical to the function of each pyramidal neuron is how it responds to its synaptic inputs to produce an action potential that excites its postsynaptic targets. . . . All pyramidal neurons have several relatively short basal dendrites. Usually, one large apical dendrite connects the soma (cell body) to a tuft of dendrites. . . . [there is] some evidence [that] supports the division of pyramidal cell dendritic trees into . . . domains, which correspond to regions that receive distinct synaptic inputs and/or have synapses with distinct properties. . . . it is reasonable to postulate that pyramidal neurons with different structural features are also likely to differ functionally. . . . inputs to the main apical dendrite and the oblique apical dendrites might be integrated differently, but it is not known whether synaptic inputs to these domains are identical or different.”

Hence, it is acceptable for me to offer a postulate on how wave forms generated by cognition interact with the pyramidal tufts and their numerous spines to stimulate changes in the microstructures of ionic channels to initiate dendritic spikes. This action could involve quantum tunneling as we have seen with the transmission of wave forms through potential barriers at neural synapses to initiate spike trains of action potentials that transmit specified codes. Just where, I am asking, would wave forms generated by the immaterial mind act? In subsequent blogs I will address the statements of Sir John C. Eccles that are prescient in this regard.

“Pyramidal neurons are covered with thousands of dendritic spines that constitute the postsynaptic site for most excitatory glutamatergic synapses. . . . The function of dendritic spines remains enigmatic. . . . Spines vary considerably in their size and shape and are highly plastic [so that they may be functional in memory and learning].”

I have discussed in my books and several blogs how the immaterial mind “learns” to interpret neural codes over a lifetime as well as generates their formation within spike trains of action potentials. Neural codes are archived in memory and accessed by the mind to effect desired actions with purpose and meaning. An example I have discussed in my books is the supplementary motor area, where neural codes for various motor actions are archived in the so-called liaison brain described by Eccles.

When dendritic spines are stimulated by incoming wave forms they “exert significant influence over action-potential initiation through the activation of dendritic voltage-gated channels, which can enhance charge entry at distal synapses and might even lead to dendritic spike initiation. Several observations suggest that synapses at different dendritic locations are specialized to perform different functions . . . The apical tuft also has a relatively large number of [spine] synapses on the dendritic shaft. These differences suggest that these various dendritic regions receive synaptic inputs that have distinctive properties.” [The author does not address cognitive function and its potential application to this process.]

In my next blog I will continue to draw upon Spruston’s article, focusing on the process of dendritic excitability and coincidence detection, leading to the discussions by Eccles that are prescient in this context.

Apical tufts in cognition, part 3

Spruston discusses the very complex properties of apical and basal dendrites. Dendritic spikes include both calcium and sodium spikes activated at the ionic channels for these two ions by synaptic input. How the postulated wave forms generated by the cognitive mind may interact with the components of ionic channels, likely involving quantum tunneling, to generate these spikes is an unanswered question. “Once initiated, dendritic spikes propagate towards the soma where, in some cases, they can initiate an action potential. . . . [Spruston points out that] dendritic spikes do not propagate reliably from the apical tuft into the main apical dendrite,” propagation depending upon whether a ‘gate’ is opened or closed that governs the influence of distally generated dendritic spikes on axonal action-potential initiation.”

So we see that the function of apical tufts remains under study and that spike generation in dendrites and axons is most complex. Initiation of spikes in ionic channels and synapses by cognition is not ruled out. Spruston concludes with the statement that the answering of questions about dendritic function “will move [us] closer to a detailed understanding of the complex and dynamic function of pyramidal neurons, a crucial key to unlocking the mysteries of cortical function.”

I conclude my discussion of this aspect of cognition. My intent has been to show how progress in neuroscience is being made to shed light on an understanding of dualist interaction between the immaterial mind and the brain. There is much yet to learn, but I am confident that findings will reveal concordance between Scripture and science, so that our faith that the Holy Spirit communes with us in our time is strengthened.

The wisdom and knowledge of God

I am posting verses from Romans 11: 33-36 that were included at the end of my book, The Boundless Love of God: A Holy Spirit Story. Yes, we are learning much from advances in the neurosciences, providing confirmation of dualist interaction between the Mind of God and the mind of Man and perhaps how that works with wave forms at the level of pyramidal modules of the cerebral cortex and the consequent transmission of encoded spike trains through neural synaptic networks. But our God is so much more majestic and powerful, and we are humbled as we seek His Truth.

Oh, the depths of the riches and wisdom and knowledge of God! How unsearchable are his judgments and how fathomless his ways! For who has known the mind of the Lord, or who has been his counselor? Or who has first given to God, that God needs to repay him? For from him and through him and to him are all things. To him be glory forever! Amen.

Thank you for your attention to my blogs that expand on the contents of my books. I will continue my research through the available neuroscience literature, though my posts will be less frequent. I pray that I have provided to date and in future posts a means to increase your faith in the fact that our Creator God, by his grace through our Lord and Savior, Jesus Christ, desires to have an intimate, two-way personal communion with us as members of his Kingdom, now and forever more.

Stan Lennard
Minds in Communion - 9

Woman with hemorrhage and transmitted power from Jesus

Just then a woman who had been subject to bleeding for twelve years came up behind him and touched the edge of his cloak. She said to herself, “If I only touch his cloak, I will be healed.” Jesus turned and saw her, “Take heart, daughter,” he said, “your faith has healed you.” And the woman was healed from that moment. (Matthew 9: 20-22)

And a woman was there who had been subject to bleeding for twelve years, but no one could heal her. She came up behind him and touched the edge of his cloak, and immediately her bleeding stopped. “Who touched me,” Jesus asked. When they all denied it, Peter said, “Master, the people are crowding and pressing against you.” But Jesus said, “Someone touched me; I know that power has gone out from me.” Then the woman, seeing that she could not go unnoticed, came trembling and fell at his feet. In the presence of all the people, she told why she had touched him and how she had been instantly healed. Then he said to her, “Daughter, your faith has healed you. Go in peace.” (Luke 8: 43-48)

We see evidence of a dual interaction in these passages between the woman and Jesus, a healing power that flowed from Jesus to the woman. In my writings I offer a description of that power.  We have seen in multiple blog posts that the immaterial, nonphysical energy of dual interactionism exerts causal effects on the material components of the neural synaptic networks.  Reference to the Merriam-Webster Dictionary shows that the definition of power, the noun, includes the ability to produce an effect, a mental efficacy, or a means of supplying energy.  The energy of wave forms having amplitude, frequency and shape has been attributed to the synaptic transmission of specified information encoded within action potentials to bring about intended action.  I posit that the healing power that went out from the Spirit of Jesus consisted of the energy of wave forms spoken to by Luke 2000 years ago.

Knew their thoughts

The Pharisees and the teachers of the law were looking for a reason to accuse Jesus, so they watched him closely to see if he would heal on the Sabbath. But Jesus knew what they were thinking and said to the man with the shriveled hand. . . . (Luke 6: 7-8)

I have discussed in blog posts the likelihood that wave forms are generated by the intention of a cognitive mind that may be transmitted to a recipient brain, accounting for Jesus’ knowing “what they were thinking.”

Mental imagery and the brain

I now return to posting blogs that address findings from the neurosciences that give compelling support to dualist interaction between the immaterial mind and the material synaptic networks that are involved in cognition.

My first post addresses the findings of O’Craven and Kanwisher reported in the Journal of Cognitive Neuroscience, 12:6, (2000) pp. 1013-1023. The authors refer to the “mind’s eye” of mental imagery that engages many of the same cognitive and neural mechanisms involved in visual perception of physical stimuli. Cortical regions selectively involved in the visual processing of a material object physically present show similar selectivity during mental imagery in the absence of a material stimulus. Functional magnetic resonance imaging (fMRI) responses in the brain were robust to the extent that a single mental event could be determined with high accuracy in the inspection of raw fMRI data. Their “data are the first to show that the content of a single thought can be inferred from its fMRI signature alone.” I conclude with the authors’ statement, “The present study takes the final step . . . by showing that content-specific neural activity in . . . visual cortex can be created by a pure act of will even when no visual stimulus is present at all.”

The stimulus, whether real or imagined, could have generated wave forms actualized with specification within neural codes transmitting information through synaptic networks interpreted as to meaning by the cognitive mind of the subject.

Mental imagery and the "mind's eye"

Deana Vitrano has compared perception and imagination at the visual cortex in a recent article. She presented the findings in her Dickinson College Honors Thesis, Paper 12, in 2012. Her work is consistent with articles that have been presented in the last decade by neuroscientists.

Her study found that imagined patterns and seen patterns produced similar waveforms in 30 college students. Her findings supported “the claim that the visual cortex is activated in a similar manner during both imagination and perception.” That perception and visual mental imagery share common processes in the visual cortex was strengthened by the application of fMRI and PET scans. She recognized the importance of analyzing imagined stimuli that had not been seen before, so that imagined images would not be drawn from memory but were described verbally to the study subject. “The same neural substrates are involved in both imagination and perception.”

Evoked potential waveforms that were recorded were reflective of images that were both perceived and imagined in the “Mind’s Eye.” As I have shared in previous blogs, including “Waves in Our Brains,” Parts 1-3, it can be inferred as the best explanation that the immaterial cognitive mind can generate waveforms that are transmitted through the visual cortex as neural codes that can be interpreted as the images imagined as well as perceived. Her study is consistent with the premise of dualist interaction between the immaterial mind and the material components of the brain’s synaptic networks. That the human mind has been created in the imago Dei infers in a compelling manner that the Mind of God can in fact commune with the mind of Man via the indwelling Holy Spirit, a process supported by the brain’s synaptic networks.

Mind and matter

My thesis is that the explanations based on the present materialist/reductionist views on how experiential qualities developed out of inert matter are unconvincing and that an alternate viewpoint offers a more parsimonious and logically coherent account. This is a quotation taken from Leonard Freris’ article entitled “Mind and Matter.” It appeared in Communicative and Integrative Biology in 2014 (http://dx.doi/org/10.4161/cib.26658). He goes on to state that the truth of dualism would support the possibility of the mind surviving the death of the body. “The fundamental problem of Dualism is that it has no convincing explanation of how the two realms of mind and matter interact.” This last statement by Freris underscores the very objective of my studies over almost 30 years, the findings of which are presented in my two books and now in my blogs.

The author asks how experiential phenomena can be physical. The materialist/reductionist agenda is problematic. It is the mind-body problem. He refers to “eliminative materialism” wherein “mental phenomena are considered to be an ‘aspect’ of brain activity,” being physical phenomena. “Cognitive psychology” on the other hand views the brain as a computer. Mental activity is “information processing with experiential activity reduced to a computational process.”

Freris addresses the “mind-body” problem well. He closes with a postscript by Erwin Schrodinger:

But now let us assume that in a particular case you eventually observe several efferent bundles of pulsating currents, which issue from the brain and through long cellular protrusions (motor nerve fibers), are conducted to certain muscles of the arm, which, as a consequence, tends a hesitating, trembling hand to you to bid you farewell - for a long heart rendering separation; at the same time you may find that some other pulsating bundles produce a certain glandular secretion so as to veil the poor sad eye with a crape of tears. But nowhere along this way from the eye through the central organ to the arm muscles and the tear glands - nowhere, you may find, however far physiology advances, will you ever meet the personality, will you ever meet the dire pain, the bewildered worry within this soul, though their reality is to you so certain as though you suffered them yourself - as in actual fact you do!

Immaterial aspects of thought

In support of dualist interactionism I am identifying an article by Edward Feser that appeared in the American Catholic Philosophical Quarterly, Vol. 87, No. 1, 2013. Its title is “Kripke, Ross, and the Immaterial Aspects of Thought.” Feser cites comments by the materialist philosopher of mind, Jerry Fodor, who stated, “Lots of mental states are conscious, lots of mental states are intentional, and lots of mental processes are rational, and the question does rather suggest itself how anything that is material could be any of these.” One of the authors, the late James Ross, formulated a “powerful argument for the immateriality of our intellectual operations.” (His argument for the immateriality of the intellect was rooted in the Aristotelian-Scholastic tradition.) He identified a contrast between “the determinacy of thought and the indeterminacy of the physical.” Favoring the immateriality of thought is “the contrast between the universality of thought and the particularity of physical processes.” The determinacy of thought was considered by him to be immaterial.

Visual mental imagery

Visual mental imagery refers to the perceptual experience of “seeing in the mind’s eye.” Mario Senden and coworkers published an article in 2019 that addressed the subjective correspondence known between imagined images and physical image perception and further showed that correspondence exists in their neural representations (https://dol.org/10.1007/s00429-019-01828-6). Visual “imagery-based reconstructions of letter shapes are recognizable [by fMRI] and preserve their physical geometry” in the visual cortex. Their results confirmed “that visual mental imagery preserves perceptual topographic organization” in the brain. Images of letters directly perceived by sight were generated via waveforms (photons) transmitted from the letters perceived and transmitted through the retina and optic nerve to the visual cortex. Of great interest in their study is that imagined letters were also detected in visual cortex by fMRI with the same “physical geometry” or topography. This finding suggests that mental imagery by the cognitive immaterial mind also generates waveforms that are transmitted through coherent neural networks to topographically corresponding visual cortex as neural codes. It is the cognitive mind that interprets the codes as perceived, or imagined, imagery. One can reason that the Mind of God has the power to stimulate neural networks to generate images as in dreams and visions?

Decoding thoughts of the human mind

STEPHANIE MARTIN AND COWORKERS PUBLISHED AN ARTICLE IN FRONTIERS IN NEUROENGINEERING, MAY 2014, VOL. 7, ENTITLED “DECODING SPECTROTEMPORAL FEATURES OF OVERT AND COVERT SPEECH FROM THE HUMAN CORTEX.” IN THEIR STUDY SUBJECTS READ THE SAME STORIES BOTH ALOUD AND SILENTLY, OVERT AND COVERT RESPECTIVELY. SPEECH IMAGERY IS INNER SPEECH, SILENT SPEECH, IMAGINED SPEECH, COVERT SPEECH, OR AUDITORY VERBAL IMAGERY. IT IS HAVING WORDS IN THE MIND. IT REFERS TO THE ABILITY TO “HEAR” SPEECH INTERNALLY WITHOUT THE INTENTIONAL MOVEMENT OF ANY BODY PARTS INVOLVED IN GENERATING AUDIBLE SPEECH. THE AUTHORS UTILIZED A METHOD TO “RECONSTRUCT OVERT AND COVERT SPEECH FROM DIRECT INTRACRANIAL RECORDINGS” TAKEN BY ELECTROCARDIOGRAPHY. THEY FIRST BUILT A NEURAL DECODING MODEL FROM SELF-GENERATED OVERT SPEECH, AND THEN [EVALUATED] WHETHER THIS SAME MODEL COULD RECONSTRUCT SPEECH FEATURES IN THE COVERT SPEECH CONDITION.” THEY FOUND THAT “AUDITORY FEATURES OF COVERT SPEECH COULD BE DECODED FROM MODELS TRAINED FROM AN OVERT SPEECH CONDITION, PROVIDING EVIDENCE OF A SHARED NEURAL SUBSTRATE FOR OVERT AND COVERT SPEECH.” THOUGHTS WERE MAPPED TO BRAIN ACTIVITY IN THE FORM OF WAVEFORM TRACINGS THAT WERE DECODED SO THAT BRAIN ELECTRICAL ACTIVITY COULD BE TRANSLATED INTO UNDERSTANDABLE SPEECH. BUT THE PROCESS BY WHICH WAVEFORMS WERE GENERATED THAT WERE REFLECTED IN THE BRAIN TRACINGS WAS NOT ADDRESSED. AND JUST WHAT “HEARS” THE INTERNAL SPEECH? I OFFER THAT IT IS THE IMMATERIAL COGNITIVE MIND IN BOTH INSTANCES, BUT THE AUTHORS PROPOSED THAT “IMAGERY-RELATED BRAIN ACTIVATION COULD RESULT FROM TOP-DOWN INDUCTION MECHANISMS, INCLUDING MEMORY RETRIEVAL AND MOTOR STIMULATION.” THEIR PROPOSAL SUGGESTS A MATERIALIST REDUCTIONISM, ASSIGNING NO ROLE FOR THE IMMATERIAL COGNITIVE MIND.

THE AUTHORS TRANSLATED THE BRAIN TRACINGS USING THE MODEL THEY BUILT, AND IT IS AN ELEGANT STUDY THAT HOLDS ULTIMATE PROMISE FOR BRAIN-COMPUTER INTERFACES THAT CAN MAKE COMMUNICATION POSSIBLE FOR PATIENTS UNABLE TO SPEAK BUT ABLE TO HAVE THOUGHTS. I PROPOSE THAT THEIR STUDY RESULTS POINT TO THE IMMATERIAL MIND AS THE “TRANSLATOR” OF LINGUISTIC NEURAL CODES GENERATED BY BOTH AUDIBLY PERCEIVED AND IMAGINED SPEECH. WE HAVE SEEN IN PREVIOUS BLOG POSTS AND IN MY BOOKS THAT WAVEFORMS ARE TRANSMITTED PROBABILISTICALLY VIA QUANTUM TUNNELING THROUGH POTENTIAL BARRIERS WITHIN SYNAPTIC COMPONENTS TO GENERATE SPIKE TRAINS OF ACTION POTENTIALS TRANSMITTING IN TURN LINGUISTIC NEURAL CODES THROUGH COHERENT SYNAPTIC NETWORKS WITH PURPOSE, SUCH AS TO TRANSMIT SPEECH. I OFFER THAT THE COGNITIVE MIND IS THE GENERATOR OF THE WAVEFORMS AND THE TRANSLATOR/INTERPRETER OF THE LINGUISTIC NEURAL CODES. THAT THE COGNITIVE MIND OF A HUMAN HAS THIS CAPACITY LEADS ONE TO DEDUCE THAT THE MIND OF GOD INDWELLING US AS THE HOLY SPIRIT ALSO HAS THE CAPACITY FOR DUALIST INTERACTION WITH THE MIND AND BRAIN OF MAN.

God's omnipresence and omniscience

I am offering verses from Psalm 139 that show concordance with points I have shared in my two books and blogs, that God has the power to “translate” neural codes that course through the synaptic networks of our brains as well as to generate them. He knows our thoughts.

You have searched me, Lord, and you know me….you perceive my thoughts from afar….Before a word is on my tongue you, Lord, know it completely….Where can I go from your Spirit? Where can I flee from your presence? If I go up to the heavens, you are there; if I make my bed in the depths, you are there….if I settle on the far side of the sea, even there your hand will guide me….For you created my inmost being; you knit me together in my mother’s womb. I praise you because I am fearfully and wonderfully made; your works are wonderful, I know that full well.

Imagined touch by the mind

In an article published in 2021, the authors “recorded neurons within the posterior parietal cortex (PPC) of a human . . . participant during actual touch presentation and during a tactile imagery task” (https://doi.org/10.7554/eLilfe.61646). The results of the study showed that PPC neurons that are activated by physical touch are also activated “during a tactile imagery task in a body part-specific manner.” It is a novel finding that suggested “PPC involvement in the cognitive processing of touch [encoding]. . . . cognitive processing prior to active imagery as well as during imagery shares a neuronal substrate with actual touch.” Of particular interest is that the study participant was a tetraplegic in whom touch sensation was tested in insensate parts of the body. Actual touch in those parts was found to elicit no neuronal activation, but imagined touch did activate the known coherent neuronal pathways normally activated by direct touch. Activation was attributed to the cognitive mind through the PPC. The mechanism for the activation was not addressed, but there is accumulating evidence that activation could have been via waveforms generated by the cognitive mind and transmitted encoded through the PPC and its coherent synaptic networks. I propose that the immaterial mind of the study participant accounted for the interpretation of the neural codes as touch, a dualist interaction between immaterial and material entities.

Brain-computer interface technology

While seeking articles from the neuroscience literature that speak directly to the generation of brain waves by the immaterial mind, I am posting summaries of some articles that address applications of brain-computer interface (BCI) technology. ‘Mind-Reading’ Technology Allows Paralyzed Man to Rapidly Text is an article discussed by Amy Norton in WebMD, May 12, 2021.

In this technological application, “tiny chips are implanted in movement-related areas of the brain, where they tap into electrical activity in cells. When a person imagines [Italics added] executing a movement, the relevant brain cells start firing. Those electrical signals are then transmitted by wires to a computer, where they are “decoded” by sophisticated algorithms and translated into action, allowing people to control assistive devices with their own mind power.”

The “cells” are neurons, and the electrical activity consists of the spike trains of action potentials generated within and transmitted across the synapses of coherent, synchronized neural networks explained in my blogs. That the signals are “decoded” signifies that the frequencies and amplitudes of the neural impulses are transmitting actualized codes relevant to the specific intended motor action. It is remarkable that it is now possible for neuroscientists to access nerve impulses generated by the imagined objectives of a subject’s mind, by “mind” power according to the author. How the immaterial mind generates the neural impulses is the subject of my research, and in my blogs I have presented evidence suggesting that it is via wave forms transmitted to and through synapses via quantum tunneling.

Researchers at Stanford University asked a man with full-body paralysis to imagine handwriting utilizing BCI technology. This approach allowed him to “churn out text at a rate of roughly 18 words per minute, . . . nearly on par with the typical smartphone user.” Dr. Jaimie Henderson, a co-senior researcher and professor of neurosurgery at Stanford, “implanted two microchips in the man’s motor cortex, an area in the brain’s outermost layer that governs voluntary movement. . . . The microchip had electrodes that sensed the encoded signals from neurons involved in moving the hand. The computer algorithms utilized by the investigators decoded [Italics added] the mental handwriting codes. The curves and speed changes resulting from visualizing handwriting provided a “rich signal” that was relatively easy to decode using their algorithms”.

Immaterial mind's causal effects

Today while driving I found myself behind a bus with an interesting sign on the back. Pictured was an Asian man wearing a team uniform preparing with great concentration to kick a soccer ball. He had had an amputation of his left leg just below his hip joint, and he was balancing his body by holding onto special canes, one on each side, so that he could kick the ball. As I viewed the image on the sign I found it inconceivable that the physical brain could account solely for this action. No, there had to be an immaterial mind that expressed the will and intent to kick the ball and that exerted causal effects on the man’s nervous system to bring it about in the face of such a significant physical hindrance and specific circumstance in time.

In my previous blog post I identified the precise focus of my research over nearly thirty years. Just how does the immaterial, cognitive mind exert causal effects on synaptic networks. Synaptic transmission is understood to be electrochemical in nature, and it is now understood that wave forms enter the potential barriers of synapses and pass through via quantum tunneling. Are the wave forms generated by the immaterial mind? I have presented evidence suggesting that this is the case.

Wave of the gaps

I want to identify the focus of my research very concisely. I refer to it as the “wave of the gaps.” I draw upon the phrase “God of the gaps” that has caused such confusion among people over time, a view often expressed by the atheist perspective. Just how does the cognitive, immaterial mind, including the Mind of God, initiate causal interaction with the synaptic networks of the human brain? In my books and blogs I have discussed how wave forms stochastically/probabilistically pass through potential barriers of synaptic components to generate spike trains of action potentials that are encoded and transmitted through neural networks. The “gap” is between the mind of Man/Mind of God and wave forms that have amplitude, frequency and shape and are now acknowledged to pass through neural synapses via quantum tunneling. My hypothesis is that the immaterial mind of Man/Mind of God generates these wave forms which interact with synaptic dendrites of neural networks. My ongoing search is to find articles from neuroscience literature that address the hypothesis, a hard task when so much of the literature accepts materialist reductionism that denies the causality of the immaterial mind. This is an issue I have identified in previous blogs.

God created the waves

Consider that God created the waves that comprise our universe. God transcends His creation but can and does interact within it. To be sure God may have the means to commune with Man apart from all that is known about information transmission, but there is reason to accept the likelihood that He also uses the wave forms He created. Also, consider that the Holy Spirit indwells repentant mankind. As our own minds have the capacity to generate wave forms that pass through our neural networks, so also does the Mind of God via His indwelling Holy Spirit.

Stan Lennard
Minds in Communion - 8

Current neuroscience and dualist interaction

I have referred to my blog, “Waves in Our Brains,” Part Two, several times since it was posted on October 3, 2020. I invite your review of it to refresh your understanding of dualist interactionism between the immaterial mind and the material synaptic networks of the human brain. In that blog I referenced an important and exciting study that provides compelling confirmation of this interaction. I am copying the work of the authors of that study here that I summarized in that blog. It will serve as the basis for my subsequent blogs that will expand on their findings. My research continues investigating how the mind exerts an energy expressed as wave forms that transmit information through synaptic networks of the brain within linguistic neural codes.

THE NEURAL CODES OF OVERT AND COVERT SPEECH

THROUGH PART TWO OF THIS BLOG REFERENCES HAVE BEEN MADE TO COGNITION, ATTENTION AND INTENT, AND WE HAVE SEEN THAT WAVES ARE TRANSMITTED INTRINSICALLY THROUGH NEURAL NETWORKS TO BRING ABOUT SPECIFIC FUNCTIONS SUCH AS TO MOVE AN EXTREMITY.  WHAT IS LEFT IS TO ADDRESS THE QUESTION RAISED ABOVE, HOW DOES THE IMMATERIAL MIND RELATE TO THESE PROCESSES IN A DUALIST INTERACTION?  DOES THE HUMAN MIND GENERATE WAVES EXTRINSIC TO THE BRAIN ITSELF THAT CAN ACT CAUSALLY ON IT?  STEPHANIE MARTIN AND EIGHT COWORKERS PUBLISHED AN ARTICLE IN FRONTIERS IN NEUROENGINEERING THAT ADDRESSES THIS QUESTION WITH EXCITING FINDINGS. (17)  I CONCLUDE THIS BLOG WITH A DISCUSSION OF THEIR FINDINGS.

THE MODEL USED WAS ECOG IN SEVEN EPILEPTIC PATIENTS WHO PERFORMED AN OUT LOUD AND SILENT READING TASK.  SUBJECTS READ SHORT STORIES THAT WERE PRESENTED TO THEM BOTH ALOUD AND SILENTLY.  A HIGH GAMMA (70-150 HZ) NEURAL DECODING MODEL WAS BUILT “TO RECONSTRUCT SPECTROTEMPORAL AUDITORY FEATURES OF SELF-GENERATED OVERT SPEECH.”  THE DECODING MODEL TRAINED FROM OVERT, SPOKEN SPEECH WAS USED TO DECODE THE NEURAL ACTIVITY OF COVERT, SILENTLY READ SPEECH (WHICH DID NOT INVOLVE AUDITORY SENSORY INPUT, ONLY INPUT FROM MENTATION!). SPECTROGRAMS WERE GENERATED IN CONTROLS AND IN SUBJECTS WHO USED OVERT AND COVERT SPEECH TO RECONSTRUCT NEURAL RESPONSES WITH A HIGH STATISTICAL ACCURACY.  EVIDENCE WAS PROVIDED THAT SHOWED THAT REPRESENTATIONS OF OVERT AND COVERT SPEECH COULD BE RECONSTRUCTED SHARING A NEURAL SUBSTRATE.  IN OTHER WORDS, OUT LOUD SPEECH AND READ TEXT COULD BE RECONSTRUCTED IN NEURAL NETWORKS MONITORED VIA ECOG.  NO WIRES CONNECTED THE TEST SUBJECTS TO THE CORTICAL MONITORS, INDICATING THAT THE CEREBRAL NETWORK RESPONDED TO WAVES GENERATED BY THE MIND OF THE TEST SUBJECTS.  THE HIGH GAMMA BAND RELIABLY TRACKED NEURONAL ACTIVITY AND CORRELATED WITH THE SPIKE RATE OF THE UNDERLYING NEURAL POPULATION.  THE KEY TEST OF RECONSTRUCTIVE ACCURACY, ACCORDING TO THE AUTHORS, WAS THE ABILITY TO USE THE RECONSTRUCTION TO IDENTIFY SPECIFIC SPEECH UTTERANCES.  THIS WAS POSSIBLE ESPECIALLY FOR OVERT SPEECH.

Is wave function reality?

Throughout my writings I have referred to quantum wave functions and to wave forms that vary in frequency, amplitude and shape. In “Waves in Our Brains,” Part Two (to which I referred in a very recent blog on March 1, 2021) I have shared that wave forms now appear to be generated by the immaterial mind of Man (and by the Mind of God, I would add) that transmit specified information to and through neural synaptic networks. The term wave function consists of all the information wave forms can assume in a probabilistic manner. W. A. Dembski has referred to the “small probabilities” that describe the specification of information that can be transmitted between a sender and recipient. Wave forms, if you will, are expressions of “small probabilities” by which wave functions can be specifically manifested, for example within linguistic neural codes.

But are quantum wave functions real? Colbeck and Renner have addressed this question and have found that they are elements of reality in a one-to-one correspondence. (https://cqi.inf.usi.ch/qic/ColbeckRenner2012_2.pdf) The authors maintain that the wave function corresponds to an element of reality that objectively exists, and it does not depend on whether it is measured or not. Colbeck and Renner’s claim is that “…the wave function includes all information that is in principle available about the system….” So we can justifiably assume that wave forms correspond to specified elements of reality.

Is mind an immortal reality?

It is important to explain the relationship between the mind and the soul. In my writings I have defined the soul as consisting of the mind, the will and the emotion expressed by the living human being. Yes, there are “soulish” animals, such as dogs and horses. If you have ever ridden a horse (as I have on many occasions over 35 plus years) you have been exposed to its emotions and its will, such as when it has tried to rub you off its back against a fence or beneath a low limb! It is with its mind that it expresses its will or intention to get you off of its back! But, to the best of our theological knowledge “soulish” animals have no spirit, as does Man, and it is not known if “soulish” animals have immortal souls. But how about Man? Is the soul of Man immortal? Scripturally we have reason to believe that indeed the soul of Man IS immortal, as is his spirit.

Michael Egnor wrote an article on January 31, 2021 that speaks to this issue. It appeared in “Mind Matters.” (https://mindmatters.ai/2021/01/your-soul-has-no-off-switch/) Egnor states that “Man has a soul, and the mind is several powers of the soul - sensation, perception, sensus communis, imagination, memory, sensitive appetite, reason, and will.” He continues saying, “But there is no evidence - either philosophical or scientific - that the mind or the soul (of which the mind is an aspect) has an “on switch” or an “off switch.” The most reasonable scientific inference is that we are never “unconscious,” nor are we “conscious” in any meaningful sense. Our mental life is a composite of abilities - arousal, sensation, perception, locomotion, reason, etc., and these abilities appear to subsist in modified form despite dramatic changes in the body and brain….Even after death, we often seem to retain awareness that can be verified, and even have heightened awareness, as the massive literature on near death experiences demonstrates….Our minds are never off; we just have states in which one or more powers of the mind - sensation or perception or memory etc. - are temporarily inactive….Most egregiously, the concept of “consciousness” perpetuates the lie that we are extinguished at death. There is every reason - philosophical and scientific - to infer that man has an immortal soul.” Our mind is an immortal reality.

Information flow and brain waves

Researchers from The Picower Institute for Learning and Memory at the Massachusetts Institute of Technology published an article in 2020 that addresses information flow through the brain. The title is “Preservation and Changes in Oscillatory Dynamics across the Cortical Hierarchy.” and the authors are Mikael Lundqvist, Andre M. Bastos and Earl K. Miller. An excellent review of the article appeared in Science Daily on September 8, 2020 to which I now refer. To produce … thoughts and actions, [the] brain processes information in a hierarchy of regions along its surface, or cortex. … many studies have looked at how synchronized the phases of a particular frequency are between cortical regions. … [The authors found] a systematic shift in preferred frequencies across regions. [In their animal studies three regions were studied, the visual cortex, the parietal cortex and the prefrontal cortex, and the animals were given the task of correctly identifying an image they had just seen. The authors tracked the waves produced by this activity in the three regions.] In each region they found that when an image was either being encoded (when it was first presented) or recalled (when working memory was tested), the power of theta and gamma frequency bands of brain waves would increase in bursts and power in alpha and beta bands would decrease. When the information had to be held in mind, … theta and gamma power went down and alpha and beta power went up in bursts. … the bursts of theta and gamma power were closely associated with neural spikes that encoded information about the images. Alpha and beta power bursts … were anti-correlated with that same spiking activity. … As you move from the back of the brain to the front, all the frequencies get a little higher. … the inverse relationships between frequency bands … are consistent with a model in which alpha and beta alternatively inhibit, or release, gamma to control the encoding of information - a form of top-down control of sensory activity. … The increased frequency in the oscillatory rhythms may help sculpt information flow in the cortex.”

I cite this article because it shows how brain waves in different frequencies work in synchrony to provide the flow of information through different regions of the brain. As I stated in “Waves in Our Brains,” Part Two, energy in wave forms is transmitted through the brain’s synaptic networks linguistically encoded to convey semantic information, and this article elaborates on that point. My objective is to identify work that supports dualist interaction between the immaterial mind and the material neural networks of the brain involving wave forms generated by the intention or attention of the immaterial mind.

Neural encoding of imagined touch

I have come across an interesting article that is relevant to research that supports dualist interaction between the immaterial mind and the material brain. It is entitled “Neural Encoding of Actual and Imagined Touch within Human Posterior Parietal Cortex,” authored by Srinivas Chivukula et al in eLife and published on March 1, 2021 (https://doi.org/10.7554/eLife.61646) I am posting excerpts from that article along with my comments:

“Recent human neuroimaging studies suggest that the PPC [posterior parietal cortex] is also recruited during touch cognition in the absence of actual tactile input (e.g., seen touch or imagined touch), supporting a notion that both higher-level touch processing and tactile cognition share a neural substrate. . . . we found that a shared PPC neuronal population coded for overt movements as well as cognitive motor variables including imagery, observed actions, and action verbs. . . . The tactile imagery task evoked body part-specific responses that shared a neural substrate with actual touch. Our results demonstrate that PPC neurons that discriminate touch are partially reactivated during a tactile imagery task in a body part-specific manner. The latter represents a novel finding . . . and suggests PPC involvement in the cognitive processing of touch. . . . Recordings were made from a chronic implanted array, and thus neuronal waveform sorting resulted in both well-isolated neuronal waveforms and multi-neuron groupings.”

The authors asked the important question, “Are neurons that encode tactile sensations also recruited during tactile imagery?” Recall the comment above, “. . . and thus neuronal waveform sorting resulted in both well-isolated neuronal waveforms . . . .” Previous blog posts have identified the compelling possibility that the cognitive mind has the capacity to generate waveforms that interact with neural synaptic networks to transmit specified information through neural networks in the form of linguistic neural codes within spike trains of action potentials. It is important to note that “. . . during the imagery task, no stimulus was delivered to the participant.“

In previous blogs and as discussed in my books a nonclassical, immaterial energy generated by the immaterial mind may interact with material neural networks as waveforms with amplitude and frequency that are transmitted through neural synapses by quantum tunneling. Are we getting closer to at least a partial understanding of how the Mind of God communes with the mind of Man?

Imagining touch

An article was published on April 3, 2014 entitled “Dissociating the Neural Correlates of Experiencing and Imagining Affective Touch.” The authors are Molly V. Lucas, Laura C. Anderson, Danielle A. Bolling, Kevin A. Pelphrey and Martha D. Kaiser. The investigators shared that “both experiencing and viewing affective . . . touch recruit similar neural mechanisms.” An observation from earlier studies suggests that “some components involved in touch perception do not require physical sensation. . . .The anterior insula of the brain is involved in subjective feeling states and affective learning.” The investigators “sought to characterize . . . stimulus-independent activations, which may be coding the affective aspects of gentle [imagined] touch.” Their hypothesis was “that some aspects of brain mechanisms for processing touch may reflect stimulus-independent, cognitive-based, responses, which code for the affective response to touch. . . . While the posterior insula showed activation only during the physical experience of touch, the anterior insula was responsive to both experienced and imagined touch, suggesting that this region plays a role in the interpretation of the affective meaning of the touch.”

I propose from my studies that the mere imagining of touch in the prefrontal cortex generates specific wave forms that stimulate spike trains of action potentials transmitting neural codes with meaning through synaptic networks. The cognitive mind is the interpreter of the codes. That the anterior insula “plays a role in the interpretation of the affective meaning of the touch” is explained by the synaptic transmission of neural codes within specific regions of the brain that the cognitive mind “reads” through a lifelong process of learning archived in memory. It is important for neuroscientists to account for the activity of the cognitive mind in such interpretation.

So what, dualist interactionism?

I have spent close to 30 years in research, written two books and now have a website and over 700 blogs that expand on the contents of my books. One can ask, “So what?” Why have I spent so much time and energy on this task? Let me answer.

I find that many people who consider themselves Christians, and this includes pastors, cannot differentiate between the spirit and the soul and their relation to the body and fail to give full explanation to the human spirit and its relation to the Holy Spirit. Reference is made to the “heart,” but no explanation is given to what constitutes the “heart.” Yes, the Bible refers to the heart, but what IS the heart in this context? And what does it mean when it is taught that the Holy Spirit indwells the body, the “heart?” OR, did the indwelling of the Holy Spirit cease at the closure of the Canon? Does the Holy Spirit indwell repentant mankind in our time? What exactly does it mean to be indwelled by the Holy Spirit? Can we only pray TO God, or can we yet hear FROM and receive Counsel FROM God through His indwelling Holy Spirit, sent as promised by Jesus Christ upon His resurrection, as documented in the Book of Acts? And how do we hear from God, or can we only pray TO Him? Is being “spiritual” merely signified by the raising of hands in song or by other physical actions? What IS worship anyway? Is it expressed only in song and when we “feel” the “moving of the Holy Spirit,” however that is expressed in an emotion?

In a very recent communication with a dear friend I made the following statement: “My research really does not deal with consciousness but rather with the cognitive, immaterial mind/soul of humanity and how it relates to the spirit both of Man and of God in dualist interaction with the material neural synaptic networks of the brain.” But the fair question is, “So what?” So many questions! IT HAS BEEN THE PURPOSE OF MY WRITING IN MY BOOKS AND IN MY BLOGS TO ADDRESS THESE  VERY CRITICAL QUESTIONS. We are now living in an era when science is “king,” and we must ask if there is concordance between properly conducted and interpreted science, including of course, neuroscience, and properly interpreted Scripture in context. In my next blogs I will endeavor to succinctly address these questions. It is important to the Great Commission given to all mankind by Jesus Christ.

Tripartite Man

I now address the question if Man is a tripartite being. Spirit and soul can be confusing concepts since the words appear to be used interchangeably in Scripture. And where does spirit fit in?

For the word of God is living and active. Sharper than any double-edged sword. It penetrates even to dividing soul and spirit, joints and marrow. Hebrews 4:12

From my first book, Nerve Endings of the Soul: Interaction Between the Mind of God and the Mind of Man Through Neural Synaptic Networks, I addressed this issue with comments that give support to Hebrews 4:12:

Then God said, “Let Us make man in our image, in my likeness” . . . . So God created man in his own image, in the image of God He created him; male and female He created them. Genesis 1:26-27

God is a triune God, Father, Son and Holy Spirit. Only the Spirit knows the Mind of God. (1 Corinthians 2:11) Since man was created in the image of God (imago Dei) it is biblical that man is tripartite with body, soul and spirit. 1 Thessalonians 5:23 states, “May God himself, the God of peace, sanctify you through and through. May your whole spirit, soul and body be kept blameless at the coming of our Lord Jesus Christ.” When God formed man from the dust of the ground, He breathed “the breath of life” into him. (Genesis 2:7) It is this life from God that constitutes the human spirit, and as it is with God only the human spirit truly knows the mind of man. It is the soul of man that is the vehicle through which the mind’s will operates, and if a repentant man’s soul wills to obey God, it will allow the spirit to rule over the man as ordered by the indwelling Holy Spirit. As spirit acts upon the soul of man, the soul in turn expresses itself through the brain and body.

With the Fall of man (Genesis 3) the image of God in humans was corrupted with the loss of intimate communion between the soul of man and the Holy Spirit since Man in sin experienced spiritual death, losing [the indwelling personal] communion between the Holy Spirit and his human spirit. Man’s mind became governed by his soul, the will of his own self-centered focus. The relationship between God and Man was and is designed to be a bidirectional, interactive one. Man’s capacity is to use all the communicable attributes of his Creator God, his mind being created in the image of the Mind of God. The restoration of this interaction depends upon Man’s repentance and the soul’s choice to follow the Counsel of the Holy Spirit through his human spirit.

Indwelling of the Holy Spirit

What does it mean to be indwelled, or anointed, by the Holy Spirit? In The Boundless Love of God: A Holy Spirit Story, I address this action. In the next blogs I will share my comments from this book, beginning with the indwelling of Jesus Christ, the God-Man, by the Holy Spirit of his Father. Recall that I refer to the soul as consisting of mind, will, emotion and conscience and heart as the soul.

Throughout his life Jesus lived and spoke in complete obedience to God’s counsel through his indwelling Holy Spirit. In John 15:9-15 Jesus teaches that he has obeyed his Father’s commands and that everything he has learned from his Father he has made known to his disciples. In the synagogue in Nazareth Jesus opened the scroll of Isaiah and read, “The Spirit of the Lord is on me because he has anointed me to preach the good news…,” confirming his identity with God the Father and fulfilling Scripture that identified him as the promised Messiah. To Thomas he said, “If you really knew me, you would know my Father as well. From now on, you do know him and have seen him.” Responding to a question from Phillip Jesus stated, “Anyone who has seen me has seen the Father. How can you say, ‘Show us the Father? Don’t you believe that I am in the Father, and that the Father is in me? The words I say to you are not just my own. Rather, it is the Father, living in me, who is doing his work. Believe me when I say that I am in the Father and the Father is in me.” These passages confirm Jesus’ indwelling by his Father through his Holy Spirit who descended to dwell in the human spirit of Jesus just after he was baptized by John the Baptist. He willfully lived in complete obedience to the Father all his life, even to his death. As Jesus was dying on the cross he cried out, “Father, into your hands I commit my spirit.” That Jesus possessed a human spirit is indicated by these words he spoke on the cross. His very last words were, “‘It is finished.’ With that he bowed his head and gave up his spirit.” These verses confirm that Jesus the Man possessed a spirit and submitted it in full obedience to the Spirit of the Father.

Indwelling of the Holy Spirit, restored

The Book of Acts could be called The Acts of the Holy Spirit since there are fifty-six references to the Holy Spirit in the twenty-eight chapters of the book, more than in any other single book of the Bible. Huber L. Drumwright, Jr. stated that Jesus Christ continued his work through the lives and ministries of his disciples. In John 12:24 Jesus told his disciples, “I tell you the truth, unless a kernel of wheat falls to the ground and dies, it remains only a single seed. But if it dies it produces many seeds.” Walter Thomas Conner said, “The Holy Spirit is the presence of the living Lord Jesus in spiritual power in the lives of men.”

This work was begun at Pentecost as recorded in Acts 2:14-36 when the Holy Spirit was given as an indwelling as Jesus had promised before his death on the cross. The Spirit was given to dwell permanently once again inside all repentant believers, making regeneration possible for all mankind. Regeneration refers to the restoration of the intimate, direct, personal interaction between the Holy Spirit and the human spirit and soul that was lost at the Fall. Though yet fallen in our time humanity in repentance has been granted salvation by the grace and love of God through the sacrifice of his Son, Jesus Christ, resurrected by the power of the Holy Spirit. The price for sin has been paid. Life is restored in the living Jesus Christ. Spirit-indwelled individuals are spokespersons for God, and their testimony is Spirit-originated and Spirit-empowered. The first Christian sermon was given by Peter at Pentecost, and the events demonstrated that Jesus who was raised from the dead had his authority extended beyond our time into eternity and beyond Earth into heaven. Jesus reigns by virtue of his resurrection. The presence and power of the Holy Spirit is the proof.

Effects of the indwelling Holy Spirit

I conclude this series of blog posts by commenting on how the indwelling of the Holy Spirit in repentant believers is manifested. The Apostle Paul admonished believers to walk by the leading of the Holy Spirit, as did the God-Man Jesus Christ. In doing so they manifest the fruits of the Holy Spirit. These include love, joy, peace, patience, kindness, goodness, faithfulness, gentleness and self-control. The Source of these effects is the character and living presence of Jesus Christ. Desires of the flesh reflect an attitude of defiance to God. Believers who live in obedience to the leading of the Holy Spirit are “sealed,” signifying that God has ownership of them.

Paul also taught that spiritual gifts are given to believers for the benefit of the whole Church. The gifts are supernatural, Spirit-given abilities that are addressed in 1 Corinthians 12:1-11. The gifts are given by one Spirit for the common good, the Spirit of Jesus Christ. These include wisdom, knowledge, faith, healing, miracles, prophecy. the discernment of spirits, tongues, interpretation of tongues, service, teaching, encouragement, sharing, leadership and showing mercy. We are designed to need each other and to serve one another. Communion and companionship vertically between the Christian and the Father will always include a horizontal relationship in love among the saints.

It is my hope that what I have shared in this series of blogs is helpful for an understanding of what it means to be indwelled by the Holy Spirit. How does the indwelling relate to the human spirit and soul, and how does communion occur in our time between the Holy Spirit and the human spirit and soul? It is a communion actualized by the transmission of meaning in neural codes through God’s created synaptic networks. It is a bidirectional dualist interaction between the immaterial Mind of God and mind of Man and the exquisite material mechanisms of the human brain.

Jesus knew what they were thinking

The first verses I shall share are in Luke 5:21-23:

The Pharisees and the teachers of the law began thinking to themselves, “Who is this fellow who speaks blasphemy? Who can forgive sins but God alone?” Jesus knew what they were thinking and asked, “Why are you thinking these things in your hearts? Which is easier to say, ‘Your sins are forgiven,’ or to say, ‘Get up and walk?’”

Another instance of Jesus’ knowing the thoughts of other people is recorded in Luke 6:7-8:

The Pharisees and the teachers of the law were looking for a reason to accuse Jesus, so they watched him closely to see if he would heal on the Sabbath. But Jesus knew what they were thinking and said to the man with the shriveled hand, “Get up and stand in front of everyone.” So he got up and stood there.

I refer to the scheme for communication discussed in my books as a template for information transmission between the Mind of God and the mind of Man via the indwelling of the human spirit by the personal Holy Spirit. It also applies to the communication between God the Father and his Son, the God-Man Jesus Christ, who was indwelled by the Holy Spirit at his baptism. In this scheme the identification of the Sender, or information Source, is the Mind of God the Father, and the recipient, or receiver, is the mind of Man, applicable in this case to the Mind of Jesus Christ the God-Man. The transmitter of specified information in this scheme is the Holy Spirit who directs a signal with meaning and purpose to the receiver, in this case the cognitive Mind of Jesus. The signal is in the form of spike patterns of action potentials transmitted through the neural synaptic networks as linguistic codes in various manifestations, including perceived words and discernment. I suggest a parallel between this scheme and the cited Scriptures wherein Jesus “knew what they were thinking.” It is a dualist interaction between immaterial and material entities created by God.

The God Hypothesis

I have finished reading Stephen C. Meyer’s new book, Return of the God Hypothesis, and I strongly recommend it to you. My next blog posts will address points made in his book and relate them to the points I have made in my books and blogs concerning dualist interactionism. As Meyer stated, too many people, including some leading scientists today, do not accept the reality that properly interpreted Scripture in context and good science can be in concordance without contradiction, a point I have made in my writings. I value his book since the transcendent intelligence that designed the universe and all within and sustains it is identified by inference to the best explanation as the biblical God. I quote from Meyer’s book:

…philosophers or scientists who postulate the existence of God understand God to have certain attributes (e.g., transcendence, intelligence, creativity, omnipresence, and free will) and corresponding causal powers that would allow God to produce certain kinds of effects expected on the basis of those powers….By articulating those attributes, properties, and powers, philosophers can provide a theoretical rationale for affirming the causal adequacy of a God hypothesis…with respect to specific observable phenomena or kinds of events….Since scientists have evidence confirming those expectations in, for example, the discovery of the fine tuning and temporal beginning of the universe and the digital code and information processing systems in living cells, evidence from the world provides confirmation of the theistic hypothesis and positive support for its causal adequacy as an explanation.

God hypothesis response

In the blog I just posted that included Meyer’s comments, I wish to apply his comments to points made in my writings. God’s attributes indeed include His Mind with its intelligence, creativity and free will. He is a personal God who desires a bidirectional communion with Man whom He created. His causal powers that resulted in the creation of the universe and the fine tuning of its constants and laws made human beings possible whose cognitive minds were created in the image of the Mind of God. God is Spirit and immaterial, and we have seen in my writings that the immaterial mind of Man and Mind of God interact with the material synaptic networks of the brain, transmitting specified information within neural codes to achieve goals. Likewise the DNA code is digital and transmits specified information instantiated by the intelligent design of our Creator God for a multitude of purposes. As Meyer has stated so well, the specification of information is improbable, selected by the willful design of God as well as by the design of the will and intention of Man. Information is only generated by a mind, and its immaterial reality is ultimately derived from the Mind of God. These are observed phenomena, events that give testimony to the validity of the God hypothesis by the scientific process clearly explained by Meyer, inference to the best explanation. These phenomena also give testimony to dual interaction between that which is immaterial and is material.

Waves in Our Brains, Part Three

 I am posting a new third part of the blog, “Waves in Our Brains,” previously posted in two parts.  My research continues, and I find it important to supplement what I shared in that two-part blog in relation to the hypothesis I recorded in my first book, Nerve Endings of the Soul: Interaction between the Mind of God and the Mind of Man through Neural Synaptic Networks. I will continue to expand on this third part in subsequent blogs, drawing from both neuroscientific literature and applicable Scripture.

The Hypothesis

The Mind of the personal God interacts with the immaterial mind of Man by the atoning grace of God through the living Jesus Christ in our time.  His Holy Spirit indwells a receptive, repentant human spirit with the power to interact with the chemical neural synaptic network of the cerebral cortex, the predominate site for cognition.  Synaptic transmission is stochastic, and it proposed that a nonmaterial energy from the Mind of God induces the synaptic transmission of specified information to the mind of Man by quantum tunneling across presynaptic vesicular grids and synaptic clefts.  Information specified in variable expressions is transmitted with a statistically small probability and is distributed through synaptic networks as encoded spike trains of action potentials, a mechanism without violation of the energy conservation law.  The human mind has the unique capacity to interpret meaning and purpose within the linguistic neural codes developed through lifelong learning and archived in memory.

Expansion of The Hypothesis

Drawing upon the blog posts composed from my more recent studies, the content of my books and from books by Stephen C. Meyer and William A. Dembski, I am expanding on the hypothesis presented above.  

Stephen Meyer discusses a universal wave function that is resident in the Mind of God (Return of the God Hypothesis: Three Scientific Discoveries that Reveal the Mind behind the Universe).  It existed before the beginning of time, space, energy and matter and consisted of all possible wave forms of position and momentum, amplitude, frequency and shape in a vast probability distribution.  By God’s design He selected specific wave forms from all the possible presentations of the universal wave function to actualize His goals for the design, structure, fine tuning, meaning and purpose of the universe as well as for sustaining it over time.  It is the process by which He selected wave forms to transmit specified information content for the creation of human life, including the immaterial, cognitive mind of human beings and its interaction with the physical human brain.  It is an outcome that provides for personal communion between mankind and with God.

It is the selection of outcomes derived from the universal wave function that defines specification, the process by which information generated via the Mind of God has been actualized within His creations by His will and design. The outcomes chosen have small probabilities, or put another way, are improbable considering the infinite options God has had from within the universal wave function.  A nondeterministic universe as given by quantum mechanics is informationally open, and in previous blog posts and in my books we have seen how quantum mechanics applies to the dualist interaction between the immaterial mind and the material synaptic networks of the physical human brain.  To quote William A. Dembski, “Such a universe will produce . . . random events [from which are chosen by a mind’s intent] patterns [Italics added] of events that stand out against the backdrop of randomness (as a signal stands out from noise).  Such patterns . . . could reasonably be interpreted as constituting novel information inputted from outside the system.  Accordingly, in a nondeterministic universe, divine action could impart information into matter without violating any physical laws by which matter operates.” Dembski goes further, stating, “Nondeterminism means that God can substantively affect the structure and dynamics of the physical world by imparting information . . . a nondeterministic universe can be informationally porous and thus open to action by a deity able to impart information without imparting material [Italics added] energy.  Quantum mechanics, when interpreted as a fundamentally probabilistic theory, offers such a picture of the universe, allowing God free play at the quantum level” (Being as Communion: A Metaphysics of Information, Ashgate, 2014 and my books).  As discussed in “Waves in Our Brains” the most recent research in neuroscience is identifying how waves are transmitted via quantum tunneling through the synaptic networks of the human brain in the form of linguistic neural codes, or patterns.  The waves emanate from the immaterial, cognitive mind of humans and from the Mind of God.  By causal interaction with the networks of the brain outcomes result with meaning and purpose.

In his book Meyer cited these comments made by Dembski: “Systems, sequences, or events that exhibit two characteristics at the same time – extreme improbability and a special kind of pattern called a ‘specification” – indicate prior intelligent activity.  According to Dembski, extremely improbable events that also exhibit ‘an independently recognizable pattern’ or set of functional requirements, what he calls ‘specification,’ invariably result from intelligent causes, not chance or physicochemical laws.”  Meyer states that “our uniform experience affirms that specified or functional information . . . always arises from an intelligent source, from a mind [that is immaterial].”  And we now understand that the ultimate Source of all information instantiated into the universe and all within it is the immaterial Mind of God, who is Spirit. (John 4:24)

Meyer stated that “In using language the human mind routinely ‘finds’ or generates highly improbable linguistic sequences to convey a preconceived idea.  In the process of thought [or cognition], functional objectives precede and constrain the selection of words, sounds, and symbols to generate functional (and meaningful) sequences from a vast ensemble of meaningless alternatives. . . . Intelligent agents can select functional goals before the goals are physically instantiated. . . . They can then actualize those goals in accord with a preconceived design plan or set of functional requirements.” The linguistic patterns are then transmitted by wave forms into neural codes within spike trains of action potentials interpreted by the cognitive mind of humans and archived in memory.

Meyer provided evidence of “the causal adequacy of intelligent agency as a cause of the kind of specified digital information [and fine tuning] needed to produce life [and I would add dualist interaction between mind and brain] . . . including the unique causal adequacy of a transcendent and intelligent agent as the best explanation.” 

In his concluding remarks, Meyer stated, “Since theism holds that a benevolent God possessing a rational intellect created our minds, we have good reason to expect the basic reliability of our belief-forming cognitive equipment.  Since most versions of theism hold that the same benevolent and rational God who created our minds created them in God’s image and also created a rationally ordered universe, we have good reason to think we can understand and perceive the order built into that universe. . . . Our beautiful, expanding, and finely tuned universe and the exquisite, integrated, and informational complexity of living organisms bear witness to the reality of a transcendent intelligence – a personal God.”  And we can have confidence in what neuroscientists are learning about the orderly interaction between the human mind and the synaptic networks of the brain via the application of good, unprejudiced scientific methodology unconstrained by methodological naturalism and materialism.  The comments I have shared given by Stephen Meyer and William Dembski provide a foundation for accepting the validity of dualist interactionism between that which is immaterial and material, the mind and the brain.

Stan Lennard
Minds in Communion - 7

Information, matter, design and intelligence

In my books and my blogs on this website I have often referred to information, matter, design and intelligence. I have endeavored to explain both what the terms mean and how they relate, fundamentally to our Creator God. This is a challenging task. Dr. William A. Dembski has made significant contributions to intelligent design and how information and energy are related. In the next series of blogs I will post excerpts from his article, “An Information-Theoretic Proof of God’s Existence.” (https://billdembski.com/wp-content/uploads/2012/09/) He identified the most troubling word in the title, “proof,” a word that derives etymologically from the Latin probare, which means to test and to approve or esteem as good that which has passed a test. It is in this sense that he describes how information theory approves God’s existence. By citing the writing and work of Dr. Dembski in this article I believe these terms will be clarified as few people can.

Design argument

The design argument begins with features of the natural world that exhibit evidence of purpose and from there attempts to establish the existence and attributes of an intelligent cause responsible for those features. (W. A. Dembski)

Creation and design

We need here to draw a clear distinction between creation and design. Creation is always about the source of being of the world. Design is about arrangements of preexisting materials that point to an intelligence. Creation and design are therefore quite different. . . . Creation asks for an ultimate resting place of explanation - the source of being of the world. Design, by contrast, inquires not into the ultimate source of matter and energy but into the cause of their present arrangements, particularly those entities, large and small, that exhibit signs of intelligence. (W. A. Dembski)

Information and matter

Matter is raw stuff that can take any number of shapes. Information is what gives shape to matter, fixing one shape to the exclusion of others. . . . Information (from the Latin verb informare) literally means to give form or shape to something. Unlike passive or inert matter, which needs to be acted upon, information is active. Information acts on matter to give it its form, shape, arrangement, or structure. . . . The relation between matter, with its potential to assume any possible shapes, and information, with its restriction of possibilities to a narrow range of shapes, is fundamental to our understanding of the world. (W. A. Dembski)

Design and nature

Dr. Dembski points out in his article that the relation between matter and information can become controversial when they are mixed with design and nature. “. . . designing intelligences are not the only causal powers capable of structuring matter and thereby conferring information. Nature, too, is capable of structuring matter and conferring information. . . . Nature and design therefore represent two different ways of producing information. Nature produces information, as it were, internally. . . . design [consists] in capacities external to an object for bringing about its form with outside help. . . . nature [consists] in capacities internal to an object for transforming itself without outside help. . . . information is conferred on an object from outside the object and that the material constituting the object, apart from that outside information, does not have the power to assume the form it does. . . . Nature produces information not by imposing it from outside but by growing or developing informationally rich structures from within. . . . an information-theoretic design argument contends that the art of building certain information-rich structures in nature (like biological organisms) is not in the physical stuff that constitutes these structures but requires a designer.” (W. A. Dembski)

Information and meaning

Ordinarily when we think of information, we think of meaningful statements that we communicate to each other. The vehicle of communication here is language, and the information is the meaning communicated by some utterance or linguistic expression. . . . For information to be generated . . . means identifying one possibility and ruling out the rest. The more possibilities get ruled out and, correspondingly, the more improbable the possibility that actually obtains, the greater the information generated. . . . To generate information is therefore to rule out possibilities. (w. A. Dembski)

Complex specified information

Complex specified information . . . requires a dual ruling-out of possibilities, one by an intelligent agent who identifies a pattern [such as a linguistic neural code with structure, meaning and purpose] and one by physical processes that induce an event [such as spike trains of action potentials that transmit neural codes through neural synaptic networks to bring about specific actions]. Provided these coincide, the probability is small, and the pattern can be identified independently of the event, we say the event exhibits complex specified information. Complex specified information reliably detects design. (W. A.Dembski)

Choice and intelligent agency

The principal characteristic of intelligent agency is choice. “Intelligent” derives from two Latin words, the preposition inter, meaning between, and the verb lego, meaning to choose or select. Thus, according to its etymology, intelligence consists in choosing between. For an intelligent agent to act is therefore to choose from a range of competing possibilities. . . . Actualizing one among several competing possibilities, ruling out the rest, and specifying the one that was actualized encapsulates how we recognize intelligent agency, or equivalently, how we detect design, (W. A. Dembski)

Nature and existing information

. . . when natural systems exhibit intelligence by producing complex specified information, they have in fact not created it from scratch but merely shuffled around existing information. Nature is a matrix for expressing already existing information [e.g. acorn to an oak tree]. . . . the ultimate source of that information resides in an intelligence not reducible to nature. (W. A. Dembski)

The designer

Complex specified information refers to patterns embodied in physical structures. But if the designer is not a physical structure, the designer, though capable of bringing about complex specified information, would not in turn exhibit complex specified information. . . . The designer responsible for the complex specified information in nature is, as best we can tell, not an event, object, or structure. . . . Who is the designer? . . . Design inferred from complex specified information in nature is compatible with Christian belief but does not entail it. This is as it should be. Nature is silent about the revelation of Christ in Scripture. At the same time, nothing prevents nature from independently testifying to the God revealed in the Scripture. . . . An information-theoretic design argument therefore removes us from the paths of atheistic materialism that lead away from God and takes us a modest distance toward an intelligence behind nature who, from the vantage of Christian theology, can be no other than God. In this way, information theory (ap)proves the existence of God. (W. A. Dembski)

Stan Lennard
Minds in Communion - 6

Mystery of the mind

In his preface to his book, Mystery of the Mind: A Critical Study of Consciousness and the Human Brain, Dr. Wilder Penfield shared his experience listening to a lecture by Sir Charles Sherrington as a medical student in Oxford. He said, “I realized that there was a thrilling undiscovered country to be explored in the mechanisms of the mammalian nervous system. Through it, one might approach the mystery of the mind, . . . there was always a restless wondering within me about the working of the brain and its relation to mind. . . . the primary duty of each of us is to give an account of his own intriguing expeditions into this undiscovered country and to pass on his own record accurately and hopefully to others who follow on these explorations that have now become a fateful pilgrimage.

In the blogs to follow I will show how prescient the neurosurgeon, Dr. Penfield, was in elucidating the interaction between the mind and the brain through his studies conducted on live patients.

Brain mechanisms and the mind

Quoting Dr. Penfield, “Throughout my own scientific career I, like other scientists, have struggled to prove that the brain accounts for the mind. But now, perhaps, the time has come when we may profitably consider the evidence as it stands, and ask the question: Do brain-mechanisms account for the mind? Can the mind be explained by what is now known about the brain? If not, which is the more reasonable of the two possible hypotheses: that man’s being is based on one element, or on two? . . . But it is, I believe, a mystery that science will solve some day. In that day of understanding, I predict that true prophets will rejoice, for they will discover in the scientist a long-awaited ally in the search for Truth.

Distinctive reality of mind

Charles W. Hendel wrote the Foreword for Dr. Penfield’s book. He said, “. . . I find the last pages are an eloquent, convincing justification of your hypothesis and belief that mind has a being distinct from body, though intimately related to and dependent on body. . . . mind is a very distinctive reality.”

Mind's energy

I continue with an excerpt from the Foreward to Dr. Penfield’s book written by Charles W. Hendel:

“[Dr. Penfield] became more and more convinced that the mind is something in its own right, that it did things with the mechanisms at hand in its own way, that it had an ‘energy’ of its own. . . . [He aligned himself] with the prophets, the poets, and the philosophers who have emphasized the spiritual element in man.”

Mind's continuing existence

I continue with another excerpt from the Foreward to Dr. Penfield’s book:

“. . . the mind must be viewed as a basic element in itself. One might call it a medium, an essence, a soma. That is to say, it has a continuing existence.”

The mind's energy

In Chapter 12 Penfield makes the following statements:

By taking thought, the mind considers the future and gives short-term direction to the sensory-motor automatic mechanism. But the mind, I surmise, can give direction only through the mind’s brain-mechanism. It is all very much like programming a private computer. The program comes to an electrical computer from without. The same is true of each biological computer. Purpose comes to it from outside its own mechanism. This suggest that the mind must have a supply of energy available to it for independent action.

The mind has energy

But the mind has energy. The form of that energy is different from that of neuronal potentials that travel the axone pathways. (Wilder Penfield)

Highest brain mechanism

In my book, Nerve Endings of the Soul: Interaction Between the Mind of God and the Mind of Man through Neural Synaptic Networks, I share Dr. Penfield’s comments about what he called “the brain’s highest mechanism.”

“The highest brain mechanism . . . should itself understand, and reason, and direct voluntary action, and decide where attention should be turned and what the computer [brain] must learn, and record, and reveal on demand.”

I posit in my book that Penfield’s highest brain mechanism interacts with the will, intention and attention of the individual Self. . . . Penfield refers to the highest brain mechanism as the mind’s executive. By some means the executive accepts direction from the mind and passes it on to various mechanisms of the brain conforming, I suggest, to the liaison brain proposed by Eccles and Popper that serves as the resource for neural codes specified for certain neural functions. Penfield goes on to say that decisions come from the mind, and “in conformity with the mind’s decision, the highest mechanism sends neuronal messages [encoded] to the other mechanisms in the brain,” again in conformity with Eccles’ and Popper’s liaison brain. . . . Penfield posits that the messages go as neuronal potentials arranged in a specified pattern [linguistic neural codes] to the appropriate target grey matter, requiring the subject’s mind to interpret what the pattern represents in terms of meaning and purpose.

What the mind does

But what the mind does is different. It is not to be accounted for by any neuronal mechanism that I can discover. (Wilder Penfield)

Mind is the person, the Self

Dr. Wilder Penfield commented on the mind’s being the person. In my first book, Nerve Endings of the Soul: Interaction Between the Mind of God and the Mind of Man through Neural Synaptic Networks, I share a discussion of the inner person of the Self. This discussion gives validity to the mind’s being not only transcendent of the material brain but also being the “inner core” that is each individual that survives physical death.

Doctor James Le Fanu has presented a discussion of the “self” that is an excellent lead-in to the work of Eccles. . . . Le Fanu describes the Self as the “inner person” composed of several distinct attributes. These include a unique subjective experience of the world that is the Self’s alone, that the Self is an autonomous agent with freedom to choose [via the will of the cognitive mind], that it is founded upon a rich autobiographical inner record of memory, an accumulated subjective experience extending back to childhood and that it possesses powers of reason and imagination expressed through language extending beyond the boundaries of personal experience. The “self” is non-material with no substance, and it cannot be weighed or measured. Its non-material attributes collectively form the “inner core” [of the mind] that is each unique individual. Self is grounded in the human brain which facilitates its formation through cognition and memory, but it has a coherent, durable, transcendent reality that cannot be explained by ever-changing, transient electrical activity of neuronal circuits.

Nature of the mind and the mind's energy

When we come to understand man, we will see that the nature of the mind and the nature of the mind’s energy is simple and easily comprehensible. However, that shows only that I am an optimist. (Dr. Wilder Penfield)

It is my hope that the information shared in my books and blogs makes our mind more understandable as being created in the image of the Mind of God who is Spirit and that our understanding of the human mind as being irreducible to the physical brain becomes clear. The human mind transcends our brain, has a distinct energy and is eternal. Along with our will, emotion and conscience, it is our soul.

The attention of the mind

From Dr. Penfield’s book, Mystery of the Mind:

One can only conclude that conscious attention adds something to brain-action that would otherwise leave no record. It gives to the passage of neuronal potentials an astonishing permanence of facilitation for the later passage of current, as though a trail had been blazed through the seemingly infinite maze of neurone connections. . . . Permanent facilitation of a patterned sequence in these brain mechanisms is established only when there is a focusing of attention on the phenomenon that corresponds to it in consciousness.

If previous decision regarding the focusing of attention is made in the mind, then it is the mind that decides when the facilitating engram is to be added. One may assume that it is the highest brain mechanism that initiates the brain action associated with that decision. One may assume, too, that the engram is simultaneously added to conditioned reflexes and to the sequential record of conscious experience.

Is there any evidence of the existence of neuronal activity within the brain that would account for what the mind does?

My two books and the blog, “Waves in Our Brain,” Parts One and Two, address these comments by Dr. Penfield in considerable detail. In contemporary terms he is addressing the function of the liaison brain and its linguistic codes (facilitating engrams) established through a lifetime of experience and archived in memory. The attention, will and intention of the immaterial mind possess a nonclassical energy that works through the linguistic codes of the liaison brain (Penfield’s highest brain mechanism) to effect functional neuronal activities via synaptic networks, such as lifting an arm, speaking a phrase or expressing an idea.

The attention of the mind

From Dr. Penfield’s book, Mystery of the Mind:

One can only conclude that conscious attention adds something to brain-action that would otherwise leave no record. It gives to the passage of neuronal potentials an astonishing permanence of facilitation for the later passage of current, as though a trail had been blazed through the seemingly infinite maze of neurone connections. . . . Permanent facilitation of a patterned sequence in these brain mechanisms is established only when there is a focusing of attention on the phenomenon that corresponds to it in consciousness.

If previous decision regarding the focusing of attention is made in the mind, then it is the mind that decides when the facilitating engram is to be added. One may assume that it is the highest brain mechanism that initiates the brain action associated with that decision. One may assume, too, that the engram is simultaneously added to conditioned reflexes and to the sequential record of conscious experience.

Is there any evidence of the existence of neuronal activity within the brain that would account for what the mind does?

My two books and the blog, “Waves in Our Brain,” Parts One and Two, address these comments by Dr. Penfield in considerable detail. In contemporary terms he is addressing the function of the liaison brain and its linguistic codes (facilitating engrams) established through a lifetime of experience and archived in memory. The attention, will and intention of the immaterial mind possess a nonclassical energy that works through the linguistic codes of the liaison brain (Penfield’s highest brain mechanism) to effect functional neuronal activities via synaptic networks, such as lifting an arm, speaking a phrase or expressing an idea.

What the mind does

It is what we have learned to call the mind that seems to focus attention. The mind is aware of what is going on. The mind reasons and makes new decisions. It understands. It acts as though endowed with an energy of its own. It can make decisions and put them into effect by calling upon various brain mechanisms. It does this by activating neurone-mechanisms [linguistic neural codes of the liaison brain transmitted with meaning and purpose through the synaptic neural networks]. This, it seems, could only be brought about by expenditure of [both nonclassical, nonphysical, and classical electrochemical] energy. (Dr. Penfield)

What the mind does, continued

. . . to expect the highest brain-mechanism or any set of reflexes, however complicated, to carry out what the mind does, and thus perform all the functions of the mind, is quite absurd. . . . there is, in fact, a second fundamental element and a second form of energy. . . . the mind makes its impact upon the brain through the highest brain-mechanism. The mind must act upon it. . . . The mind must remember by making use of the brain’s recording mechanisms. The mind is present whenever the highest brain-mechanism is functioning normally.

If there are two elements, then energy must be available in two different forms. There is force that is made available through neuronal conduction in the brain. Is there a force that is available to the mind, which has no such circuits? (Wilder Penfield)

The focus of my research over almost 30 years has been to address Dr. Penfield’s question in the last sentence. It is a force/energy used by an immaterial mind that could also include the Mind of God.

Dualist hypothesis

. . . the nature of the mind presents the fundamental problem, perhaps the most difficult and most important of all problems. For myself, after a professional lifetime spent in trying to discover how the brain accounts for the mind, it comes as a surprise now to discover, during this final examination of the evidence, that the dualist hypothesis seems the more reasonable of the two possible explanations [the other being that the brain explains the mind]. . . . What a thrill it is, then, to discover that the scientist, too, can legitimately believe in the existence of the spirit. (Wilder Penfield)

Mind-to-mind communication

Dr. Penfield addressed the question of whether the human mind survives after death and how it relates to energy:

. . . it is clear that, in order to survive after death, the mind must establish a connection with a source of energy other than that of the brain. If not, the mind must disappear forever as surely as the brain and the body die and turn to dust. If, however, during life, when brain and mind are awake, direct communication is sometimes established with the minds of other men or with the mind of God, then it is clear that energy from without can reach a man’s mind. In that case, it is not unreasonable for him to hope that after death the mind may waken to another source of energy. I mean that if the active mind of a man does communicate with other active minds, . . . it could do so only by the transfer of some form of energy from mind to mind directly. Likewise, if the mind of man communicates with the mind of God directly, that also suggests that energy, in some form, passes from spirit to spirit.

Again, I refer you to my two books and my blogs, especially that posted above entitled, “Waves in Our Brains,” Parts One and Two. This important and challenging question posed by Dr. Penfield has been addressed over nearly 30 years of my research. By the grace of God perhaps our understanding is becoming a little closer to the truth.

Stan Lennard
Minds in Communion - 5

The mind-brain problem

It was Sir John C. Eccles who first understood the importance of quantum mechanics for resolving the mind-brain problem. He proposed that mental events can cause brain events. I cite Danko D. Georgiev who said, “Indeed if one considers the wave function of a quantum particle as a non-observable mental state of pre-probabilities and the actualized position in space and time as an observable mental state, then the dualistic interactionism proposed by Sir John Eccles is consistent with the modern vision of what the physical world is.” Perhaps the afore mentioned “non-classical energy” of the mind conforms to the “non-observable mental state” and the spike trains of encoded action potentials to the “actualized position in space and time as an observable mental state.” I quote Rene Descartes who 400 years ago said, “Cartesian dualism postulates that the immaterial mind and the material brain, while being ontologically distinct substances, causally interact.”

 

Energy conservation law

Alvin Plantinga addresses the workings of natural laws in a closed versus an open universe. He points out that the conservation laws derived from Newton’s laws are stated for closed or isolated systems. In closed systems there would be nothing to prevent God from changing the velocity or direction of a (quasi)particle, but if he did so energy would not be conserved. Moreover, it would not be a truly closed system, and the law of conservation of energy would not apply. He states that classical science does not claim that the universe is causally closed. His statement is entirely consistent with special divine action in the world. Just as God, who is immaterial and Spirit, can act in the physical universe, so too can the immaterial minds of human beings. There is no objection to special divine action or for human free action, dualistically conceived.

 

Quantum mechanics and divine action

Plantinga finds that the indeterminism of quantum mechanics offers less of a problem for divine action than classical science. “…special divine action…is by no means incompatible with quantum mechanics…because…quantum mechanics doesn’t determine a specific outcome for a given set of initial conditions, but instead merely assigns probabilities to the possible outcomes.” Special divine action is not restrained. It is free to select via a nonmaterial energy (wave forms interacting via quantum tunneling in the case of synaptic transmission) certain outcomes according to what has been termed “small probabilities” by William A. Dembski, giving definition to specificity [which is meaning for the information we receive as recipients from the Mind of God].

 

Mind-brain interaction

At this time, I will post a “take away” from all that has been presented to this point about the tremendous complexity of dualist interactionism. Along the way I have endeavored to make the posts as understandable as possible, but neurophysiology and quantum mechanics are . . . complex!

Dualist interaction involves a nonmaterial mind with the capacity to cause a probabilistic, directed transmission of synchronous action potentials through coherent synaptic networks of the physical brain. It occurs by quantum tunneling, which induces conformational changes in the protein scaffolds, vesicles, vesicular pores and ionic channels of the components of synaptic networks. By this process neural transmitters are released from vesicular pores into synaptic clefts. The transmitters stimulate linguistically encoded spike trains of action potentials that are conducted through a network of postsynaptic downstream neurons. Synaptic transmission of specified (meaningful) information occurs by this process and is interpreted by a mind through a lifetime of learning. When the intention, attention or will of one’s mind generates encoded neural impulses the mind interprets the codes as Eccles’ “percepts” in real time so that one knows what one is thinking and intending. The linguistic code generated is by an immaterial energy of the mind.

 

Relation of information and energy

 

It is important to consider the relationship between information and energy and how information is transmitted through synaptic networks. I am citing the important work of Dr. William A. Dembski, who has stated that information is dynamic, passing in, through and out of matter. Matter itself can be reduced to the information instantiated within its design, construction and function. “Anything that exhibits information needed at some point to be imparted with information. What causes information to undergo such dynamic transformation? . . . Energy.” Energy is always inferred from information and is the “causal glue” that connects items of information in an informational universe. Material energy is a form of energy but not the whole of energy as stated by Dembski. He asked if there are information transfers that transcend material media and take a nonmaterial form of energy for transmission. The question applies in the context of quantum tunneling which depends upon the material media of synaptic networks for transmission of information encoded with meaning and purpose within spike trains of impulses but cannot be reduced to the synaptic networks themselves. If the energy of an information relationship actualized within wave forms cannot be justified as being material, then it must be nonmaterial.

 

God's free play at the quantum level

 

Dembski has posed the question to traditional theism of how God, who is immaterial and Spirit, can interact with the material world, imparting information into it without applying material energy. Quantum mechanics gives nondeterminism to the universe which characterizes it as being informationally open and accommodating free will, as Alvin Plantinga has pointed out. I am posting a quote from Dembski in Chapter Five of The Boundless Love of God: A Holy Spirit Story, that elaborates on this question:

“. . . in a nondeterministic universe, divine action could impart information into matter without violating any physical laws by which matter operates. . . . A deity capable of co-opting randomness would impart information by arranging outcomes [with small probabilities and specification], but do so by channeling material energy in ways that violate no principle governing matter. If divine action takes this form, the problem of finding the missing material energy by which God introduces novel information into the world simply does not arise . . . . information is then being transferred without any transfer of material energy . . . . Quantum mechanics . . . offers such a picture of the universe, allowing God free play at the quantum level . . . . In a world of irreducibly chance or random events, as some interpretations of quantum theory allow, God can channel such events toward preordained ends.”

In Part Two of “Waves in Our Brains” we see how the specified, encoded frequencies and amplitudes of wave forms generated by the immaterial mind become synchronized with the wave frequencies and amplitudes of selected cerebral modules generated by lifelong learning and archived in memory. The synchronized wave forms in turn stimulate the synaptic transmission through coherent neural networks of the encoded meaning, purpose and intended action of the cognitive mind.

 

Divine action in the framework of quantum events

I am posting an excerpt from a doctoral dissertation by Christoph Lameter that applies to the theme of the last several posts on my blog. It is a quotation included in Chapter Five of The Boundless Love of God: A Holy Spirit Story:

If God can act in reality through coordinating large amounts of quantum events for a purpose at a higher level then it is possible to assume that the same can be done with the human brain. God can effectively communicate with humans by direct stimulation of neurons in the human brain generating images and memories. God is able to communicate with humans in a direct way. May this be an explanation for the working of the Holy Spirit? Visions and other religious experiences could be understood through this process.

Visions, memories and other experiences alluded to by Lameter would be interpreted as Eccles’ “percepts” within linguistic neural codes by the immaterial mind of Man. The percepts would be products by the "working of the Holy Spirit.”

 

Renewed direct interaction between the Holy Spirit and the human spirit

Both the immaterial Mind of the Holy Spirit and the immaterial mind of Man have the capacity to direct synaptic networks in the cerebral cortex and associated regions of the brain to transmit specified information within linguistic neural codes. The human mind of the God-Man Jesus Christ during His life on Earth was in an intimate communion with God the Father through His indwelling Holy Spirit. He was in full obedience to the counsel of the Spirit through His human spirit, even to death on the cross. The information that has been shared provides compelling reasons to believe from the neurosciences that the same process exists in our time through the human spirit in the mind of Man. The life, death and resurrection of Jesus Christ glorified has given a renewed direct access to the human spirit and repentant soul by the indwelling counsel of the Holy Spirit by God’s grace and boundless love.

 

Our hunger for communion

 

In Chapter Six of my second book, The Boundless Love of God: A Holy Spirit Story, entitled “Our Hunger for Communion Today,” I cite discussions by Calvin Miller who has given confirmation that the plan of God has always been to have an intimate, personal, bidirectional communion with Man. Miller stressed the importance of seeking union with the Holy Spirit in our inner being. We learn how to listen in silence for his counsel so we can grow in righteousness and in obedience by his power as mentored by the life of Jesus Christ. Miller emphasized that the holy communion of prayer is “two-way.” Meaningful communion with God through the Holy Spirit is not only a voice but also an ear. Listening is the most valuable part of prayer. Our focused silence is key to blocking out the inner and outward chatter, or noise. The Holy Spirit wants us to be open to him, and our silence is a door for him to enter into our souls. Our silence is an ear for us to hear, and we have seen the beauty within the linguistic neural codes transmitted through synaptic networks that give “voice” to his counsel.

Stan Lennard